COLUMBUS, Ohio (AP) - A group challenging a policy used to enforce Ohio's ban on workplace smoking says a judge's ruling in favor of a Columbus bar means other taverns who have been cited by the Ohio Department of Health could have their violations tossed.

The state is appealing the Franklin County ruling, which says the department exceeded its authority by holding Zeno's bar responsible for the actions of its patrons.

Judge David Cain says the department fined Zeno's despite "no smoking" signs, the removal of ashtrays and requests by employees
that smokers extinguish cigarettes.

The bar was defended by the Columbus-based 1851 Center for
Constitutional Law.

Health department Director Alvin Jackson says the decision is surprising because dozens of other cases have been decided in the
state's favor. The law center says the case is different because
the others were administrative reviews and because the attorney
general has sought to make an example of Zeno's.