|
Updated: 9:18 PM Nov 19, 2008
UPDATE: Former Firefighter Voices Safety Concerns
For former Charleston firefighter Eric King, it's a Catch-22. The National Fire Protection Agency recommends a firefighter not have a pacemaker and continue on the job. So, King was fired from the department. Posted: 8:31 PM Nov 18, 2008Reporter: Amanda Barren Email Address: Amanda.Barren@wsaz.com |
|
Update from 6 p.m. Wednesday
CHARLESTON, W.Va. (WSAZ) -- For former Charleston firefighter Eric King, it's a Catch-22. The National Fire Protection Agency recommends a firefighter not have a pacemaker and continue on the job. So, King was fired from the department.
Here's where the catch comes in, according to King. He said it was a job-related test that he doesn't believe always follows those NFPA guidelines that caused his medical condition to begin with.
"They routinely send people to the hospital, most of the time they will pass out, they'll get fluids in them and they will be fine," King said. King told WSAZ Tuesday by phone that (they) "act like it's funny to break someone down and send someone to the hospital. "
King blames the test for his pacemaker and his diagnosis of bradycardia. According to King and his doctor, his cardiac health was fine prior to taking this test.
Local IAFF President Myron Boggess said needing treatment at the test is just like needing treatment at the scene.
"There is people who pass out on the fire scene, there is people that have to take oxygen on the fire scene, there are people that have to take IV fluid on the scene," Boggess said. " I don't understand what the difference is."
King said he was among three people taken to the hospital because of the Charleston Job Related Skills Test. The class only had 10 people.
When it comes to enforcement, NFPA guidelines are not black and white. During testing a medic is on the grounds, but not closely monitoring the test. Based on the NFPA standards, someone should be watching, according to King. He also believes the amount of time firefighters should be in their gear needs to be examined.
One firefighter who serves as a medic at the test from time to time agrees with King in part. Steve Haga has been a Charleston firefighter for more almost 10 years, and told WSAZ.com Tuesday, "Repeatedly they've had people that require attention after the test. That tells you, one, either the test is flawed or the preparation for the test is flawed. "
Dr. Paul Davis, PhD., is an expert in physical fitness and employment standards. He is a retired firefighter and paramedic. He took a look at the test and said he saw nothing wrong with it.
He did wonder why veteran firefighters weren't taking the test biannually.
Chief of Operations Rodney Winter told WSAZ.com that it's a logistics issue. That's because the department uses the Charleston Civic Center parking garage for its testing. He said, however, that he would like to see a department physical test.
Original story
CHARLESTON, W.Va. (WSAZ) -- Firefighters face dangerous situations every single day. But now, one former probationary Charleston firefighter claims the group's biggest danger might be coming from the department itself.
Eric King is speaking out, saying that life has changed drastically for him and his family since he took the Charleston Fire Department's Job Related Skills Test.
King is 34 years old. He now has a pacemaker and was diagnosed with bradycardia. Bradycardia is a condition that means your heart beats less than 60 times a minute. King said up until he passed out from heat exhaustion during the skills test, he had a clean bill of cardiac health.
"I got hurt taking a test, and they continue to take that test after numerous people have been hurt taking the test, and nothing is changing on it," King said. "I am afraid someone will get seriously injured."
The test is a series of job-related skills probationary firefighters must complete to become a full-fledged member of the Charleston Fire Department. That includes everything from tying knots to using a sledge hammer, to climbing a ladder and pulling a mannequin. The goal is to simulate what happens in the field, and to make sure members are not only proficient but efficient.
Myron Boggess is the president of the local chapter of the International Association of Firefighters.
"It is a hard test," Boggess said. "If it wasn't, anyone could do it. You have to have some kind of a gauge set to where people either pass or they fail."
There is no time limit on the test, but the average length is about an hour. King said he'd been in his turnout gear for about that long when he passed out. He said he was almost done.
"I don't disagree with those skills needing to be tested," King said. "But to have it all in one and to run people for over an hour in full gear -- that is crazy; it's absolutely ridiculous. They are going to end up killing someone."
According to the Charleston Fire Department's chief of operations, more than 100 fire fighters have passed the test. Two breaks -- each lasting two minutes -- are provided during the test.
Each day leading up to the test and even once the test is over, firefighters are allowed an hour during their scheduled shift to work out in the fire department gym. They are encouraged to do the same on their days off.
The test requirement started back in the 1990s.
Danny Anderson is the IAFF secretary/treasurer. He believes the test prepares a firefighter for any day on the job.
"I like to feel like the Charleston Fire Department is the best fire department in the state," he said. "I feel like we set our standards and goals above and beyond. Because that way when we go to fight a fire or have to rescue a person or cut someone out of a car, whatever it may be that we have to face, we are going to be above and beyond ready to handle that challenge."
Boggess said that he never heard any complaints about the test until he found out King's situation was brought to the attention of WSAZ.
King was let go from the job because he uses a pacemaker; that is a guideline put in place by the National Fire Protection Association. NFPA is a a standard-setting group for fire departments across the nation.
King is appealing his workers' compensation claim, which was previously denied.
Charleston City Manager David Molgaard said that is why the workers' compensation appeals process is in place.
"Better to understand the physical capabilities during a test than during a true emergency where other peoples lives and the lives of their coworkers are really at stake," Molgaard said. "To the extent he had a physical condition that manifested itself during a training exercise or a test, it might have been for the better."
Latest Comments
I doubt it that a Huntington Fire Department meber made the comment that was posted because I some of them and have found them to be far better quality than that. The statement that our department is the best is a matter of pride and from my point of view we are. However the fact is we all try to do our best in our line of work which really makes all of us come up to the highest of standards. We are Paid Prfessional Firefighters. We are willing to go that extra mile when it commes to risks and dangers. Yes our test is rigorous but so is our job in the real life. I hope we continue the test so we don't have to find out that someone couldn't handle the job in ral life and then we have to dress in our Class A uniforms and march down that long funeral procession. As I probationary firefighter I had not been a volunteer so it was ll new to me. Yet I knew in order to complete my probation I had to prove myself worthy by preparing to take the tests that were ahead. Thanks to those who worked.
[ Report Abuse ]
I am intrigued by all of the comments stating the test did what it was suppose to do. I failed the test and it is on video (video in which WSAZ has) the only reason I was not terminated was due to the fact I have documentation that would crucify certain members of the Charleston Fire Department in the court of law. So there are free passes and I am proof of that. There is no denying this and all you have to do is email WSAZ and request they show this video footage.
[ Report Abuse ]
I agree, the bashing between the paid guys and the vollies needs to stop. It's childish. The point of this story is of Eric King. Yes tests are designed for people to pass or fail, not send people to the hospital. Every person at CFD needs to take the same test or maybe the CPAT test every year to test their physical ability, and yes that includes everyone from a new hire to the chiefs. Eric's condition resulted from an overload of physical strain on his heart. What kind of excuse is Rodney Winter tryin to make..."It's a logistics issue..." Logistics has nothing to do with a guy gettin a pacemaker put in because his heart got overloaded. Let's look up NFPA 1584, I believe it's covers incidents and training exercises, and wouldn't the test fall under training exercises? If CFD is going to follow NFPA, they should follow all the guidelines of the NFPA not just the ones that benefit them.
[ Report Abuse ]
|
Popular Searches Powered by Local.com |
- Rape victim's parents charged with child abuse
- Arrests in Italy linked to Mumbai attacks
- Hospital hearing set for Hasan
- Prosecutor: Knox resented roommate
- H1N1 cases down; vaccine access up
- Plea deal reached in Wal-Mart trial
- Anglican leader to meet with Pope
- Fans mourn end of 'Oprah' show
- Dozens missing after China mine blast
- Senate vote next step on health bill road
- Students hold buildings in protest
- CDC: H1N1 cases down, vaccine availability up
- Charge against Blackwater guard dropped
- Oprah ending talk show in 2011
- 'Summers were the worst,' says woman in sex abuse case
- Senate vote next step on what could be a long road for health care
- Attorney: Fort Hood suspect to be held in hospital
- Burned Florida teen having skin graft surgery
- New cervical cancer screening guidelines released
- Ex-U.S. official, wife to plead guilty in Cuba spy case
- Prosecutor: Knox taunted, killed victim
- Pope to meet Anglican leader amid tensions
- Scores missing after China mine blast
- Bacteria prompts nasal spray recall in U.S., Europe
- Blind students sing upon school supplies' arrival
- Peru: Arrests made in ring that sold human fat
- Right-wing activists storm TV station over 'bias'
- Football fever turns nasty in Cairo
- Man who killed wife while dreaming is released
- Police find body, 3 rifles after Saipan shooting spree
- Prosecutor: Knox tortured roommate
- Parents of 8-year-old rape victim charged with abuse
- Florida men sentenced for plotting terror attacks
- Wal-Mart line jumper to plead guilty to resisting arrest
- 'Summers were the worst,' Mohler family accuser says
- Burned Florida teen having skin graft surgery
- Hospital hearing sought for Fort Hood suspect
- Man faces murder charge in Shaniya Davis case
- Suspects sold fat harvested from corpses, authorities say
- Police: Suspect in Arkansas slayings killed in shootout
- Scrutiny for cancer screenings
- Can your doctor spot H1N1?
- Purpose found after loved ones' suicides
- CDC: H1N1 cases down, vaccine availability grows
- 'I want my mammograms!'
- What to expect in Saturday health care vote
- New cervical cancer screening guidelines released
- Vicks nasal spray recalled over bacteria
- Two men reflect national divide over health reform
- HIV+ soccer team scores against stigma
- Michigan-Ohio State and more Saturday Storylines
- Predictions for Michigan-Ohio St. and more
- Seth Davis: Syracuse will go as far as the once-reluctant Johnson carries it
- Hawks soar to league-best 11-2 on Smith's tip-in
- No. 6 Boise St. rips Utah St. to stay in BCS chase
- LeBron drops 40 as Cavs pull away from Pacers
- Death of Brees' mother ruled a suicide
- Carter's big 4th quarter carries Magic past Celtics
- Giants LB Pierce out indefinitely with neck injury
- Knicks decide against signing free-agent Iverson
- Hundreds Greet Miles Ferguson on Return Home to Portsmouth
- South Charleston Police Seek 2 Teens in Connection with 'Gruesome' Murder
- Miley Cyrus Tour Bus Overturns in Va., Killing 1
- Man Shot Five Times at a Home in Kanawha County, Name Released
- Ambulance Crashes while En Route to Accident, 3 Hurt
- Name Released: Man Shot in South Charleston, Found Near Mound
- Racial Profiling Allegations in Huntington; HPD Chief Said He Was Barred from News Conference
- Child Hit By Bus in Front of School
- One Dead in Boyd County Crash, Name Released
- Oprah Winfrey to Announce Friday Show will End in 2011
- Hundreds Greet Miles Ferguson on Return Home to Portsmouth
602 Comments - One Dead in Boyd County Crash, Name Released
54 Comments - Huntington City Council Members Discuss Violence in Downtown Bars
30 Comments - Ambulance Crashes while En Route to Accident, 3 Hurt
21 Comments - MCTC Picks New Name, Initials Remain the Same
20 Comments - UPDATE: Two Arrested in Double Carter County Murder
17 Comments
![]() |
| PHONE IN YOUR YELLS TO: 1-866-616-5354 |
![]() |
Full 2010 Olympic coverage from the WSAZ Olympic Zone. Coverage begins Friday, Feb. 12, at 7:30p with the Opening Ceremony on WSAZ |
![]() |
A glittering holiday show full of fun and surprises for the whole family! Children thrill as Santa takes them on a magical ride to his workshop. |
![]() |
Healthy Connections Find a local health professional |
![]() |
A collection of resources here to help Moms weather the daily storms that come along with parenting. |
| SOMC Very good things are happening here |
|
| WV Lottery Nightly drawings and numbers |
|
| Big Sandy For all your furniture and appliance needs |
|
| Healthy Tri-State Tips to live a healthier lifestyle |





