Bottle Cap Drive for Cancer a Hoax
Bottle Cap Drive for Cancer a Hoax Save Email Print
Posted: 9:45 AM Aug 18, 2008
Last Updated: 9:45 AM Aug 18, 2008
Reporter: Associated Press
Email Address: news@wsaz.com

A | A | A

PARKERSBURG, W.Va. (AP) - A bizarre hoax has fooled residents across West Virginia who thought they were helping raise money for cancer patients.

Churches, restaurants and businesses from Wheeling to Bluefield have been collecting plastic bottle caps, fueled by flyers that claim the caps can be redeemed for money to pay for cancer treatment.

The caps, though, are worthless. Even recycling centers are rejecting them.

Aleta Brace of Parkersburg collected more than 20,000 bottle caps before learning about the hoax. She's upset, but said the response shows how West Virginians are eager to help people suffering from cancer.

Amy Berner of the West Virginia chapter of the American Cancer Society says the group is trying to discover how the hoax started.

[ Copyright 2009 – WSAZ.com. All Rights Reserved. ]
This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.
Severe Weather and Breaking News Coverage

To send a news tip or submit a story idea, e-mail news@wsaz.com

More Stories
UPDATE: Missing Teen Found Safe in Cabell County

Fed Ex Truck Gets Stuck in Huntington Viaduct

Columbus Children's Hospital to Open Center in Ironton

Traffic Stop Leads to Six Arrests

Jack Whittaker's Daughter Found Dead

Local Company Expanding, Adding 30 Jobs

Ky. Congressmen, Federal Courthouses Receive Threatening Letters

Grayson Raises More than $600,000 in Potential Senate Bid

Post Your Comments
First Name:
Location:
Enter Comments: characters left
Email (optional):
By posting this comment I have read and agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy:
You must agree to the Terms of Service to continue.
Read Comments
Comments are posted from viewers like you and do not always reflect the views of this station.
Posted by: kitten on Jul 4, 2009 at 07:55 AM
i saved a ton of thoses well not really a ton as in pound wise but you know what i mean lol and found it to be a hoaxafter o gave them to my friend who was told they were for cancer. now ive started saving them again but for craft reasons.you can use then to do touch up paint jobs . just put a lil paint in the lid when paintind lil crafts at bible school or ceramics, at holidays gle cotton on them for santas hat or beard.im gonna use them as a foundation to start a small house, glued together with hot glue. so if ant of you still have them dont fret it was the though that counted not make gifts and give them awaynonthing better then being creative.

Posted by: ashley on May 11, 2009 at 12:55 PM
the bath county schools have just started collecting my younger sister and i have tryed to get everyone involed to tell you the truth i have swiched to buying most of everything in bottles because of this. if this is truly a hoax, it is very sad that someone would go to the level of hurting people such as the cancer patients that have already endured so much..

Posted by: Scott on Apr 30, 2009 at 08:35 AM
I am currently involved with recycling caps and everything I've searched for is comin back as a hoax. I did however find a copany that will recycle the bottle caps to be used as packaging for thier line of beauty products. The company name is AVEDA and here is the link... http://aveda.aveda.com/aboutaveda/caps.asp Please, if anyone has caps that they've collected, go to this site!!! AVEDA will send you packaging slips to allow you to send the caps to them free of charge. Just in case you didn't know, bottle caps are not currently being recycled by ANY recycling centers across the country. They are made of a different kind of plastic that the bottles. So again, check out the AVEDA site and keeps those caps out of the landfills!!!

Posted by: Ashlea on Apr 13, 2009 at 05:50 PM
I learned of this bottle cap drive from my 17 yr old sister in H.S. we have her whole school and many companies through outthe Las Vegas, NV area saving bottle caps. Is this really true? Should I not save any more bottle caps? If you really wanna help some one please save all your soda can tabs from your soda cans and donate them to you local Ronald Mc Donald House Charities. I have been saving them for my 13 yr old cousin who was hit by a speeding driver and has used the Ronald McDonald House for help with his surgeries. If you would like to help someone do this... If you are unsure about what I am saying please go online and contact your local Ronald McDonald House to get all the information yu need! thank you!

Posted by: Theresa on Mar 8, 2009 at 03:20 PM
I have been saving them as well and that is why I dont like to do things like someone always reunions for some one who needs something......Not Again

Posted by: kathy on Feb 8, 2009 at 08:26 PM
someone just told me about this . I have my sister inlaw going through kemo for lung cancer.she never smoked.. now i was gonna collect the caps . so is it true they are no good..please if someone can reply to my email i appericate it . cause i will do something else to help cancer patients

Posted by: amber on Oct 15, 2008 at 11:33 PM
it is so embarrasing to have to tell my friends and my community that this is all a hoax after spending so much time puting up boxes around the school and trying to get everyone involved. however this does show how everyone is willing to help someone in need.

Posted by: sarah on Oct 13, 2008 at 07:09 PM
my mom told me about the cap drive so i had been collecting through friends and where i work i was sadden to find out that it was a hoax but its good to see just how many people are willing to help if only there was something simple we could do that would REALLY HELP.

Posted by: Ali on Oct 8, 2008 at 09:34 PM
A few days ago my RA in my hall at college started up a bottle cap collection and all the girls in the hall are chipping. I was skeptical so I decided to look up information on it. I'm saddened to learn this is all just a hoax. I just lost my aunt to breast cancer a week ago and I thought this was a good sign for me to do something to make a difference. I know there's other things I can do. It's just...painful to know this is all just a joke to someone.

Posted by: A Mad MoM on Oct 6, 2008 at 07:48 AM
my daughter has been collecting bottle caps threw the summer... and we are in ky? this is a cruel joke.. my nephew died of cancer 10 years ago. and he was only 13years old... we know what cancer can do to a love one...

Posted by: Kristi Dunigan on Sep 30, 2008 at 11:26 AM
Here at Matinsville High School there are several clubs here that are collecting bottle caps. Who ever started this they are very crule. These clubs could be putting there efforts on something else. Our clubs here take this very seriuos, because all we want to do is help out the childern who are sick with cancer.

Posted by: Mariah on Sep 19, 2008 at 01:46 PM
Yes, this is a sad and hope depleting thing to do to people, but I would really like to know WHY DOES SOMEONE HAVE TO HAVE CANCER OR NEED DIALYSIS FOR US TO HELP? ISN'T EARTH'S CANCEROUS LEGIONS ENOUGH TO GET PEOPLE TO RECYCLE? IF YOU ARE CONCERNED ABOUT THE WELFARE OF PEOPLE AND YOUR CHILDREN, TRY SAVING THE LIFE OF OUR HOME SO THAT THEY MAY HAVE A HEALTHIER EARTH IN WHICH TO LIVE. Many states have recycling services in which people separate their recyclables from their trash in to different containers, these containers are put out each week right next to your trash cans and picked up just the same but by different trucks. This reduces the amount of landfill and recycles paper, aluminum, plastic, and glass which saves the earth and will help to purify the environment in which we live that is responsible for much of the cancer in the first place. It may be an expensive program to start but I should think that a portion of the recycled goods should be enough to maintain it afterwards.

Posted by: Darin on Sep 17, 2008 at 06:43 PM
From my research, the recycling centers reject the cap not because it's not the "right" kind of plastic (it's PET just like the bottles) but because of the liner (look for a translucent blue film inside the cap) most of them have. This liner is PVC, and apparently just a tiny bit of PVC will ruin an entire batch of the "soup" ("soup" is their term for the in-process batch of recycled PET plastic.) One source said that if a recycler receives a bottle with the cap on it they don't even waste time unscrewing the cap but have a process whereby the entire top of the bottle is sawed off, wasting even more plastic, so whatever you do separate the caps from the bottles if you're going to recycle!

Posted by: Crystal on Aug 28, 2008 at 10:32 AM
A guy in Northern KY says that a friend of his received free treatments as a result, but I don't know how they turned them in.

Posted by: Anonymous2 on Aug 24, 2008 at 05:32 PM
It's a shame that someone started this and it isn't true. We've been saving them for months and turned them in at an auction we go to (which is where we heard the idea) Like some of the other commenters on here, I think the recycling centers should go ahead and accept them for what we've been collecting them for...

Posted by: Donna on Aug 23, 2008 at 06:17 PM
I think it's a shame that people will lower themselves to this kind of scam. It is serious, and if they catch the person responsible, they should get jail time.

Posted by: CrackerJack on Aug 20, 2008 at 03:04 PM
That is one reason why me and my family only give donations to the Huntington City Mission.

Posted by: Tonya on Aug 19, 2008 at 10:01 PM
This is in response to Kayla your congergation at church will just be proud that you are willing to help people in need. It is not like you did this for your own selfish reasons. I think you should still be proud of your self and know that God sees your heart and if you were doing it for the right reason that is all that matters... Your reward will come in the end... Keep an open mind to be able to help people in need and you will go far in life.

Posted by: Dialysis - on Aug 19, 2008 at 09:02 PM
People, the dialysis story is just a hoax too. Google it and you'll see it's an e-mail forward that's been going around for years - there are no organizations that donate medical treatment in return for plastic bottle cap donations. The pop can tab thing WAS a popular hoax as well, until the Ronald McDonald house graciously stepped in and started accepting them.

Posted by: Kristin on Aug 19, 2008 at 08:39 PM
my grand parents used to save bottle caps and use them as checker board pieces. Lets everyone get together and play checkers!

Posted by: Kayla Suiter on Aug 19, 2008 at 08:13 PM
I am a junior from Chesapeake High School, and I have had my church, family, hotels, restaurants, the Veterans Memorial Field House, and even the PEPSI company involved! Do you know how embarassing it is to go to my church and tell the whole sanctuary that this whole thing, what we've been working, and praying for all summer long is a hoax?? This is ridiculous, and whoever started it, needs to be fined! They need to be punished in some form. Just today, I brought at least 8,000 bottle caps to school, not including the ones that I've been bringing the rest of the school year, and the ones that the PEPSI company is going to be bringing very soon to my friends Pizza Hut. This is ridiculous. I am glad to see the way people come together to help others, but this is plain out stupid. People need to get a life, and if their life is starting rumors, they need some serious help!Luckily, the caps aren't going to waste, our art class is going to paint them and make a mural in the art room

Posted by: Beth Ann on Aug 19, 2008 at 07:36 PM
Thank you Tony for the info.

Posted by: anon on Aug 19, 2008 at 10:40 AM
this is why i dont give money to anymore. unless i know it is going to the "cause" for sure i dont and wont give anything.how sad...

Posted by: Tony on Aug 18, 2008 at 11:56 PM
http://www.rmhc.org/giving/ways-to-help Many Ronald McDonald Houses work with local recycling centers to raise money by collecting tabs from aluminum cans. Ronald McDonald Houses collect pop tabs instead of entire aluminum cans because the tabs are pure high-quality aluminum, unlike cans, which consist of aluminum and other alloys. Tabs are also easier to store than whole cans. If your local Ronald McDonald House participates in the program, it’s likely cardboard collection containers in the shape of a house have been distributed to schools, community and civic groups and other organizations in your area, as well as at the Ronald McDonald House, local McDonald’s restaurants, local banks and grocery stores. You can collect pop tabs to donate to your House. After the tabs are collected, the local RMHC Chapter brings the collection to local recycling centers, where they are weighed to determine their value. One pound of tabs is worth 57 cents, and one gallon of pop tabs (4,175 tabs) is worth $1.49. The recycling center then sends the local RMHC Chapter or House a check for the total value. To date, more than 400 million pop tabs have been collected, generating more than $4 million.

Posted by: Candy on Aug 18, 2008 at 11:27 PM
Yeah I am like other people on here. How can the recycling company reject these lids? I mean they are plastic... or is this just a hoax so people will start throwing them away because they have collected so many and raised so much money for alot of people that they dont want to help anyone else. And then after people start throwing them away they start saying collect them once again. IDK but I am going to keep savin them I dont know about anyone else. I know I went out this morning to the doctor and you wouldnt beleive the bags people has throwed out of there vehicle and the plastic lids everywhere on the road. I mean people was gettin out and pickin up garbage just to get these lids to help cancer patients. Come on the recycling plant can not reject these lids there is no way!

Posted by: jaclyn chapman on Aug 18, 2008 at 11:07 PM
does anyone have any info about the girl in williamson collecting them for dialysis? My sister has A LOT of caps she can give to them. Please email me any info you can give. It would be greatly appreciated.

Posted by: trav on Aug 18, 2008 at 10:25 PM
Lets all go green and throw them away and bury them underneath the green grass and the green trees to make a big pile of junk and replant green grass and green trees and think it has all gone away. Out of sight out of mind!! The world is an enclosed environment and it is screwed!!

Posted by: Anonymous on Aug 18, 2008 at 10:20 PM
My neighbor was just telling me about saving the bottle caps for one of her co-workers. Somebody in her family had cancer and they were doing the same thing. This was in Charleston. Really sad. Somebody already sick and worrying about bills and they hear something like this and thinking it was going to help their family so everyone bands together to help somebody out only to find out their efforts were in vain. But you know what, they probably do it again if they thought it was going to help out somebody in need.

Posted by: just me on Aug 18, 2008 at 10:02 PM
I have a friend who collected these at work, tirelessly. She hauled bag after bag home each nite because she thought she was helping a child. Se has been collecting them for about six months. Now what will she do with them? Thousands and thousands of caps going into the landfill? Does anyone hae any idea where she can get them recycled? Such a waste. Not of her time or effort, I'm sure she would gladly do it again!! but a waste of hope for so many people who thought they were helping a child to heal.......

Posted by: mo joe on Aug 18, 2008 at 09:31 PM
a young girl in the Williamson area is collecting bottle caps to use for dialysis

Posted by: Rob on Aug 18, 2008 at 09:05 PM
I would still like to know why they can't be recycled.....are they just more fodder for the landfills? All these complaints about plastic bottles and such and the recycling centers won't accept these lids? We need to know why!

Posted by: Jane on Aug 18, 2008 at 05:49 PM
Why would people fall for an urban myth like this without further researching it? This has not only wasted people's time, but also done nothing to help cancer.

Posted by: Beth Ann on Aug 18, 2008 at 05:03 PM
What about pop can tabs? are they for real. I hate hearing how someone can be so cruel and lie about something like this.

Posted by: no name on Aug 18, 2008 at 04:39 PM
that a shame people will do things like that. make up stuff. and then people find out the hard way that they can't help. what is this world coming too??

Posted by: employees on Aug 18, 2008 at 04:26 PM
Our office has been saving these caps as well as having everyone that we know save them. We think it is a shame that someone would start a rumor like this. We were told that they were for a small child to receive free cancer treatments. We think whoever started this rumor should be very ashamed of themself.

Posted by: JC on Aug 18, 2008 at 04:19 PM
This is ridiculous. Since everyone did attempt to collect these caps, some nice company ought to go ahead and honor this. It would be a tax write-off and would be helping out.

Posted by: Anonymous on Aug 18, 2008 at 04:12 PM
Interesting. This is going around in Eastern Kentucky, but not for cancer. It's being told that a boy can receive a free minute of dialysis for each bottle cap he gets.

Posted by: cory on Aug 18, 2008 at 03:53 PM
we live in ohio and have been collecting bottle caps for the same thing how do we find out info

Posted by: Kathy S on Aug 18, 2008 at 03:26 PM
probably started on the internet in fact I think someone sent me one of those pass along thingies a few years ago about saving them only it was for some supposed child with cancer in another area I checked up on the web - there's several sites that will tell you whether these "requests" are valid or not so you need to check before you believe any of these so-called "pleas for help" that get sent along from one person to another via email Some people who start these things are capable of anything, even making us children with cancer or other disease to collect money etc Beware! Most of them ARE scams and then when VALID drives or collections for REAL people come along, people are wary of helping THEM. THAT is really sad

Posted by: donater on Aug 18, 2008 at 03:09 PM
Bottle caps don't work, but can tabs do.

Posted by: crystal on Aug 18, 2008 at 02:53 PM
Yup, it figures..... It was too nice to be true!!

Posted by: Eric on Aug 18, 2008 at 02:08 PM
I know how it got started...a greedy person saw an opportunity to collect on Coke Rewards points, Pepsi stuff and all the other promotions soft drink manufacturers do. This is as shameful as someone parking in a handicapped space and I hope karma pays them back in a big way!

Posted by: me on Aug 18, 2008 at 01:48 PM
i was on the putnam county fair this year. There was 3 or 4 kids were going around collecting the bottle caps and said that they were for a cancer patient. i wondered if it was really true or not.

Posted by: Christa on Aug 18, 2008 at 01:23 PM
At Putnam Co Fair this year they collected them for a boy that had cancer and for every 1000 collected the boy received a free treatment.

Posted by: concerned citizen on Aug 18, 2008 at 01:17 PM
I am very upset about this hoax. I have people helping to save these "so called" bottle caps. This a very sick hoax. Here we all think that we were helping and we are wasting our time.

Posted by: J on Aug 18, 2008 at 12:31 PM
My baby's daycare in Nitro has been saving bottle caps, so we have all our friends and family saving also because someone needed dialysis, so I guess this one is a hoax too.

Posted by: angie on Aug 18, 2008 at 12:29 PM
i think it take a low down dirty rat to do this to people, my husband has a rare cancer called Merkel Cell Carcinoma , its deadly. i myself have collected caps in ohio to help kids with treatment, i think whoever started this should be tghrowed in jail for years

Posted by: Anonymous on Aug 18, 2008 at 10:33 AM
OMG! We have a TON of those dumb things and its all a lie! Cute!

Posted by: Pablo on Aug 18, 2008 at 10:29 AM
You wouldn't believe how much "stuff" out there is a hoax or simply not true. Type in "Urban Legends" in a search engine on your computer and read about all the untrue things we've thought were true for years, i.e., alligators in the sewers of New York, Dept. of Natural Resources dropping rattlesnakes out of helicoptors (to eat turkey eggs) and even the old saying about cutting hair will make it come back in thicker. All untrue.

Posted by: Vicky on Aug 18, 2008 at 10:12 AM
Well I and my teenage Son have been saving these caps as well,, guess we will throw them away now that I know its all a lie. why would someone do such a thing?

Posted by: Rob on Aug 18, 2008 at 10:10 AM
Even recycling centers are rejecting them??? They stress on us to recycle to save the environment and the recycling centers are rejecting them??????????????????????????????

PHONE IN YOUR YELLS TO: 1-866-616-5354
The Yell: Comments for the Week of 7/5
  • Posted By: to food for thoughti think you have solved the mystery on m.t.r.obama pay back of the unions.lets see if the so called news investigates this theory.but aren,t news media union too.wont hear any thing from them.left up to the peons and peasants to bring up truth ful news.
  • Posted By: KeithAnon. it would seem Big Earl is sick of you too. And Food for Thought, great comment, Cecil Roberts is a joke and a sorry excuse for a labor leader he seems to as big a dunce as his buddy Obama. Look at the union under him and figure it out. So hows the hope and change working for everyone? Another half million jobs lost in June. Trace it back folks, the economy went belly up when it bacame apparent the democrat party was going to nominate a radical, ignorant, inexperienced marxist to their ticket. Economists tell us that full employment is considered at an unemployment rate of 4.7%, a year ago unemployment was at 5%. But you all know, Bush was soooo stupid. Look at how the war in Iraq turned out...ooops can't use that one, look at how great the economy is now...oops, can't use that one...well everybody hated us when Bush was in office and now everybody just loooves us and helps us out in the world, well, oops, look at N. Korea, Iran, can't use that one. Some of you really got fooled.
  • Posted By: Bob & MegWhat I want to know is how many times does the water company have to be notified that water is coming up from the street on East Gardner Ave. in Belle? Bugs are getting bad and sometimes it has a sewer smell to it. Get on the ball WVAWC!
  • Posted By: politically correct againdo video on left wing coal protesters,tea party ,a grudgeing few sentences.i wrote a longer anynallyse,but i dont see it,it must have been too much truth for liberal left wing so called reporting.but we do have some truth seeker else where,they,re catching on.....
  • Posted By: jescoWhat a disappointment the Ashland Summer Motion was for our children. No focus on the children whatsoever...........The hospitals were the main focus along with the motorcycle show..... very little for the children to enjoy. HUGE DISAPPOINTMENT!!!!
  • Posted By: Ben ChambersYOUR DECISION TO SHOW MJ FUNERAL IN PLACE OF DAYS IS VERY POOR AND NOT WELL THOUGHT OUT. YOU SHOULD BE ASHAME. MAYBE A NEW PROGRAM DIRECTOR IS IN ORDER.
  • Posted By: RE: Worm in Water If you will Google "hair worm", you will be given millions of pages of information concerning the hair worm. There used to be a myth that a horse hair put in water would turn into a worm. From experience, it doesn't work.
  • Posted By: food for thoughtWSAZ I ask of you please do a a follow up story of the 6 weeks of rain that we had so some of these people who have forgotten will have some miniscule sense of thereselves to know that ALL THAT RAIN would cause flooding anywhere. Here is another story. Find UMWA president MR. Roberts and ask him why he hasn't come out and had his brothers and sisters to be involved in keeping there MTR jobs.All these people that say Massey is a Union breaking company should be worried in salvaging the jobs they do have. It's not rocket science, UMWA supports Obama, in return Obama may reward them. This may be from left field but believe I am on to something. Isn't it strange the protesters only target Massey. Most of them are led to believe there are NO union jobs in WV. HOW STRANGE!? Here is the hunch I have WV politicians don't like Don B and the Union supports Obama. So sounds like a money trail to me for the hippies. Just a thought, but makes for good reporting. Big Earl lets make the idea reality!
  • Posted By: To Fat EarlYou're losing! Ha,Ha!
  • Posted By: DianeBuck, I agree. When it comes to kids playing sports (not just in the summer), the parents are CRAZY! They just need to "cut the cord" and allow their children, the refs, and coaches worry about the games. Now if you have a parent who is a coach just watch out...that is a double wammy!
  • Posted By: jbugi saw on the news this morning obama is in russia and he took the family,people are upset about gov of south carolinia takeing a trip on taxpayers money,witch he agreed to payback, is obama going to pay for his familys plane tickets,hotel bill,food and entertainment or will it us taxpayers.....
  • Posted By: I for one am sick and tired of reading the same bs that big earl keeps spewing out. All you ever hear is peta, tree huggers, hippies. People who made a difference in this world and who are smart enough to care, should be honored instead of being bashed by some people who have the mentality of the monkeys who they believed they evolved from. also big earl keep on believing that your idol, who you worship and adore so much is smarter than a nasa scientist, apparently you haven't been around any smart people.
  • Posted By: bias obiousif anyone has had a dought about left wing liberal news bias,heres a glaring clue.anti coal party,news,with video.tea party,productive people concerned with socialism,taxed into poverty,a czar run government,etc,no video ,a disintrested report,yawn,yawn,yawn.thankfully we now have an alternative to this liberal bias with conservative talk radio,internet news ,alternate t.v. etc.there is a good article on world net daily about the vietnam war.hollywood was running the war then too.
  • Posted By: buckwhy is it w/ summer sports it seems the parents make it all about them instead of the kids. am i wrong or do alot of these parents seem to want to relive life again through the kids. or even worse make a claim to being so good at whatever the sport the parent did that they push the kid all because of what they did 'or never did'. These parents also seem to be the really high ego type person. funny thing is if the parent was so good then why arent they pro or at least a great college player. what i have noticed is the the kids w/ the parent who did play college or was on the verge of being pro does not press the issue. they allow the kids to play ball. just my opinion
  • Posted By: Big EarlWell hello again good working coal people of WV this is Big Earl and I hope everyone had a nice holiday wouldn’t it be nice if we could have a holiday or one of them permenant vacations from all the tree hugger types and hippies that are barging into our communities uninvited tying to run all our jobs off. Well good people I am calling on those who have the means to do so and you know who you are so lets pony up some cash and have our own protest here in the coal fields to support our coal miners. I seen on this very TV station where the tree huggers held a rally and a cookout with a bunch of Grateful Dead hippie wanttobees singing about the trees and polar bears but we can do one better. We can have it down at the coal festival in Madison people I say invite some real singers who aint got above there raisin like WV adopted son Mr. Charlie Daniels and how about Alabama since they have coal down there to. Invite Gov. Joe and them people from Washington DC that is a good way to find out who is pretending to be a friend of coal and who is really on our side. We could even make Mother Jones bobblehead dolls to give away I for one would like to see her set loose on these tree huggers that have invaded Cabin Creek trying to run off her beloved coal miners. You could pull a string and she would say #** !!##**!! Tree huggers.
SearchKOW Business of the Day
WSAZ.com Sponsor Sections & Links
Healthy Tri-State
Live a healthier lifestyle in 2009
SOMC
Very good things are happening here
Moms4Moms
By moms, for moms
WV Lottery
Nightly drawings and numbers
Big Sandy
For all your furniture and appliance needs