|
Updated: 11:00 PM Nov 3, 2009
UPDATE: Driver Involved in Fatal Tractor-Trailer Accident Appears in Court
Michael Joyce's case was sent to the grand jury during a preliminary hearing Tuesday morning.
Posted: 12:14 PM Nov 3, 2009Reporter: Carrie Cline Email Address: carrie.cline@wsaz.com |
Joyce is in the orange jumpsuit
|
UPDATE from 6pm Tuesday 11/3
WAYNE, W.Va. (WSAZ) -- He's charged in the death of a man in a wheelchair after police say he ran over him in his tractor trailer last week.
On Tuesday, that truck driver, Michael Joyce, apologized. He spoke exclusively to WSAZ.com on the way to his first court appearance.
“Do you have anything you want to say to Mr. Scott's family?” asked WSAZ.com's Carrie Cline.
“I'm sorry, I never seen him,” Joyce said.
“Did you know you hit something?” Cline asked. “No,” Joyce replied.
“What were your thoughts when you found out you had killed a man?” Cline asked. “I started praying,” Joyce said.
Joyce has been a professional truck driver for at least 20 years. But, last Monday, while driving his tractor-trailer through Kenova, police say he ran over a man in a wheelchair. Joyce was turning onto 14th Street in Kenova when police say the back wheels of his truck went up on the curb, striking Deris Scott, killing him and dragging his wheelchair for more than two city blocks.
“We can't get inside of his mind -- I don't know what the truck driver knew or didn't know as to whether or not a person was involved," Wayne County Prosecutor Tom Plymale said. "But, we do know that the evidence would indicate that he left the scene where something had taken place that left debris on the road in two different places. That's what we’re looking at.”
Joyce faces a felony charge of leaving the scene of an accident causing death. That's punishable by up to three years in prison. He's also charged with two misdemeanors, including negligent homicide.
In court on Tuesday, his bond was reduced from $100,000 to $25,000. He posted that bond and was released from jail.
It has been a story that's resulted in nearly 400 comments here at WSAZ.com -- most saying he should have never been charged with a crime.
“I'm not unsympathetic to that," Plymale said. "I've talked to truck drivers and a lot have told me you can't feel these things, you can't get the impression. I understand that. I felt like the evidence at the scene was significant enough that he should be charged.”
“Mr. Joyce is a good man," said Benjamin Bryant, who is Joyce's defense attorney. "He's devoted to his religion. He's a professional driver. He is profoundly upset over Mr. Scott's death. This is a tragic accident.”
Also in court on Tuesday, Joyce waived his preliminary hearing -- deciding to let a grand jury decide if there’s enough evidence to go to trial. The felony charge of leaving the scene of the accident causing death is punishable by up to three years in prison.
UPDATE Tuesday 11/3
WAYNE, W.Va. (WSAZ) -- The case against a tractor trailer driver who police say hit and killed a man in a wheelchair was sent to a grand jury Tuesday morning.
Police say Deris Scott, 68, of Kenova, died after the trailer of the semi Michael Joyce was driving, hit Scott’s motorized wheelchair, and knocked him out.
The fatal accident happened last month at the intersection of Route 60 and 14th Street in Kenova.
Police say Scott's wheelchair was dragged several blocks before a motorist was finally able to get Joyce to stop near the intersection with I-64.
Joyce, who is from South Carolina, is charged with felony negligent homicide and two misdemeanors - failure to stop at a scene and accident causing death.
During the preliminary hearing in Wayne County Magistrate Court, the case was waived to a grand jury.
The Magistrate also reduced Joyce's bond to $25,000. A representative of the trucking company was in the process of paying the bond so Joyce could be released from jail.
UPDATE from 6pm Tuesday
KENOVA, W.Va. (WSAZ) -- One day after a tractor-trailer hit a man in a wheelchair and killed him, the truck driver continued to sit in jail Tuesday -- charged with felony negligent homicide.
It's raised some strong opinions on both sides of the issue. Should the driver be charged with a crime? And why are trucks using such a narrow road to access the interstate?
“It is against the law when you kill somebody because of your negligence, that's against the law -- even if it is an accident,” Kenova Police Chief Bob McComas said.
The chief is adamant when he says charging the truck driver, Michael Joyce, with felony negligent homicide is the right thing to do.
“We've got witnesses and statements that said they couldn't believe he left," McComas said. He had to know he hit the man. I wasn't there, I'm just telling you what people said.”
But, plenty of other people who also weren't there have weighed in on here at WSAZ.com. Out of more than 150 comments so far, the court of public opinion is wide ranging.
Many say it’s insane to charge the driver with a felony, calling it a tragic accident. But, others say the driver is getting what he deserves, and it was his responsibility to stop.
“It's an everyday thing," Ron Ferguson said. "Very seldom does a truck come around there that doesn't hit the curb.”
Ferguson owns Ron's Cars, located at the intersection where the accident happened. On Monday, witnesses said the back wheels of the truck caught Deris Scott's wheelchair, dumping him onto the street and dragging his wheelchair for more than two blocks. Ferguson blames the narrow road.
“Instead of turning there to get on the interstate, they can go two more miles down the road and have direct access to I-64," McComas said. "I'm not going to pass judgment on this driver. It's my job to just present evidence to the judge.”
Joyce is also charged with two misdemeanors -- failure to stop at the scene and accident causing death.
UPDATE from 6pm
KENOVA, W.Va. (WSAZ) – A 68-year-old man was crossing the street in his wheelchair Monday morning when a tractor-trailer hit and killed him.
The accident happened just before 10 a.m. in Kenova, leaving a trail of damage for more than two city blocks. The Kenova community is mourning the loss of a man that lived his life giving to others.
"I just don't know how someone could turn a corner and not realize he drug someone for two city blocks," said Elaine Hairston, a friend of victim Deris "Scotty" Scott.
Not someone, something -- it was Scott's wheelchair being dragged after a tractor-trailer hit him at the intersection of U.S. Route 60 and 14th Street in Kenova, killing him and dragging the chair.
Kenova Police Chief Bob McComas said the tractor-trailer’s driver had made a wide right turn, and Scott, who was physically challenged, was run over by the rear wheels of the trailer.
Witness Steve Sullivan had just seen the man everyone knew simply as "Scotty" only minutes earlier. He described hearing a "loud thump" when the accident occurred.
"I hollered at him, and he wouldn't stop," Sullivan said. "I heard a girl hollering and saw a body."
Hairston said Scott attended Kenova Church of Christ.
"He came to the senior center and ate and studied there," she said. "He was wonderful -- always smiling and talking to you."
Hairston has known Scott for more than 20 years. She says ironically, he was hit by a car more than 50 years ago, landing him in the wheelchair.
"He was working on someone's vehicle and lost both his legs trying to help someone else," she said.
McComas said he doesn't believe the truck driver saw Scott. He said it took a good Samaritan to flag down the truck driver about a half mile later. He told police he thought he'd just run over a curb.
"It's a very sad day for Kenova and sad for policemen seeing that," McComas said.
The truck driver is Michael Joyce from South Carolina. He has been charged with negligent homicide and failure to stop at a scene and was taken to the Western Regional Jail.
ORIGINAL STORY
KENOVA, W.Va. (WSAZ) -- Police say a man in a motorized wheelchair was killed after being hit by a tractor trailer in Kenova.
Officers say the accident happened at the the intersection of U.S. 60 and 14th Street around 9:50 Monday morning.
Kenova Police tell WSAZ.com, that the tractor trailer was heading east on Route 60 when the driver made a wide, right hand turn onto 14th Street heading toward I-64.
This all happened just as the man in the wheelchair was almost across the street.
That's when police say the back wheels of the truck caught the wheelchair, dumping the man and dragging the chair for several blocks.
Police say the vicitm is 68-year-old Deris Scott. He died at the scene.
Witnesses say he is simply known around town as "Scotty."
Kenova’s Police Chief says it was a good Samaritan that finally got the truck driver to stop near the entrance ramp to I-64. He says the driver was surprised by the news that he'd hit something.
The chief says charges are pending against the driver.
Kenova Police have called in crime scene reconstructionists from the West Virginia State Police to help piece this accident together.
Keep clicking on WSAZ.com for updated information.
[ Copyright 2009 – WSAZ.com. All Rights Reserved. ]
This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.
Severe Weather and Breaking News Coverage
To send a news tip or submit a story idea, e-mail news@wsaz.com
Latest Comments
I have known Mike Joyce all of my life. THere is not a mean bone in his body! Had he known he had hit much less killed a man he would have stopped and done everything in his power to help the person out. So the charges "leaving the scene" are outragous! Mike is a great guy and is going to be punished by himself far greater than any the jury can give him. I know he is truely sorry for the accident and that is exactly what it was and accident. I hate that this happened but 2 wrongs do not make a right.
[ Report Abuse ]
I have known Mike Joyce for many years and know that he would never run away from responsibility. This was truly a tragic accident and had he known he did it he would be the first to take responsibility for his actions. He has one of the kindest hearts of anyone that I have ever known. Let him come home to the people that care and support him so that he can deal with this around friends and family and his young daughter. My prayers are with the family of the victim. Mike, we here in Rockingham County support you.
[ Report Abuse ]
I understand there are going to be some negligence issues in this case, but "Felony leaving the scene?" How can you get hit for leaving the scene of an accident if you never knew there was one. I was sitting at a stop light one day and had a car rear end my truck at 50 mph. I NEVER FELT IT. Do you really think he could feel this man in the wheelchair? The fact that this was a tractor trailer is the whole reason this is being made into felony issue.
[ Report Abuse ]
|
Popular Searches Powered by Local.com |
- Prosecutor: Amanda Knox taunted, killed roommate
- H1N1 cases down; vaccine access up
- Riots in Cairo follow World Cup defeat
- Plea deal reached in Wal-Mart trial
- Suspect in slayings dies in shootout
- Fans mourn end of 'Oprah' show
- Right-wing activists storm TV station
- Arrests in human fat ring in Peru
- Senate vote next step on health bill road
- Google OS: End of the hard drive?
- Students hold buildings in protest
- CDC: H1N1 cases down, vaccine availability up
- Charge against Blackwater guard dropped
- Oprah ending talk show in 2011
- 'Summers were the worst,' says woman in sex abuse case
- Senate vote next step on what could be a long road for health care
- Attorney: Fort Hood suspect to be held in hospital
- Burned Florida teen having skin graft surgery
- New cervical cancer screening guidelines released
- Ex-U.S. official, wife to plead guilty in Cuba spy case
- Scores missing after China mine blast
- Bacteria prompts nasal spray recall in U.S., Europe
- Blind students sing upon school supplies' arrival
- Peru: Arrests made in ring that sold human fat
- Right-wing activists storm TV station over 'bias'
- Football fever turns nasty in Cairo
- Man who killed wife while dreaming is released
- Police find body, 3 rifles after Saipan shooting spree
- Parts of Scotland, England underwater, 11 missing
- Suspected drone kills 8 militants in Pakistan
- Prosecutor: Knox tortured roommate
- Florida men sentenced for plotting terror attacks
- Wal-Mart line jumper to plead guilty to resisting arrest
- 'Summers were the worst,' Mohler family accuser says
- Burned Florida teen having skin graft surgery
- Hospital hearing sought for Fort Hood suspect
- Man faces murder charge in Shaniya Davis case
- Suspects sold fat harvested from corpses, authorities say
- Police: Suspect in Arkansas slayings killed in shootout
- Gay teen's grisly slaying ignites protests
- Scrutiny for cancer screenings
- Can your doctor spot H1N1?
- Purpose found after loved ones' suicides
- CDC: H1N1 cases down, vaccine availability grows
- 'I want my mammograms!'
- What to expect in Saturday health care vote
- New cervical cancer screening guidelines released
- Vicks nasal spray recalled over bacteria
- Two men reflect national divide over health reform
- HIV+ soccer team scores against stigma
- Syracuse uses 22-1 run to topple No. 6 Carolina
- Turner's double-double lifts No. 15 Ohio St. by Cal
- Peter King's Game Plan: What to watch in Week 11
- LeBron drops 40 as Cavs pull away from Pacers
- No. 6 Boise State faces off with Utah State
- Death of Brees' mother ruled a suicide
- Ailing Orton misses third straight Denver practice
- Giants LB Pierce out indefinitely with neck injury
- Knicks decide against signing free-agent Iverson
- McGrady wants to play right now; Rockets say no
- Hundreds Greet Miles Ferguson on Return Home to Portsmouth
- UPDATE: Police Investigate 'Gruesome' Murder in South Charleston, Name Released
- Miley Cyrus Tour Bus Overturns in Va., Killing 1
- Man Shot Five Times at a Home in Kanawha County, Name Released
- Man Shot in South Charleston, Found Near Mound
- Ambulance Crashes while En Route to Accident, 3 Hurt
- Racial Profiling Allegations in Huntington; HPD Chief Said He Was Barred from News Conference
- One Dead in Boyd County Crash, Name Released
- Jimmy John's Delivery Guy Robbed After Making Delivery
- Child Hit By Bus in Front of School
- Hundreds Greet Miles Ferguson on Return Home to Portsmouth
602 Comments - One Dead in Boyd County Crash, Name Released
55 Comments - Huntington City Council Members Discuss Violence in Downtown Bars
30 Comments - Ambulance Crashes while En Route to Accident, 3 Hurt
23 Comments - MCTC Picks New Name, Initials Remain the Same
19 Comments - UPDATE: Two Arrested in Double Carter County Murder
17 Comments
![]() |
| PHONE IN YOUR YELLS TO: 1-866-616-5354 |
![]() |
Full 2010 Olympic coverage from the WSAZ Olympic Zone. Coverage begins Friday, Feb. 12, at 7:30p with the Opening Ceremony on WSAZ |
![]() |
A glittering holiday show full of fun and surprises for the whole family! Children thrill as Santa takes them on a magical ride to his workshop. |
![]() |
Healthy Connections Find a local health professional |
![]() |
A collection of resources here to help Moms weather the daily storms that come along with parenting. |
| SOMC Very good things are happening here |
|
| WV Lottery Nightly drawings and numbers |
|
| Big Sandy For all your furniture and appliance needs |
|
| Healthy Tri-State Tips to live a healthier lifestyle |





