UPDATE: Huntington Mayor Felinton, Wife Cleared in Domestic Call Case
UPDATE: Huntington Mayor Felinton, Wife Cleared in Domestic Call Case Save Email Print
Posted: 12:46 PM Sep 17, 2008
 Last Updated: 5:09 AM Sep 18, 2008
 Reporter: Melanie Chapman; Dave Benton
Email Address: melanie.chapman@wsaz.com; dave.benton@wsaz.com
286 comments Photos
A | A | A

UPDATE @ 4:15 Wednesday
The Huntington police department will not pursue charges against Huntington Mayor David Felinton and his wife, who were involved in a domestic call at his home Sunday morning.

Huntington Police Captain Steve Hall said Bethany Felinton, the mayor's wife, admitted to embellishing the story with police and 911.

"She lied if you will," Captain Steve Hall said. "Because she was just flat mad at her husband and wanted to see him in trouble."

Police Chief Skip Holbrook said there were no visible signs of injury on either Mr. or Mrs. Felinton. Holbrook said there were signs both consumed alcohol, but neither appeared to be impaired.

Hall said the police won't charge Mrs. Felinton for making the false call Sunday morning. Hall said it would set a dangerous precedent for the police department.

"It would have a chilling effect. It would deter anyone from reporting a domestic incident," Captain Hall said.

Chief Skip Holbrook applauded the work of his department in the case.

"The way we approached this from the beginning is to be professional, ethical and consistent with how we handle any domestic situation," Skip Holbrook said.

UPDATE @ 12:10 Wednesday
HUNTINGTON, W.Va. (WSAZ) -- The Huntington Police Department has announced a news conference for 4pm Wednesday to announce the findings of the investigation into the domestic disturbance at the mayor's home.

UPDATE @ 5:22pm
HUNTINGTON, W.Va. (WSAZ) -- WSAZ obtained a copy of the 911 call made by Bethany Felinton early Sunday morning. Mrs. Felinton tells 911 dispatchers that her husband, Huntington Mayor David Felinton, was trying "to jump into me and my mother."

Mrs. Felinton claims on the call that Mr. Felinton tried to slam her head into a brick wall.

Monday, in an interview with WSAZ's Dave Benton, Mrs. Felinton said she is sorry for misusing 911 and that what she said on the 911 call was not true.

"He has never given me a reason or inkling to have any kind of fear," Bethany Felinton said of her husband. "He's a very loyal, very gentle man."

Mrs. Felinton admits her marriage is not perfect, but says she thinks this incident will help them grow stronger.

Mrs. Felinton said a stressful situation at home with her children and family contributed to the incident Sunday morning.

Huntington officers did not arrest anyone at the home after an hour and a half on the scene.

WSAZ obtained the 911 recording from a third party source. A Freedom of Information Act request to 911was denied on the reasoning that police are still investigating the matter. Huntington Police Chief Skip Holbrook confirmed to WSAZ.com Monday afternoon that the investigation continues.

911 Call Transcript

The following is a transcipt of Bethany Felinton's call to 911.

Dispatch: 911

Bethany Felinton: I need uh a domestic at (address withheld).

Dispatch: What’s going on?

Bethany Felinton: Mayor Felinton has lost his mind. He is jumping into my mother and me.

Dispatch: Where’s he at?

Bethany Felinton: (address withheld).

Dispatch: Where’s he at?

Bethany Felinton: He’s right here. He just tried to slam my head up against a brick wall.

Dispatch: What is your name?

Bethany Felinton: Bethany, I’m his wife.

Dispatch: Huh?

Bethany Felinton: I’m his wife.

Dispatch: And what was your first name?...Ma’am?

Original Story, Sunday September 15th

HUNTINGTON, W.Va. (WSAZ) -- Huntington Mayor David Felinton held a news conference to explain a domestic disturbance that happened at his home early Sunday morning.

Huntington officers responded to the Felinton home after the mayor's wife, Bethany, called 911 around 12:45 a.m.

When officers arrived, the mayor was standing on the sidewalk and his wife was on the porch, according to a police report. Police found a broken wine glass on the front porch and personal items thrown across the front yard and sidewalk.

Neither was injured, and no one was arrested in the incident.

Mayor Felinton said it all resulted from a misunderstanding due to his wife's stressful situation.

Bethany Felinton asked for forgiveness from emergency workers for her "misuse of the critical resources" that are provided to the community.

Mayor Felinton would not elaborate on what started the argument, other than to say it was due to stress in their relationship. The mayor said the couple will seek counseling.

Police have never been called to the Felinton home before.

Mayor Felinton said police followed proper protocol and did not treat him any differently than any other member of the public.

Keep clicking on WSAZ.com for more information.
Click Pictures to Enlarge
More Stories
UPDATE: Woman Killed in Interstate 77 Crash, Name Released

Suspect Charged in Huntington Murder

Huntington City Council Preps for Next Mayor

EPA Touts $1.9 Billion Gain for W.Va.

 Former Local Doctor, Daughter Killed in Crash

W.Va. Ethics Panel OKs Retirement Gifts, Awards

Workers Vote to Start Strike Process in Scioto County School District

Bridges Reportedly Icing Over in Kanawha, Multiple Wrecks Across County
Post Your Comments
First Name:
Location:
Enter Comments: characters left
Email (optional):
Email will not be displayed on site. For station contact purpose only.
Read Comments
Comments are posted from viewers like you and do not always reflect the views of this station.
Posted by: Scott on Sep 24, 2008 at 01:38 AM
I support Mayor Felinton. However, WSAZ will not display any of my comments on this subject. What did he do? Refuse an interview at one time. Please be fair!
Posted by: M on Sep 21, 2008 at 09:17 AM
Apparently no ones reads the actual story here. There were no arrests made because there was no actual PHYSICAL EVIDENCE of domestic battery. An officer cannot make an arrest on something when the victim recants her story and there is no evidence to prove contrary. If she refuses to file charges and there is no evidence to show that she was assaulted, then they CANNOT prove that a crime was actually comitted. Whatever the reason was that she called, there was nothing proving that it happened. Until she is ready to press charges and file a report, then the officers can do nothing without evidence. Those laws were put there to protect EVERYONE, not just the mayor or anyone else of some political significance. And to address the issue of why "part of the 911 tape was missing", well, it wasn't. She hung up on the dispatcher before they could tell her that officers would be sent. You can't make someone stay on the phone with you. There are no holes. That's it.
Posted by: Dee Smith on Sep 20, 2008 at 04:42 AM
I find it funny that neither mayor or wife went to jail considering in most cases of domestic disturbances at least one of the party goes to jail. Tha mayor isn't above anyone else when it comes to slapping a woman. She's still with him, apparantly he didn't slam her head against the wall hard enough.
Posted by: Smitty on Sep 20, 2008 at 04:34 AM
Perhaps he told her about future plans for another tax increase and she slapped him.
Posted by: Hmmm on Sep 19, 2008 at 09:23 PM
Why would she call her husband 'Mayor Felinton' instead of my husband or David? Where is the rest of the 911 call where they say officers are on their way, etc? There are lots of holes in this one.
Posted by: Larry Dixon on Sep 19, 2008 at 08:40 AM
I have smoked some a lot of poles in my life but I have never seen hogwash like this. Thad is my lover and alway will be but this is crazy that they are going to sweep this under the rug like it never happened. I will bite my pillow hard tonight. Just like I always bite my pillow when he is around.
Posted by: sad on Sep 18, 2008 at 11:44 PM
whats really sad is there is almost as many comments over this unimportant story than there were about the young mother that the thug boyfriend gunned down in the taco bell...wheres your priopities?
Posted by: Anonymous on Sep 18, 2008 at 11:37 PM
i think most of these post are to stir the pot ,so to speak.that way wolfe will get it for mayor,could this be?sort of dirty playing,but isnt that politics as usual?hope the mayor and his wife are doing ok,
Posted by: cnb on Sep 18, 2008 at 11:32 PM
To Anonymous on Sept 17. Evidently you care you're reading it every day!
Posted by: Anonymous on Sep 18, 2008 at 11:00 PM
A person don't just call the police and say someone tried to slam their head up against a brick wall unless it really did happen. WAKE UP PEOPLE....next time it might be worse....
Posted by: Randy Durham on Sep 18, 2008 at 10:28 PM
I can relate to Bethany Felinton. I can see her covering for him-I see it in her eyes. He has convinced her that it will ruin them financially if he loses the election. Being an openly gay man, I was once involved with an abusive life partner. Smitty would threaten and hurt me verbally, and I would call 911 when things got bad, but he convinced me to recant my story each time he hurt me. I still love Smitty. He is beautiful black man, who is stong and proud.
Posted by: kathy on Sep 18, 2008 at 10:24 PM
He's up for Election isn't he. Let's see if he gets voted IN. Will this cost his re-election. If So how long until the ole song OUR DIVORCE WAS FINAL TODAY. The Fake 911 call SHE MADE could cost a HIS re-election.
Posted by: LarryDixon on Sep 18, 2008 at 05:54 PM
Being gay is nothing to be ashamed of Randal W. I have been openly gay since my teens and I also have a life partner Thad. If that was me or my partner then we would have been jailed for weeks!!!
Posted by: M on Sep 18, 2008 at 04:05 PM
There are plenty of "upstanding" citizens that abuse 911 every single day. There are people that call 911 needing 411 instead and actually ask for the time of day. People lie to 911 and officers every single day. 99.99% are not arrested or charged with false reporting. The only ones that are charged are for making a false police report (which means they actually made a police report, not just that officers showed up at their house) or excessive false 911 calls. I can only recall of a very few (maybe 2 or 3) that have been arrested for making false calls and they were excessive (every day and several times a day) callers. Why should she be prosecuted when there are many others who are a nuisance to the law enforcement field. Those who call in false domestics because they are arguing over their kids (for the 4th time this week!) or the many people that call in on a 911 line because a car is parked on the street in front of their house. Seriously people, get some perspective!!!
Posted by: amy on Sep 18, 2008 at 02:57 PM
i think she should be prosecuted for lying--anyone else would--but i guess thats how it works when you have money.
Posted by: cloud on Sep 18, 2008 at 02:14 PM
http://www.policedomesticviolence.com Wives of powerful people recant all the time.
Posted by: UNREAL on Sep 18, 2008 at 01:41 PM
I HAVE BEEN A COP FOR 10 YEARS AND SEEN A LOT OF THIS... FOR THE DA THERE AND THE PD NOT TO ARREST ONE OR THE OTHER IS WRONG.... TOTALY WRONG.
Posted by: charleston on Sep 18, 2008 at 01:40 PM
who cares? big hairy deal!!!!
Posted by: Barb on Sep 18, 2008 at 01:19 PM
This story has so many holes in it to me. If this woman was this distraught at the time of this call and none of this was real, then maybe her husband would care enought to help her seek someone to talk to. If this situation did happen(and I believe there is some truth to it) then maybe he mayor is someone who is using scare tactics and bullying people and needs help....this should not be overlooked. Also, can anyone call 911 and make up a story? hhhmmm, I don't think so!
Posted by: Anonymous on Sep 18, 2008 at 01:05 PM
YOU GUYS ARE RIGHT. COUPLES ARGUE, BUT THEY DON'T CALL THE COPS ASKING FOR HELP. DON'T BECOME A MAYOR IF YOU DON'T WANT YOUR BUSINESS OUT IN THE OPEN. THATS WHY HE CALLED FOR THE PRESS CONFERENCE. HE KNEW THAT EVERYONE WOULD KNOW ABOUT IT. I THINK ITS FUNNY BECAUSE HE IS A JERK. VOTE WOLFE!
Posted by: Anonymous on Sep 18, 2008 at 11:26 AM
They don't always take ppl to jail for a domestic call...the police check out the situatuion first to see if anyone is actually in any danger. And if everthing checks out ok & the parties involved don't want to press charges, the police have no reason to take anyone to jail....I know form personal experience...k...thx!
Posted by: rachel on Sep 18, 2008 at 11:21 AM
wow look at the picture at the top it looks like shes on some kind of drug we dont need a mayor like that come on huntington we need a new one!!!!!!!!!!!!
Posted by: Billy on Sep 18, 2008 at 10:49 AM
No one is forcing you to read this kygal. I think we have a right to know if we have a mayor who cannot even control his own home, let alone a city.
Posted by: Sue on Sep 18, 2008 at 10:16 AM
To Anonymous on Sep 17, 2008 at 11:31 PM: Ummm, no I have never had a boyfriend try to slam my head up against a brick wall. Arguments happen but there is no excuse for violence. Maybe she wasn't arrested because there is something to her claim. In other words, she really wasn't misusing 911.
Posted by: Anonymous on Sep 18, 2008 at 10:07 AM
So since she lied..... and called 911....isn't that grounds for some sort of charge. I am going to keep a copy of this story so if I ever get in trouble with the law in Huntington, I can get out of it .... just by showing them this. No wonder we have a higher crime rate per capita than NYC or LA. SAD SAD Huntington. It's all about who ya know. If this had been any other couple....some one would be in jail. HPD wake up!!!!!
Posted by: Anonymous on Sep 18, 2008 at 10:06 AM
NEED A NEW MAYOR, NEW POLICE CHIEF
Posted by: Randal on Sep 18, 2008 at 09:55 AM
This is a complete waste of media time and a distraction for the mayor. It doesn't bother me as a taxpayer that the mayor occasionally has his squabbles. He isn't running for pope! I am openly gay, and I remember one night when my neighbors gave me and my boyfriend Smitty a hard time. The local news wanted to do a hate crime story, but it was no big deal.
Posted by: joe on Sep 18, 2008 at 09:26 AM
come on lets get real if you our i would have made that call, and was fals we would have been find and jaild. so what because shes snorkes wife she gets off.i could care less what happens in hier lives but shouldnt the law protain to every one no matter what.
Posted by: cin on Sep 18, 2008 at 09:18 AM
i say put them in the slammer with the dude that stole the rock.
Posted by: MICHELLE on Sep 18, 2008 at 09:18 AM
ID LOVE TO BE A FLY ON THE WALL IN THAT HOUSE,, OF COURSE THEY GET OFF, ANY WHITE COLLAR WILL, SOMETHING HAPPENS TO AN ORDINARY YOU OR ME THERE IS NO WAY WE WOULD GET OFF. I SURE HOPE YOU DONT PLAN RUNNING AGAIN FOR MAYOR.
Posted by: Anon from Huntington on Sep 18, 2008 at 09:15 AM
GREAT. Now can we PLEASE move on???? I don't support the Mayor. BUT I don't him or his wife personally either. Therefore, it's NONE of my business or anyone elses. You can bet one thing though, IF he had hurt her or the kids or his mom-in-law or anyone...the HPD would NOT have looked the other way because most of them don't like or support him!
Posted by: Justme on Sep 18, 2008 at 08:05 AM
I have been in a situation where I had to call 911 for this reason. No longer married to the jerk, but, I was told that when you call 911 someone goes to jail. My ex-husband did (without signs of abuse!) I guess it just depends on who you are. My ex-husband spent the night in jail, then we were not allowed to have contact with each other until the hearing. Sounds perfectly balanced (this incident happened in WV, I am now glad I live in Kentucky!). Welcome to the state of playing favorites in WV!
Posted by: Married Chick on Sep 18, 2008 at 08:04 AM
If it had been anyone else, someone would have been arrested at the scene. If I called 911 and intentionally lied, I would have and should have to face the legal music. This is a service provided for the safety of the citizens, not a mode of revenge. Shame on both of the Felingtons.
Posted by: anon on Sep 18, 2008 at 07:45 AM
I wonder if his wife was really pressured by Mr. Felinton to say she "lied" about the situation. Is this an abused wife syndrome or what?? Domestic abuse occurs in all social ranks...
Posted by: A on Sep 18, 2008 at 07:26 AM
I am married and yes I have had arguments with my spouse. The only thing is if it did happen the way the 911 tape stated then yes she would be recanting now because she is afraid of her husband. Hello he is the Mayor.
Posted by: Why on Sep 18, 2008 at 07:21 AM
If it was a person who was not the Mayor or his wife.We would be in so much trouble.Why do certain people get by with more than others.The law must be different in their book
Posted by: Anonymous on Sep 18, 2008 at 07:13 AM
wow i hope she never comes to my house since she's a SW i dont want her getting mad at me and lieing on me cause those judges take a SW's wood in court maybe now the courts will go back and take a look at the unfounded cases
Posted by: shena on Sep 18, 2008 at 12:38 AM
PLEASE LEAVE THEM ALONE ANYONE WHO IS MARRIED HAS HAD A FIGHT AND HAS BEEN STRESSED BUT THEY HAVE EVEN MORE STRESS ON THEM THEN ANYONE THINGS HAPPEN I HAVE FOUR KIDS AND IM MARRIED AND THATS STRESS IN IT'S SELF THEY ARE NORMAL PEOPLE JUST LIKE WE ARE SO LET IT BE THEY ARE ONLY HUMAN JUST LIKE THE REST OF US I STAND BE HIND THEM 100% SO DONT STICK YOUR RAKE IN SOMEONE ELSES BACKYARD UNLESS YOURS IS CLEAN
Posted by: kygal on Sep 18, 2008 at 12:37 AM
Now that there has been more than enough media coverage of this incident, can we get on with our lives and stay out of others???
Posted by: wvmom on Sep 18, 2008 at 12:23 AM
where's he at? Do the 911 dispatchers have to have at least a GED to get that job? No wonder people make fun of West Virgina. What a joke.
Posted by: Anonymous on Sep 17, 2008 at 11:55 PM
dumb story who really cares!
Posted by: cnb on Sep 17, 2008 at 11:53 PM
There's 241 comments on here and I guess there are 200 perfect marriages. I just hope none of you have to call 911 due to the stress of being a wife, mother, mother of your mother and perfect in the eyes of the community at all times. It's probably not their first fight and it won't be their last. I guess most of you don't go home after a long hard day and have a drink? Good Luck Mr. and Mrs. Felinton. We always see the bad. I still remember the night they found Leah Hickman in the crawl space, Mr. Felinton was there in the cold trying to assist with help, traffic or whatever needed to be done. Thank You Mayor!
Posted by: Anonymous on Sep 17, 2008 at 11:31 PM
People, come on, we all have had these kind of incidents in our personal life.S*%t happens. I understand they had a REAL good time at the Herd game, so what! Leave them alone and let them live their life.
Posted by: Charlie on Sep 17, 2008 at 11:16 PM
Really I feel sorry for the Mayor I can just imagine what he was having to put up with he was maybe having a drink & relaxing or trying to & his wife & mother in-law was doubling up on him hard to say what over but it doesn't matter. Think about it he was the one getting jumped but he kept his cool ,he is a good man . He was caught with alcohol on his breath & with those odds he didn't stand a chance & they knew it. He done nothing he would regret later.
Posted by: Jeni on Sep 17, 2008 at 10:29 PM
All I wanna say is who gives to craps about what the mayor and his wife were fighting about or anything else...David fellington isn't all he's cracked up to be anyway but they are normal people and u wouldn't see the news at my door step if I called the cops on my husband...GET OVER IT! ITS NOT BREAKING NEWS!
Posted by: robert on Sep 17, 2008 at 10:22 PM
wow! she should have been charged in my opinion. if that would have been me, or anyone else, they would be in trouble.
Posted by: lw on Sep 17, 2008 at 10:16 PM
This see if the Sheriff of Cabell Co or the Prosecuting Attorneys office steps investigate.The people of Cabell needs to make their voice heard on this case.Huntington Police Chief and Capt steve Hall should be BOOTED out of town for this cover up.If you have arrested for the same thing you should demand equal treatment.
Posted by: Phil on Sep 17, 2008 at 09:59 PM
the next person who gets into trouble for a false 911 call,should sue Huntington for discrimination,then they could take both dollars the city is worth!!
Posted by: Anonymous on Sep 17, 2008 at 09:51 PM
Hey people you know people with money always gets out of things. Look at OJ he even got away with MURDER so this is nothing new for the RICH.
Posted by: Justine Daly on Sep 17, 2008 at 09:39 PM
This just prove the guy who signs your pay check just gets a slap on the hand. In Huntington where drugs and killings are happen too often, lucky we didn't have something else going on in the city and had to pull our police off of a crime to go to the MAYORS HOUSE for a JOKE. Even the MAYOR shouldn't he pay some kind of a fine. THE Mayor had been drinking,that fine he was in his home, BUT what if there was a emergency that the Mayor had to be at, like a major fire like we had. Would he have gotten thrown in the Drunk tank for PUBLIC INTOX. NO HE wouldn't have if he didin't get punsihed for this 911 Call. Isn't calling 911 as a Hoax a federal Crime because of 9/11.
Posted by: NOT VOTING FOR OBOMMER!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! on Sep 17, 2008 at 09:38 PM
Tyrome, SHUTUP!!!!!!!!NOONE IN THIER RIGHT MIND WOULD VOTE FOR OBOMMER!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!TYROME SUPPORTER YOU NEED TO GET A LIFE TOO!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Posted by: Anonymous on Sep 17, 2008 at 09:33 PM
Huntington needs to get its priorities in check. This is beyond ridiculous. Don't tell me that if any of us regular citizens were to abuse the 911 system like she did we wouldn't get punished in some form or another. Huntington is such a joke. Just remember situations like this come election time and get these people out!
Posted by: Brad on Sep 17, 2008 at 09:11 PM
What a cover up! First the mayor's wife calls 911 and states the mayor attempted to assault her. The officers that showed up were scared of losing their jobs and did nothing. Secondly the wife CONFESSES on wsaz that she committed a crime and she is still not charged. Our police department and prosecutor have NO backbone. And we dont buy the lame excuse that it will deter other women from calling.. BS
Posted by: BR on Sep 17, 2008 at 08:40 PM
What a couple of clowns, the mayor and Bethany. They should take their act on the road. Bet the good people of Huntington can't wait until the next election. If he decides to run again.
Posted by: Antonio on Sep 17, 2008 at 08:34 PM
Hey Joe yes he is and he is doing nothing. The same thing he would do if he gets elected! The only difference is his pay will be higher!
Posted by: Confused on Sep 17, 2008 at 08:28 PM
Elvis, I was referencing Statute 3061 signed into effect by Gov Manchin 3/31/08 covered by WSAZ April 18, 2008. In the grand scheme of things 5 months is not a long time...
Posted by: davidcook on Sep 17, 2008 at 08:16 PM
i think it is a shame that wsaz and other local stations run this as a top story. my god, we have children starving to death, dying of terrible diseases, our soldiers are being killed in iraq and all you care to report on is this. you reporters should take a long look what is really important. you will run some of the dumbest stories at the top of the news with indept reporting then barely mention (if at all) stories on soldiers killed or other actual news.there are a lot more important things going on in this world and this area than this. i for one think the mayors domestic affairs is NOT news.....
Posted by: DD on Sep 17, 2008 at 07:44 PM
Ok, people. They were cleared. Let's move on.
Posted by: SOUTH POINT! on Sep 17, 2008 at 07:03 PM
This is such bull! If it had been anyone else that made a false report or "misused 9-11" they would be sitting in jail right now, but I guess you have to be the mayors wife to get out of it right? Just beacuse I get streesed doesn't mean I am going to call 9-11 on my husband. That's the dumbest thing I have ever heard!!! And everyone knows it!
Posted by: Anonymous on Sep 17, 2008 at 07:02 PM
I don't see original comment on here. Is it because I was stating facts about an incident that happened to me that is similar to this one that happened in Ashland and nothing was done...you know another one of those "who you know deals"
Posted by: Robin on Sep 17, 2008 at 06:56 PM
I knew a girl that misused 911 and she got arrested for it.I guess ther are different laws for the regular folks ,and different laws for the politions.That is not right .The laws should be the same for everyone no matter who they are. I think it is a crock of bs that she did not get in trouble for misusing 911.I guess it depends on who you are and how high up you are.i will not vote for him that is for sure.
Posted by: Larrydixon on Sep 17, 2008 at 06:14 PM
This is not fair!!! The police arrested me one night for smuggling bones on my front property. I have gobbled many of robs in the past but that night was crazy. Why was David F not arrested!!!
Posted by: Joe on Sep 17, 2008 at 06:11 PM
Isnt Kim Wolfe the Sheriff of Cabell County? Whats he doing over this situation?
Posted by: rachel on Sep 17, 2008 at 05:54 PM
if it was anyone else that wouldve made a false phone call or statement that person wouldve been in jail with charges!See thats why huntington is just getting pathetic because anyone that works for the city/state gets away with everything.
Posted by: rachel on Sep 17, 2008 at 05:48 PM
if hes like that we definately need a new mayor for this town!!!!!!!!!!!
Posted by: Anonymous on Sep 17, 2008 at 05:44 PM
wat a joke that city is if that was anyone else you would have got a dvp against one or the other what is the problem he is a joke as a mayor
Posted by: courtney on Sep 17, 2008 at 05:42 PM
only thing i got to say is.this is a everyday life where couples have arrugments but its just most of the time it dosnt go online or on tv.i personally dont believe that 911 would have released this call if it wasnt for him just being the mayor.theres more important things out there to be worry about than a couple getting in to a arrugment.Now days are very stressful.Give it a break.It would be differnet if she wantnt to prosocute him.i know bethany and david there very down to earth people who have stress in there every day life like everyone eles.good luck mayor and bethany.
Posted by: elvis on Sep 17, 2008 at 05:41 PM
Hey confused, where did you get your law degree or cj degree? Chis Chiles agreed with hpd duh? lets say you file report charge is dismissed, if they think you lied, or retract your statement, you go to jail for false reporting. What "new" law it's been on the books for years.
Posted by: JC on Sep 17, 2008 at 05:31 PM
Someone doesn't have to leave just because they got into an argument, especially when both people are clearly residents of the home. You can't make that decision because you have no proof that a crime was committed to intervene. They can say he smashed her head into the wall, but he may have fallen into her and they both fell and she was so mad that she felt it was like that at the time. No one knows, but people need to start having a little faith around here. I believe our cops would have arrested him if there was reason. Maybe this was just an average argument that just got blew out of proportions. Yeah, I feel that it is our business if he is breaking the law, but he didn't break the law, so don't assume the worse just because the story is "missing" information you are looking for. It must be horribly embarrassing to know everyone knows about this. Tell you one thing, I bet it won't happen again. You still got my vote Dave!
Posted by: Greg on Sep 17, 2008 at 05:11 PM
This is another situation of politics first, middle class working man second, come on a broken wine glass, clothes thrown throughout the yard. Nope nothing happened here, lets go home.
Posted by: gary on Sep 17, 2008 at 05:08 PM
help help help,,,my wife is beating me up right now my nose is bleeding she is sittin on my head,,,hurry hurry
Posted by: anonymous on Sep 17, 2008 at 05:08 PM
if it were anyone else, they would be injail right now for making a false allegation. that is unfair. and the police wouldn't spend and hour and a half at a domestic call either. usually they stay less than ten minutes and someone usually goes to jail or has to leave the premises. and during the conference they said they aren't pursuig charges because it may deter someone from reporting something....i think less people will report it now because they see nothing is being done. and now we may have more false allegations because people will think they can get away with it. i can't wait till someone else makes a false allegation..they will be in jail, but NO NOT THE MAYOR'S WIFE. i hope the next person who makes a false allegation files a suit against the police department after they are arrested. its not fair to let one person get away with something and not the other. another case of proving how dirty our cops in our city are......
Posted by: gary on Sep 17, 2008 at 05:00 PM
had that been anybody else somebody would have got run off the property for a while
Posted by: Confused on Sep 17, 2008 at 04:40 PM
How would charging someone for making a unjustified accusation have a "chilling effect"on legitimate domestic abuse calls? It would hopefully have the intended effect of preventing people from making false calls. Guess that means our police force won't be enforcing the new law to prevent false police reports. Or maybe they'll just choose not to enforce it if the Mayor's wife is involved!
Posted by: GAIL on Sep 17, 2008 at 04:32 PM
This is just great. So if I would decide to make up a story and call to report it, that I won't be punished...RIGHT. I have never hurt such a crock of bs that punishing her would deter anyone else from reporting domestic violence!! It's basically a waste of time to report anything to HPD and I'm speaking from experience.
Posted by: Tyrome on Sep 17, 2008 at 04:05 PM
All I can say is this is a sad night for Huntington politicans. Vote new! Vote Obama!
Posted by: Anonymous on Sep 17, 2008 at 03:14 PM
has any one thought to call CPS on this i would be more concerned for the kids safty in this than the adults what if one of the kids would og got hit during all this throwing or got cut on the broken wine glass or will ths be another unfounded case
Posted by: vicky on Sep 17, 2008 at 02:56 PM
just for your info. i believe one of them should have been taken of the primeses.check your stste laws!!!! one was supposed to be taken off the primes!!!! vic
Posted by: To Tyrome on Sep 17, 2008 at 02:40 PM
Tyrome? Hey, I agree with you buddy. Everyone here is down on ya, but Obama is the right man for our country. He will bring real change unlike our local politicans.
Posted by: wuz up? on Sep 17, 2008 at 02:21 PM
hey i have tried to put my 2 cents in and my comments aren't getting approved. i guess only the reporters can sling mud here.
Posted by: Sherry on Sep 17, 2008 at 02:08 PM
Well, I feel that everyone has a spat once in a while,,, and yes the police is called but that doesent factor a headline,,, just shows that he is normal like the rest of us few,, Lisa Presley was right when she release the song "Dirty Laundry",,,,
Posted by: Paula on Sep 17, 2008 at 01:58 PM
Until wsaz somehow comes across a tell all book noone will really know what happened in there home that night besides the Felintons. We should really leave it alone and let them decide whats right and wrong in there marriage, Deep down we all know if one of us had an argument with our spouse we wouldn't want it spread all over heck and back for everyone to play armchair physiologist, Mayor or not he does have a personal life - Relationships are not always smiling holding hands tiptoeing through the tulips.
Posted by: Old Professional on Sep 17, 2008 at 01:24 PM
The society of today apparently believes that “fights” and “domestic calls to 911” are normal. Is this behavior acceptable in today’s world? My husband and I were married many years. He was my best friend. We did not agree on everything but we both listened to each other and then worked on a solution. We had a partnership and respected one another. Now, it appears, “to shout and slug it out” is the norm, what a shame and waste of precious time here on earth; also, stress should never be used to explain bad behavior. For many years, I worked forty-plus hours a week, my husband worked two jobs, and we raised three children and enjoyed a home-cooked family meal every evening. It can be done without a 911 call.
Posted by: Anonymous on Sep 17, 2008 at 01:16 PM
Who Cares.... I am so tired of hearing about this.... I think it is pretty obvious she is just saying she misused the 911 system to help out her husband politically.....
Posted by: why does it matter on Sep 17, 2008 at 01:03 PM
Why is this family being put in the spot light? I know there are many people who have arguements, many who have called 911 and there not put on the news, and some of which are "well known" politics or not. that's there problems, not ours, its really none of our business. No disrespect to anyone, and sorry if i made you mad.
Posted by: Anonymous on Sep 17, 2008 at 01:01 PM
I believe she needs to be fined just like anyone else who misuses the 911 system! It isn't fair that she gets away with it because she's a "public figure" Because she's a public figure she should have thought before she dialed in the first place!
Posted by: anon on Sep 17, 2008 at 12:38 PM
I do not think it is normal either. If you have to call 911, there is a problem. My husband and I have been in a lot of arguments, but nothing to where I have to resort to 911. Domestic Violence needs to be taken more seriously. I am a democrat too. Never voted for him........ I have seen this city in a lot better shape.
Posted by: well on Sep 17, 2008 at 11:59 AM
the way is see it is this he is running for office again and he is aware that this could cause him some flack so he wants her to smooth things over smoothly as possible so it wont hurt him ya think
Posted by: Sue on Sep 17, 2008 at 11:45 AM
I am sorry, but if this were " a normal citizen" that made the 911 call, someone would have went to jail! Now,Mrs. Fellinton is saying that she "misused" 911, and that what she said to the dispatcher wasn't true! Maybe the Mayor should pay "out of his pocket" for the time and gasoline the taxpayers had to pay for the officers to go on a FALSE CALL!!!!
Posted by: ED on Sep 17, 2008 at 11:38 AM
Give it a REST
Posted by: Anon on Sep 17, 2008 at 09:27 AM
Not always does someone go to jail. Several years ago an ex-boyfriend beat me. When the HPD arrived they clearly saw marks on me and I wanted him arrested and throw away the key, what did they do they gave him a ride back home, after getting the small switchblade knife from him and a small bag of marijuana.
Posted by: Anna on Sep 17, 2008 at 06:44 AM
For some reason, I do not think that is the entire 911 call. why is that?
Posted by: sleepy on Sep 17, 2008 at 02:30 AM
There's not always an arrest made in domestic calls. Domestic distrubances make up a tremendous amount of calls received at our local dispatch and its ridiculous to think that an arrest is made at everyone of those. If that were the case we'd all be talking about abuse of power or whatever. The real crime here is that this news station is not reporting on all the dirty politicians sleethering around the courthouse and city hall. If I were the Felintons and had to work with those bigots everyday, I'm sure I'd probably lose my cool at some point as well. Do a little research, attend a few meetings...you might be surprised...or sick...either way. Best of luck to the Felintons.
Posted by: boo on Sep 16, 2008 at 11:45 PM
wsaz will print anything as long as it snt about them personally.and they are supposed to check these messages before their posted,but ive seen a lot of hurtful remarks,slanderous remarks,and garbage that they have let slide on thru.lets see if they post this.probably not
Posted by: kim on Sep 16, 2008 at 09:04 PM
If this was any other citizen someone would have went to jail. yes all people have arguments but abuse can be verbal or physical. Huntington needs a new mayor.
Posted by: Heather on Sep 16, 2008 at 08:50 PM
It seems that there are so many people who are uneducated in basic politcal science... tsk tsk.... Quick lesson: When you decide to run for office in a democracy and become a public servant, you are responsible to the people and must answer to the people; therefore, the people have a right to know what is going on with our public servants (including their personal lives if it were to interfere with their duties-which this does). And for those who have a hard time reading such bureacratic conundrums, "people" in this instance means citizens of Huntington. Some many bible thumpers had no problem tearing apart President Clinton when he had an affair-so why not tear this mayor apart for beating his wife. (Even though nothing is for certain...either his wife is psycho or he is a "woman beater") I think that needs to be explored in depth seeing as how he IS the mayor and I believe she is a social worker and neither one of them can help anyone if they're that mentally disabled.
Posted by: anonymous on Sep 16, 2008 at 08:39 PM
Leave them alone? You people must be as crazy as they sound. He's a political official, running for re-election to boot, and his wife called 911 to report that he was attacking her? That absolutely is news, and the only shame on this station or any other news outlet would have been in not reporting it. It would be nothing less than a coverup if they didn't report on it. And frankly I'm a little shocked at the number of people that think domestic fights that end in 911 calls are "normal", Newsflash- violence and the police being called isn't normal- at best it's disturbed, more likely domestic violence, which is no matter to be taken lightly. I've never thought our mayor did a very good job, but now I have absolutely no faith in his character or leadership skills, and would never vote for him. And I'm a life-long dedicated Democrat.
Posted by: SHENA on Sep 16, 2008 at 07:54 PM
JUST LEAVE THEM ALONE THEY ARE PEOPLE JUST LIKE EVERYBODY ELSE AND THEY HAVE FIGHTS JUST LIKE EVERYBODY ELSE AND IF YOU TRY TO SAY THAT YOU DONT FIGHT WITH YOUR SPOUSE YOUR NOT BEING HONEST EVERYONE GETS STRESSED AND THINGS HAPPEN LEAVE THEM ALONE
Posted by: Don't look now, your double standard is showing on Sep 16, 2008 at 07:31 PM
The mayor's wife is either scared half out of her wits, or making things up to harm her husband. Either way, someone should have gone to jail: either her for making a false report, or him for domestic violence.
Posted by: WHOCARES ALSO on Sep 16, 2008 at 05:28 PM
NO RELATIONSHIP IS PERFECT, MUCH BEEN A SUPPORTER FOR WOLFE THAT LEAKED TO THE MEDIA
Posted by: DDCJ on Sep 16, 2008 at 04:38 PM
Come on, this is plain stupid "NEWS". WSAZ, you should take an online poll. Who cares and who doesn't. Just wonder what the results would be.
Posted by: whocares on Sep 16, 2008 at 04:29 PM
who cares is the current mayor is good hearted or not I am sure he probably did slap his wife around, people get over it she is just trying to cover it up so she isnt in the news, well you know what mrs felinton TOO LATE!!! if you didnt want the city of huntington and everyone else involved and if it wasnt for real you wouldnt have called
Posted by: Anonymous on Sep 16, 2008 at 04:01 PM
I know that no marriage is perfect but I have never picked up the phone and called 911 when we had a fight. Then she apologizes and admits that she lied. So, will she be cited for making a false call to the emergency services? Would I be cited if I did the same thing? At least be fined for the act...
Posted by: Sharon on Sep 16, 2008 at 03:19 PM
Shame on WSAZ for publishing the 911 call and for printing all these hurtful remarks - you are becoming trash tv!
Posted by: New River Gal on Sep 16, 2008 at 03:11 PM
just what we need - MORE intrigue in Huntington! I still say leave them alone. NONE of our business. If it happens again, then fine, there must be fire where there's smoke. Otherwise it's nothing more than an argument that got out of hand like most of us have from time to time. Only we're not important enough in the food chain to merit all this publicity NO I do NOT think it's Kim Wolfe and a conspiracy for heaven's sake. Mr. Wolfe seems like way too classy a man to do anything like leaking the tape. He doesn't need to. From what I hear & see, he's going to beat Felinton anyway. But this is definitely what we need here in town...ANOTHER huge story about one of our "leaders"! I hope Kim Wolfe wins though. This town needs CHANGE and needs it SOON! THEN Mr Felinton can help his wife with the kids & chores. He'll have nothing else to do & no huge salary for doing nothing. NOW if we could only fire the entire COUNCIL!
Posted by: anonymous on Sep 16, 2008 at 01:22 PM
I am sorry any family that has issues. However, I would like to meet the family how doesn't! I am a working mother of 1 and a wife. My husband and I both work 40 plus hours a week. We have our issues also! My husband nor myself, by no means are in the public eye 24/7. However, if we do get into an argument or shuffle I would greatly appreciate it if it not be plastarded all over the news and especially the headlined story. I also, believe, if Mrs. Felington felt threatened enough to call 911, that it is not the publics place to judge her. If for heavens sakes there is a next time she may not call and then what?
Posted by: Frank on Sep 16, 2008 at 01:15 PM
So how do we go from He's trying to slam my head up against a brick wall to I misused the critical resources. It's amazing what realizing that your actions probably cost you the lifestyle that you have become accustomed to over the last eight years. Lot's of backtracking and damage control. Those of you who say we should leave them alone are you saying the same thing about what the media are doing to Sarah Palin? Is it just when it happens to Democrats?
Posted by: Randal on Sep 16, 2008 at 12:42 PM
I listened to the 911 dispatcher. i hope I never have an emergency. Bethany Felinton told her in plain english what her first name was-why can't the 911 dispatchers pay attention.?? Isn't that their jobs? When my boyfriend Wes and I had a domestic dispute our neighbor called 911 and the dispatcher was so slow to gather simple information.
Posted by: Ann on Sep 16, 2008 at 12:20 PM
Get over it people... Dont you remember how it was when you were first married...didnt you have arguments?? This is being drug thru the mudd way too much..
Posted by: JC on Sep 16, 2008 at 11:19 AM
I am sure this is an innocent matter blown out of proportion by an overwhelmed wife and a few drinks. Remember, this is not some old mayor, he is young and so is his wife, adjusting to the pressures the community puts on them. Not to mention, a very stressful time. The wife just needed to vent and probably didn't realize that the Mayor was not jumping into her and her mom, but probably fell into them after drinking so much supporting the Herd - AS EVERYONE ELSE IN HUNTINGTON WAS DOING TOO. There are no marks on her, no arrests, so I could presume that this was an argument, that everyone gets into, and when you mix an overwhelmed woman with a drunk man, you get chaos. I don't think she lied to the police, I think that she wanted the cops to put an end to the arguing because their relationship is not like that and that night seemed out of the ordinary with no way to settle it until there was a mediator. Get over yourselves people, I have seen preachers and their wifes act worse.
Posted by: Charleston on Sep 16, 2008 at 10:56 AM
becoming a public figure...one must realize they and their family WILL be in the news...constantly....so we, society, must hold those public figures to a higher standard and should be held accountable for all actions.
Posted by: Anonymous on Sep 16, 2008 at 09:44 AM
is that the best we can do for 911?
Posted by: mayor supporter on Sep 16, 2008 at 09:14 AM
First of all, I have known Mayor Felinton for a long time. He is a kind hearted person. I don't know what happened that night at their home, but I am not here to judge. Just think about how this family's life is affected. She is a mom, a social worker, a wife and now a caretaker of her mother. He is not only a husband and working father (which is hard enough), he is trying to run a city and he is doing a fair job for what he has to work with on a small salary. (Don't think Kim Wolfe will do the job for what Felinton is doing it for) And, the poor guy is living with his mother in law in the middle of a campaign. Talk about stressful. Everyone has problems, no marriage is perfect. People threaten each other, it happens. I just don't believe the Mayor would physically harm anyone, especially his wife, the mother of his children, whom I personally know he loves very much. Mayor, you still have my vote in Nov. and I wish you and Bethany the best.
Posted by: missmanners on Sep 16, 2008 at 08:59 AM
After reading all these comments I have come to the conclusion that about 40% of you are mentally deficient. Kim Wolfe conspiracy, are you kidding me? And to those of you who say it's none of our business, apparently you missed the part where THE MAYOR called a press conference specifically to discuss this. Miss Bethany should grow up and take her punishment for lying to emergency services. She doesn't sound the least bit scared in the 911 call. Sounds like she was trying to hurt her husband's chances for reelection by calling 911. That is why she called him "Mayor Felinton" to 911 instead of saying "my husband is trying to hurt me, please help." As a social worker she should really know better than to be abusing this valuable resource (yes they're still valuable even though every 911 call I've ever heard sounds like talking to a mentally challenged person). She should face the same punishment as anyone else who abuses 911 for this purpose.
Posted by: Not a herd fan on Sep 16, 2008 at 08:51 AM
I have seen the the police officers at many and I mean many domestic calls and they have never stayed a hour and a half!!! Usually 10 minutes even when there is evidence of domestic violence - they slap the abuser on the hand and make them leave - even comments from the officer "to much paperwork" then police is called back as the violence gets worse. SKIP HOLBROOK this was a waste of tax payers money and was not treated as any domestic violence call. That is, if you can even get the police to show up in a timely manner or to even make a appearance - or how bout write up areport for future reference!!!! ABUSE by the police department as it is election time and the department has it in for Felington - this is WRONG!!!!! They want Kim Wolfe who has done nothing I mean NOTHING for Cabell County as a sheriff and will do NOTHING for the City as he is the only canidate that can be bought when Felington won't play their game!!!!!
Posted by: Houston on Sep 16, 2008 at 08:36 AM
News media has beat this story to death, move on, tired of hearing about it, we all argue and fuss once in awhile, after 47 years of marriage, we still do, move on
Posted by: stop it on Sep 16, 2008 at 08:34 AM
Everyone needs to leave this family alone. The media has been like wolves. The family gave a press conference and then they pushed for the wife to be on camera. Stop it already. I do not think that this will have affected Felington's job performance nor his wife's. They stated that they were seeking family counseling. SO, what is the problem here. It is private.
Posted by: Shop Girl on Sep 16, 2008 at 08:31 AM
If the Mayor can't take charge of his own home, how is he supposed to take charge of a city? His display of anger tells a tale of immaturity and violence. He needs therapy and marriage counseling, and if the "stress" of the campaign is too intense, he should withdraw. Other politicians seem to handle it well. His lack of control is a revealing characteristic, one I don't wish on the city.
Posted by: Anonymous on Sep 16, 2008 at 08:29 AM
Oh I am sure the call is very true..She just doesnt want her husband to look bad.Thats how it works.And all you women know that if you have ever been in same type of situation...
Posted by: Michelle on Sep 16, 2008 at 08:00 AM
Oh good grief people... leave these people alone. People make false 911 calls all the time. It is not right and something should be done but hasn't this family been through enough with their private lives being dragged through the mud? Granted, I did not read this article because it's none of my business. It proves they are human. Leave the Felington's alone and mind your own business.
Posted by: bonn on Sep 16, 2008 at 07:47 AM
And now on with some real news, please. You've beat this to death.
Posted by: Monica on Sep 16, 2008 at 06:48 AM
I feel sorry for this couple and think we should give them some slack. My mother lives with us and it is stressful. We don't have childern so I can imagine they add more stress. It just seems like parents assume you have to always be there. It can put pressure plus he is tryint to campaign. I say leave them alone and let them work it out. She done something very extreme in the heat of anger.
Posted by: Mike on Sep 16, 2008 at 06:36 AM
We should leave the personal matters to the mayors family alone - they are for he and his wife to deal with. We are all human and we all have issues. I personally supprt Kim Wolfe as our new mayor of Huntington come November. However, I support the current mayor and his family in my prayers -
Posted by: BOBBIE on Sep 16, 2008 at 06:15 AM
domestic violence is a serious thing. I lived half my life like that.NOW my kids are on drugs bad and domestic violence ia repeated with there families wish i would have left the problem i was in my kids might have had a better life I HATE MYSELF FOR NOT LEAVING DEAL WITH IT EVERY DAY NOW WITH MY KIDS AND IT HURTS.
Posted by: Mary on Sep 16, 2008 at 03:41 AM
If "what she said on the 911 call was not true" then she should be charged with making a false 911 call. But of course officials will let that slide.
Posted by: Mingo County Herd Fan on Sep 16, 2008 at 03:33 AM
I have just watched the "Raw" video footage, on this story. And as much as I have supported David Felington, and His visionary policies, for the City of Huntington, I could not get passed the fact that SOMETHING HAPPENED, to force the Mayor's Wife contact 911. Watching the interview that Mrs. Felington gave the reporter, I could sense Her anxiety levels rise and fall. Mrs. Felington, try as She may, failed to convince this Viewer of Her total honesty regarding the 911 call. I have always admired Mayor Felington for His intelligence and determination. I could not help to wonder if Mrs. Felington's responses were scripted and staged. My heart does go out to this Family. I hope for the sake of Their children, counseling will be sought, by the Mayor and Mrs. Felington. After all, when this story has failed to catch any interest of those in the Media, the well-being of these children should be the main focus of the ENTIRE community of Huntington. Please, Pray for the Felington Family.
Posted by: Huntington on Sep 16, 2008 at 03:21 AM
Huntington needs a new Mayor. As you can see David Felinton cannot even keep his family happy! Look at the city of Huntington how bad it's getting and just because election is right around the corner he is saying he is putting 500,000 dollars towards fixing our roads! But these roads have needed fixed for years! He is just trying to be Mayor again so he can use Huntington's Money for his own use...Like LapBand surgery! David needs to get control on his family life and needed to do better for Huntington!
Posted by: Reader on Sep 16, 2008 at 01:28 AM
If thats the real 911 call, I think the dispatcher needs a hearing aid.
Posted by: Randal on Sep 16, 2008 at 12:48 AM
when my boyfriend wes and i got into a fight last weekend, the police didn't help out at all. i don't think they are going to help out here either.
Posted by: john on Sep 16, 2008 at 12:17 AM
my son & his wife got into an arguement a couple of years back, she walked into the room & started hitting on him, ( i was there ) her uncle call in on 911 from his house that is five miles away, he told them that they were having trouble at his neices house, the law came & by that time we had left. she did not have a mark of any kind on her. she had scratched my son face in several places, & kicked both of his legs until they were black & blue. i seen the whole thing. he did not as much as touch her. the next day wayne county police came to his work & arrested him after ruffing him up & puting him in cuffs so tight it cut into his arms. this went on his record. even though i told the judge that i was there & seen the whole thing & she did not have a mark on her, he was guilty. why is the Huntington not in jail ?
Posted by: beenthere on Sep 16, 2008 at 12:02 AM
hes a liar, shes covering, and until she gets out, it will only get worse...mayor or not...once the police arrive someone...if not both should be arrested.Last thing my ex would say"if i go to jail, i'll kill you"--so i wasn't about to press charges...if it had only been out of my hands and they had taken him the first time called-would've spared me years of abuse and emotional scarring
Posted by: Grayson Ky on Sep 15, 2008 at 11:51 PM
just about every day in grayson ky there is about two or three domestic between hubby and wife or girl friend and boyfriend goes on daily and always someone goes to jail so why didn't someone go to jail here . we as people are all the same we put are pants on the same way . so something doesn't smell right here. and her body action she is lieing about this whole thing myself i think she was hiding something there was more to this story than what they are saying .
Posted by: samlmay25704@yahoo.com on Sep 15, 2008 at 11:31 PM
i wonder if that was anybody else, how bad the cops would have beat his head in & put him in jail. it's who you are & who you know in Huntington.
Posted by: A woman on Sep 15, 2008 at 11:31 PM
Hey I have been in the same place as this woman. I have called 9-11 on my husband and he wouldnt hurt me it was just out of anger and to shut his screaming up.lol But this could be more. you never know. But thank god my buisness was not in the news...
Posted by: Rob on Sep 15, 2008 at 11:18 PM
I think Josh M. is misinformed...I'm sure WSAZ wouldn't have aired the 911 tape if it wasn't legally obtained. As for the story hampering the election, Mayor Felinton was the one who called for the press conference Sun. afternoon...which spawned much discussion.
Posted by: Mel on Sep 15, 2008 at 11:12 PM
Why is this in the news? Let alone a top story. Nobody is perfect and everyone has problems every now and again, even mayors.
Posted by: lets see....... on Sep 15, 2008 at 11:07 PM
He PROBABLY did threaten her or act like he was going to hurt her, there for, she CALLS 911 for her safety and her mothers, then after the whole incident, and them getting phone calls... he PROBABLY once again threatend her to SAY all those WONDERFUL things about him and make her look like fool, for her safety!!! Think about it... POLICE look into this....its ur job!
Posted by: Tim M on Sep 15, 2008 at 11:04 PM
Why is everyone hating on WSAZ? Its on ALL the news stations and newspaper.
Posted by: Gregg on Sep 15, 2008 at 11:03 PM
Some ask why WSAZ chose to report about this incident. The Mayor called the press conference, not the media. Then there is the "911 tape" that was aired. Not so sure how proper that was, but then what happened to investigating because of "the seriousness of the charge." So many people believe conspiracy theories (leveled against Republicans) and demand every piece of "evidence" that can be produced. Should this be a campaign issue? You tell me. Should this be ignored and covered-up just because of the election - no way. The Mayor made it public and now it must play out that way. Yes, I do believe their private life should remain that, but now there needs to be closure of what the Mayor chose to open. Again, I will pray for them both and encourage everyone else to do the same. Regardless of position or politics, let their be peace and harmony between them in the end. If this damages the Mayor's public standing, then let the process of restoration begin there too.
Posted by: Anonymous on Sep 15, 2008 at 10:57 PM
Sounds like a fight between husband and wife to me and I have to agree with one of the comments on here, in her anger was she trying to hurt him , she does not refer to him as her 'husband' but as 'Mayor Felinton' pi$$ some women off and they go overboard and regret it later ...not headline news.
Posted by: Anonymous on Sep 15, 2008 at 10:45 PM
Why was Bethany not arrested for lying to the police???? She said "He just tried to slam my head up against a brick wall"!!!! Why would you say something like that, if it didn't happen???? REVENGE OR DID IT ACTUALLY HAPPEN???? MAKES YOU WONDER......Somebody needs to talk to Bethany's mother, she knows the truth, but will she tell it????
Posted by: Goes with the territory on Sep 15, 2008 at 10:45 PM
So if he'd killed her instead of just hitting her head would that still be just personal business. NO PEOPLE - When these people go into 'public' office they have to realize, especially in today's world, that whatever happens with them is and will be 'public' business. This is partially business people do have the right to know what kind of person they are represented by but this is also because nearly everyone these days feels 'entitled' to know business of others whether it relates to them or not. It's a part of this world current politicians must accept or not choose to put themselves in these positions. Either way he was mistaken and hasn't truly explained his behavior - He's a politician, so this surprises us how!
Posted by: kim on Sep 15, 2008 at 10:29 PM
I agree with letting them handle the situation themselves & not having their dirty laundry aired out everywhere. But...she needs to realize, if she or her kids are in any danger, being the mayors wife is NO reason to stay, for her or the kids safety. No man in never that important!
Posted by: to Josh M. on Sep 15, 2008 at 10:10 PM
Get over yourself, they can run whatever soemone gives them, or not if they chose so. The one in trouble is the one who let the tape out, they're oging to lose they're job whenever the 911 Directors find out. Why would WSAZ be liable for this? Weirdo.
Posted by: Jim on Sep 15, 2008 at 10:03 PM
I doubt very much that Mayor Felinton and the subsequent domestic call was treated the same or according to protocol. As the old saying goes "someone is trying to pull the wool over our eyes". It is a proven fact that a man in blue jeans and a cap is looked upon differently than one in a suit. I was involved in a domestic "situation" when I was younger and without going into detail, I called 911 to try avert a hostile episode and in the end I was arrested due to a blatant lie and police did not spend an hour and a half talking with me to find out the truth. Those with social status and/or money will always be looked upon differently than the commoner. If you do not agree, I invite you to register for a Socialogy class on deviance and labeling at Marshall, or remind yourself of how West Virginians are viewed by the majority of our nation including your Vice President!
Posted by: Josh M. on Sep 15, 2008 at 09:49 PM
I think it is funny that WSAZ ran a tape that was illegal to run and there isn't anything being done about it... I wonder if the police department is upset about it? If the Mayor's wife doesn't sign the papers to press charges non of this happened... Then what if the Mayor loses the election? Would he then have a lawsuit against WSAZ for running a tape that defamed him so close to elections... I bet he would... And what would everything think about the tape being leaked out by some city employee who already gave their support to Kim Wolfe... Looks pretty crappy to me... But go ahead WSAZ do as you wish because you never get in trouble for anything else you do...
Posted by: JUST ME on Sep 15, 2008 at 09:49 PM
I THINK THAT IT IS SAD THAT THIS HAS BECOME PUBLIC NEWS. EVERY DAY PEOPLE GET INTO DOMESTIC FIGHTS. NOT EVERY DAY IS IT PUT ON THE NEWS AT 6PM. IT IS THEIR BUSINESS. LET THEM TAKE CARE OF IT. NO, I AM NOT VOTING FOR MR FELINTON IF YOU ARE WONDERING. I THINK IT IS UNFAIR THAT HIS FAMILY PROBLEMS HAVE BEEN MADE FRONT PAGE NEWS. WHEN WAS THE LAST TIME YOU SAW A REPORT ON THE NEWS THAT A COUPLE GOT INTO AN ARGUMENT AND THE CAMERAS WERE ROLLING?? GIVE THEM A BREAK! IF SHE IS BEING ABUSED THEN SHE NEEDS TO KNOW THAT SHE CAN GET HELP! OH WAIT SHE KNOWS THAT SHE IS A SOCIAL WORKER RIGHT??
Posted by: think about it on Sep 15, 2008 at 09:43 PM
Come on! Did anyone think that maybe she was on the wrong side? There are 2 sides! Maybe he ticked her off and she knew she could ruin him by calling the police! I am not saying it's true, but the police found no marks!
Posted by: Dale on Sep 15, 2008 at 09:39 PM
It sure is nice to see all those stones flying from those who never did anything wrong. Let the law and his family handle this. Im sure we all have alot of better things to worry and stick our noses in then this. Like your own problems!
Posted by: ohio guy on Sep 15, 2008 at 09:11 PM
I feel if the police didn't arrest anyone it is noone business but the familys. As for WSAZ reporting on this it's a free country, but there is alot of other news going on too. For everyone out there saying negative stuff about the Fellington's and the HPD, let me say this. He who has not made a mistake cast the first stone at them. That's what I thought, now sit down and hush. In my opinion , WSAZ's reporting of this story is a bit overbearing. But hey it's their time and money.
Posted by: Jenn on Sep 15, 2008 at 08:54 PM
No Its None Of Our Business But Wouldnt I go To Jail Just Cause He Is Mayor He Shouldnt Be Treated No Different I Hope It All Works Out For The Both Of Them But Most PPl Would Done Be In Jail
Posted by: Napalm on Sep 15, 2008 at 08:46 PM
It is amazing what happens to the people who stand up to our public servants Don't mess with the Police Dave. You better go on and settle their contract like wolf promises too. Free health and $5.00 on the hour, three day work week. police cars for all family mebers to drive.
Posted by: BILL on Sep 15, 2008 at 08:45 PM
TO: READ IT AGAIN BILL SEPT 15,2008 5:21AM. YOU KNOW AS WELL AS I DO WSAZ WAS AWARE OF IT SOMEHOW BEFORE THE MAYOR WANTED TO DO A PRESS CONFRENCE. WHAT IT BOILS DOWN TO THERE EINSTEIN IS, ITS HIS PERSONAL LIFE AND HIS BUSINESS. NOBODY NEEDS TO BE IN HIS PERSONAL BUSINESS. OH, I NEVER SAID WSAZ SHOULD IGNORE THIS BECAUSE ITS IRRELEVANT. READ IT SOME MORE. I ASKED A QUESTION OF HOW THEY FOUND OUT ABOUT IT, I DIDNT ASK FOR YOUR SMART A@# COMMENT EITHER. SOUNDS IF MAYBE YOU WORK FOR WSAZ, COULD THAT BE POSSIBLE?
Posted by: Randy on Sep 15, 2008 at 08:42 PM
Makes you wonder if Kim Wolfe got this tape for them since they won't say who their source is......Dirty politics at its best!
Posted by: Dave on Sep 15, 2008 at 08:42 PM
Yes everyone has problems, we all loose our temper, but come on Huntington, any kind of violence against a woman coming from a man especially her husband is just unacceptable. If he is re-elected what does that say about the city of Huntington. I wonder if Wolfe threatens his wife, I doubt it, haven't heard anything about. And as for the privacy issue, when you are in the public eye as a public servant yur privacy is trade off for that. We all know that. So go ahead, defend him, re-elect him, wahtever. i'm just glad I moved outside the city limits of Huntington and no longer have a dog in this fight.
Posted by: Anonymous on Sep 15, 2008 at 08:34 PM
I'm curious about the third party. How did they get their hands on the 911 tapes? If the incident is still under investigation, then the third party should not have released it to wsaz...
Posted by: Terri on Sep 15, 2008 at 08:29 PM
Give it up! Mayor Felinton has done an amazing job for the city of Huntington. If every "fight" between a man and his wife made the news - we would need it to be on 24/7. If Mrs Felinton says she lied, she lied...drop it and let him run the city!
Posted by: Domestic Violence Shelter Worker/Advocate on Sep 15, 2008 at 08:22 PM
This case was not handled as other domestic violence cases when the police is summons to a residence or other place where domestic violence has occurred. The law states that when law enforcement is summons to a residence or other place where abuse has occurred that someone is arrested for domestic battery. Usually it is the man who is arrested whether he is the person who did the abuse or not.
Posted by: Anonymous on Sep 15, 2008 at 08:18 PM
Isn't there laws against making false calls like that?
Posted by: Anon on Sep 15, 2008 at 08:09 PM
No one's perfect, and everyone has problems... whether we like it or not. Unfortunately when you're a public figure.. your private life becomes public.
Posted by: Dave on Sep 15, 2008 at 08:06 PM
I have met, in passing the Mayor, several times while walking in the downtown area. I have always greeted him respectfully. He has never returned my greeting. He is not a very personable human being.
Posted by: kygal on Sep 15, 2008 at 08:03 PM
How much coverage would this get if it was not the mayor and he was not running for reelection??? Leave them alone and allow them to work through this in privacy.
Posted by: Anonymous on Sep 15, 2008 at 07:58 PM
false allegations why not cps gets by with it every day
Posted by: ben on Sep 15, 2008 at 07:58 PM
So WSAZ lets MUFan put out stories about Felinton and Carter being in a drunken rage, aprroves the comments and does not require evidence. Might I remind the station that this counts as publishing and I'd hope they have the proof to back this up, because, if not, it sounds like a little something called 'libel."
Posted by: charles carroll on Sep 15, 2008 at 07:58 PM
I wonder