Leah Hickman Case Causing Fear
Leah Hickman Case Causing Fear Save Email Print
Posted: 4:21 PM Dec 31, 2007
 Last Updated: 6:14 PM Jan 2, 2008
 Reporter: Carrie Cline
Email Address: carrie.cline@wsaz.com
121 comments
A | A | A

While Leah Hickman's body is finally resting in peace, many people in Huntington are living in fear. With no arrests, no suspects and no leads in this murder case, an uneasy feeling is setting in.
With no motive and no explanation, it's hard to relax.
A killer is on the loose. Who can relax knowing that? Police are working very hard and they're still working this case around the clock, but they're coming up empty and that's leaving many full of worries.

Despite the sunny, clear day, an uneasy, eerie cloud still hovers over the neighborhood where Leah mysteriously disappeared. Her body--found one week later in the basement of her apartment building.
Young women who must walk through here, travel in groups and with hurried steps.

“It makes me real nervous. My sister lives on 5th St. and my dad on 1st St. I walk this alley constantly,” said Courtney Otts.

Because Courtney often has no choice but to walk alone, she packs her companion.

“My dad bought it for me a week ago to be on the safe side.
Does a knife make you feel safer? Yeah, because I know how to use it. I was in the military. I'm good with a knife,” said Courtney.

“I used to go to work and about my day and didn't care if anyone knew where I was. Now, I call my parents when I leave for work and when I return from work. I don't go out at night and if I do someone always knows where I am at all times,” said Stacy Haverland.

Stacy lives all the way across town from where Leah disappeared. But, because she's a Marshall University student in the same age range as Leah, she's worried.

“I’m actually very nervous and I’m surprised the person is still out there,” said Stacy.

“Do you have any reason to believe he or she will strike again? No, not at this time,” said Lt. Rocky Johnson.

Lt. Johnson has worked the case around the clock. He says he wishes he could put people's minds at ease, but the truth is--there are still too many unknowns.

“It could be a random act--not sure. We're not looking at that right now, but it could be and we want to caution people to be aware--don't be scared or paranoid,” said Lt. Johnson.

Comments continue to pour into our webchannel at wsaz.com--many about this fear factor.
Beth, the parent of a Marshall student, wrote, "as a parent, it is a terrifying thought to send my child back with a killer out there".
However, not everyone is so worried. Another person wrote, "also, as a Marshall student, I am not afraid to go back. I practice common sense safety and know how to protect myself".
More Stories
Free 4th of July Meal For Those In Need

Man of "Monkee" Fame Comes to Summer Motion

Tea Parties Scheduled for Huntington and Kentucky Saturday

Holiday Weekend Outdoor Report

 Nitro Residents Upset Over No Thru Traffic Road Sign

Floyd County Course Renewed

Search for Missing St. Albans Man

AP: Sarah Palin Resigning as Governor this Month
Post Your Comments
First Name:
Location:
Enter Comments: characters left
Email (optional):
By posting this comment I have read and agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy:
You must agree to the Terms of Service to continue.
Read Comments
Comments are posted from viewers like you and do not always reflect the views of this station.
Posted by: MovingInMay on Feb 26, 2008 at 11:46 PM
Why haven't we heard anything on this case? I can't believe there is someone out there living with the fact that they killed someone else. I can only hope the grief is going to eventually ruin their own life. I can't help but look at everyone as a killer when I drive down the road (way too unsafe to walk). It's sad to feel safer in larger cities. Killer, we're going to get you. You will pay.
Posted by: Belinda Dean on Feb 23, 2008 at 12:08 AM
I live in Ohio and I listen to see if they have caught the murderer. It is so sad that this had to happen. I pray for the family and all the kids that go to the college. This has to be difficult for all who is involved in solving this murder. I know in time God will reveal the killer. Belinda
Posted by: Anonymous on Feb 11, 2008 at 10:29 PM
What is taking so long?
Posted by: in response to on Jan 27, 2008 at 11:00 PM
in response to jessica. what you dont understand is that it would leave a token. that token could be retrieved. plus, who say's the messages were deleted? we are to just assume they were and not check? use logic jessica.
Posted by: Anonymous on Jan 27, 2008 at 10:57 PM
two people deleted her from their friends list when she either disapeared/was found dead. now, who's friend would delete someone that they were unexpectedly mourning? no you would want to keep them on your list... that alone is suspicious.. i dont know if it's been checked out yet.
Posted by: Jessica on Jan 27, 2008 at 01:47 PM
I read below that someone said for the police to login to her myspace..but, what u don't seem to understand is that..yeah, that would be great to check her messages..but, if say the killer had messaged her or she had messaged the killer..then, all the killer would have to do is delete their myspace and all the messages and so forth would be deleted along with their profile.
Posted by: Friend on Jan 27, 2008 at 12:27 AM
I agree with Greg. I am one of Leah's close friends and to know that the president of Marshall University (which Leah and I both attend) sounds so very insensitive. I was appauled when I read the comment. He may have not intended it that way but being in such a prestigious position, he should have considered the medium of the statement and knew that people were reading this (not directly speaking with him). I was half tempted to go to his office and discuss it with him...but that is more trouble than it is worth.
Posted by: SAD on Jan 24, 2008 at 08:34 AM
Kathy D one question did you call the police and report that the drug deal was going on or did you just look the other way? If you did not report it you are part of the problem.
Posted by: SAD on Jan 24, 2008 at 08:27 AM
Jean and Terry why is so important how she died the most important question is who did it. Does your nose bother you so much that you have to know the details? What if it were your daughter and you read all the post. It would be like her death all over again. Have some respect for the families. I am sure they are having a hard time dealing with the loss!! Or have you lost the compassion for other peoples feelings?
Posted by: Greg on Jan 20, 2008 at 11:02 AM
In Sundays Gazette Mail 1-20-08, MU President Stephen Kopp stated "Students and parents decide where a student lives,and students decide whom they associate with. These decisions sometimes have bad consequences." It sounds as if Kopp is actually blaming the victim, Leah Hickman for her homicide. I feel these comments were unappropriate. As to date, the HPD has not released any information that would support this statement.
Posted by: Terry on Jan 18, 2008 at 02:04 PM
Thank you Jean for stating what so many of us feel.I absolutely believe we all are entitled to know what happened. Was the killer/killers so elusive that there are simply no clues.Still, what happened to Leah on that friday evening before Christmas???
Posted by: Jean on Jan 17, 2008 at 08:50 PM
I am a woman and "VERY" concerned that the Huntington police department has not released any information on the collage girl named Leagh that was found dead under apartment building. Was she murdered ?? Was she raped ??? The women in this area have the right to know. Has the Huntington police depart. got the right to withhold information from the public ??? This is not right, we have the right to know "HOW" she died so we will know if we have a killer and rappest out there. It's been a month now.
Posted by: Jewell on Jan 17, 2008 at 11:52 AM
I'm not so sure about that... Yes, it does show where she last logged in her myspace on dec.14th... Leah is the only one that can change the last login date.. unless of course the police has her password... Am I right or wrong??
Posted by: in explanation on Jan 17, 2008 at 02:18 AM
in explaining the myspace thing. when you log into your page (as the user) when you sign in, it changes your last login date to reflect the last date you've logged in. So at the top left of the page, her myspace still says dec. 14th. Which means police have not obtained access to her myspace account, or otherwise, it would be shown with a more recent date. Not before the dissaperance as it shows in this case.
Posted by: Anonymous on Jan 16, 2008 at 12:33 PM
OH, SISTER SISTER
Posted by: Jewell on Jan 15, 2008 at 11:19 PM
O.K. readers.. I think it's time we give up on this.. Just maybe the family of Leah has requested that nothing is to be released to the public!!
Posted by: anon on Jan 15, 2008 at 09:58 PM
since someone mentioned MY SPACE i cant catch on to what you all are saying since so many people catch on. SOMEONE PLEASE TELL US.
Posted by: Jewell on Jan 14, 2008 at 11:20 PM
I just read my comment... I see I made a couple of spelling mistakes.. get ready readers.. I'm sure someone will have to comment that I can't spell.. Actually, I spell very well.. I was rushed.. have your fun!!
Posted by: Jewell on Jan 14, 2008 at 03:19 PM
O.K. I went to Leah's myspace page.. either I can't see of I'm just not catching on... I see absolutely nothing that would give a clue to solving this case... Yes, I did see where she last signed in in 12-14-07 That makes since...that was the day she disappeared!! I sure wish someone would shed some light on that comment!! I'M LOST!! I have noticed where some were still messaging her...I'm just not catching on!!
Posted by: in response to on Jan 11, 2008 at 01:05 AM
Sarah - Thank YOU! This is what I keep trying to scream to folks. CHECK HER MYSPACE PAGE! That is one STRONG key piece of evidence the HPD continues to overlook.
Posted by: Sarah on Jan 7, 2008 at 04:27 PM
Someone mentioned Myspace in an earlier comment. I think their point was quite valid. Seems like the "older" generation doesn't realize how important social networking site like Myspace and Facebook are to people Leah's age. So much information could be found by logging into her account. Both messaging that happened before AND after Leah's death.
Posted by: Anonymous on Jan 7, 2008 at 04:01 PM
How terrible for her family the way this investigation is going.
Posted by: Robert on Jan 7, 2008 at 03:30 PM
People should be afraid. Crime is up due to outside drug dealers selling their garbage here. The addicts they help create commit the majority of the crimes. What did Mayor Felinton do when he was first elected? He fired many of the street cops. That was the beginning of troubles in Huntington. Criminals can openly do their deeds with very little fear that an officer may just happen to drive by. It is time to hire more cops and crackdown on the dealers. The junkies should be offered help, if they refuse, lock them up too. Also, the law abiding citizens should take firearms training and get a Concealed Carry Permit. Nothing stops criminals better than when intended "victims" fight back. And, when the intended victim is armed, all the better. It is cheaper to bury a thug than to incarcerate one.
Posted by: Kathy D. on Jan 7, 2008 at 03:17 PM
I admit I am afraid to go to downtown Huntington. I make sure someone goes with me. I understand the fear the people who live downtown, work and go to school are feeling. I think it would be the right thing for the police to release enough information at least to let people know if Leah was THE target or if this was a random crime by chance. I can't help thinking that its someone close enough to know the lack of security in the building, to know the layout of the place to hide a body. The HPD do not need to give out the information pertinent to solving this case just enough information to ease some fears or to put up the alert. Huntington is NOT a safe place. I have seen druggies dealing right out in the open from Detroit, Columbus, Maryland etc. You know two cars don't pull up next to each other on the McD's parking lot and exchange briefcases unless its a dirty deal going down. HPD put down your doughnuts and stop this crime invasion! Huntington is easy pickins.
Posted by: Robert on Jan 7, 2008 at 10:13 AM
TO BEVY, you say "I foresee a lot of "accidental" deaths from people trying to protect themselves against nothing. It scares me to think I might be walking down the street and some paranoid person pulls a weapon on me, thinking I might be bad. Scary thought" Perhaps you should read up on the statistics of states that have enacted laws allowing law abiding citizens to obtain Concealed Carry Permits. Your fears are irrational that you would fear a law abiding citizen being armed more than you fear some robber or rapist grabbing you. Guns are not scary when carried by the good guys.
Posted by: anon on Jan 6, 2008 at 11:52 PM
let's get leah back on the front page. don't let her be forgotten!
Posted by: unknown on Jan 6, 2008 at 07:06 PM
i agree with some ppls comments down blow...They need to get a psychics to at least see what they say... ppl really do have the gift... they even have onces for murder cases to tell how it was done and where it was at.... If the police dont do it.. then i think leahs parents should go to one to see what they kind find out and tell the police... i just hope the info they get wont be as bad as some of the rummors going around about who ppl think killed her..... God bless you leah....
Posted by: Anonymous on Jan 6, 2008 at 03:33 PM
they keep updates in the paper form of the herald-dispatch. Its so slow because in real life..police work and forensic work is not like CSI on tv..this is not a show. Things dont get solved in 35 minutes. Information will come out as soon as its 100% accurate and ready to be released to the masses. There is no need for female students to be afraid, not only is there a self defense class, MUPD also offers an escort service for on campus residents. Yellow cab is also another option.
Posted by: anonymous on Jan 6, 2008 at 02:31 PM
I agree with a lot of these postings. Poor Leah. Her case will soon be a "cold case" and the general public will never hear anything about her again. We'll never know who murdered her, or how or why they murdered her. Soooo saaadd!!
Posted by: debbie on Jan 6, 2008 at 09:15 AM
I totally agree with you.We all deserve to know what the hpd isn't saying.What is the big secret and what is it going to hurt?Oh and please nobody say that it might hamper the investigation because I'll remind you of that six or twelve months down the road when nothing has changed.Yes,I am very angry that nothing is being said on the progress that Leah's case may or may not be having.I think they got NOTHING!
Posted by: question on Jan 6, 2008 at 12:21 AM
The cops are overlooking a strong piece of evidence. Leahs Myspace Page. The date last shown as her logging in, was the 14th of December. Which means, NOBODY has signed into her myspace account since the 14th. Not once, since her dissapearance. This means LEAHS MYSPACE PAGE HAS YET TO BE SIGNED INTO! Why has this KEY piece of evidence been overlooked? Her page is frozen in time. December 14, 2007. Police should be logging into her myspace page for any key pieces of evidence as to previous conversations and possible meetings, etc. this is a huge piece of potential evidence that has not been looked into?
Posted by: Student on Jan 5, 2008 at 11:10 PM
Classes start in a week! There are thousands upon thousands of scared students and parents. Something has to be released soon.
Posted by: Anonymous on Jan 5, 2008 at 10:24 PM
To bill, the four kids you are talking about was not killed in housing projects. If they were killed in the projects the killers would have been caught a long time ago because of the video cameras they installed. My heart goes out to Leahs friends and family.
Posted by: Anonymous on Jan 5, 2008 at 10:10 PM
Alot of ppl don't believe in psychics but there are ppl that do have the gift. What would it hurt to try one?
Posted by: Lindsay on Jan 5, 2008 at 07:19 PM
I am a Marshall Student. I just wanted to let the female students know that MU offers a self defense class for awareness and protection against rape and agression. I have taken it. It is taught by a few MUPD officers and I highly reccommend it.
Posted by: Why? on Jan 5, 2008 at 01:17 AM
Has have all the reports regarding this case STOPPED? Press conference, police update..anything?
Posted by: Hope4Justice on Jan 4, 2008 at 10:43 PM
Kathryn .. I agree with you 100% on more protection for the campus. I think it would be such a worry to be a parent out of state or out of county worrying about your child. I also think this weighs heavily on the mind of all students attending Marshall. Even if HPD can't release information about the case .. please do whatever it takes to protect the students as much as possible and do whatever it takes to help them feel safe!! Before long I do feel as a community that we all deserve answers.
Posted by: Anonymous on Jan 4, 2008 at 05:23 PM
I was in one of Leah's classes...when I saw the posters and the news, especially when they found her body...it just felt so weird and so wrong. Obviously, it's wrong no matter what...but she was such a nice girl, and I can't imagine why anyone would want to hurt someone like her...I guess no one will ever be able to figure that out. I wish and hope for peace for the family and for this case to be solved. Sadly, we can never have Leah back, but I hope that we can avenge her by finding who did this and making him or her pay.
Posted by: Anonymous on Jan 4, 2008 at 04:03 PM
Can we get more coverage for this murder case? Another press conference with the police... something? It already feels as if Leah's tragic death is a distant memory. Another murder case left unsolved...
Posted by: Cindy on Jan 4, 2008 at 02:31 PM
Thought people might like to know that there is a memorial page for Leah on the findagrave site. You can go to the site and type Leah Nicole Hickman in the search engine...you don't need to put anything else. It's a nice site and you can leave virtual flowers and notes, etc.
Posted by: Anonymous on Jan 4, 2008 at 12:45 PM
This is to Debbie the 4 kids had names (Megan Poston, Michael Dillon, Eddrick Clark and Donte Ward). Have some compassion for all the families who have lost loved ones to a wrongful death. My prayers go out to the Hickman family.
Posted by: Emily on Jan 4, 2008 at 09:09 AM
Why not use one of those psychics you see on TV? I know it sounds ridiculous, but it's better than nothing. Did she take a taxi to McDonald's? Check those guys out, maybe one of them wanted more than he was owed....
Posted by: Anonymous on Jan 4, 2008 at 08:51 AM
What are people getting away with this kind of stuff? 4 teens-2yrs ago, labor&delivery nurse and kids( trail put off again and again ), Angela Schneider !!!! This is crazy. People do things like this and then get no punishment until judgement day. Then they will do there time !!
Posted by: kathryn on Jan 4, 2008 at 01:02 AM
Everyone understands that to solve a case it takes time and sharing information that cannot be substantiated or that would compromise a case will not be discussed with the public. But, the Huntington Police, FBI, & Marshal administration need to assure the students and parents some information, some reassurances BEFORE classes begin next week. Parents have warned their daughters, and sons, to be careful, to call, to be safe. I'm sure Leah's parent's told her the same thing. Telling us (parents) to do the things we already do is not reassuring. Do Marshall and Huntington have more officers on duty? Do they have officers on bicycles, or walking the beat in the campus area? The Tri-state areas sympathizes with Leah's family and pray for answers to help them bring closure.
Posted by: anonymous on Jan 4, 2008 at 12:51 AM
wsaz why havent you posted the last two messages about her myspace page. are you afraid someone will uncover what HPD already hasnt
Posted by: Concerned on Jan 3, 2008 at 11:34 PM
Why has coverage stopped regarding Leah? Any updates from the HPD? Where do things stand now. I watch the news daily and have heard nothing else about this case since 12/31.
Posted by: Hope4Justice on Jan 3, 2008 at 11:11 PM
I think we all agree on some things .. Leah's murder was a horrible, senseless act and we all want justice. I think we all agree that we want to feel safe again and we want to see Huntington become safer. I believe HPD will come through. Surely they must know more. Hopefully, they are building their case and will just will not release the information in fear of jeopardizing the case. Common sense tells us they have to know more .. cause of death and lots of other things. I think as a community we support them and as a community we support Leah's family with prayers and in any way we can .. time will tell shortly if HPD is just playing their cards close. Another poster says more information will be released by the weekend. Surely justice will be served soon. If not, then I think we should begin to question our law enforcement and the leadership of this city. Someone needs to pay. To Leah's family .. I pray for you and think of the loss you have suffered. May God be with you.
Posted by: Anonymous on Jan 3, 2008 at 09:06 PM
As far as knowing if to be afraid or not.ALWAYS BE AWARE!Look how missing and murdered people there are all over the US..Don't be paralyzed,but be aware of surrounding at all times...Travel in 2's or more..HPD giving information has nothing to do with common sense.
Posted by: To Donna on Jan 3, 2008 at 05:21 PM
I am not Sarah but I did a google search on Angela Schneider and it says she was murdered in an upscale Huntington neighborhood in 2005 and it was never solved. She was 29 years old. I did not see a picture of Angela but I do agree that Samantha Burns and Leah Hickman look very similar to each other.
Posted by: unknown on Jan 3, 2008 at 04:55 PM
check out the hearld dispatch's site- they are still covering this case.
Posted by: Bev on Jan 3, 2008 at 04:45 PM
My neighbor was living with her infant son alone while her husband was out of town working on his master's degree. Luckily he is finished and came home in time to stop a burgler. The person threw a brick through their window and was part of the way in their home when her husband stuck his shotgun in their face. This is why people are afraid. I can't believe this person just decided to break into an occupied home. I can't help but wonder if they have been watching her and thought she was a single mom. I'm also hearing a LOT of things about Leah that I will not repeat b/c they are nasty rumors and nobody knows if they are true. I think we should wait for toxicological test before we start spreading some of these rumors. As I said before these young people who are dying don't deserve this. God help us all.
Posted by: Concerned on Jan 3, 2008 at 04:04 PM
We all need some answers, as to our safety!
Posted by: Mary on Jan 3, 2008 at 01:36 PM
No one knows if this was a random act nor can they say they don't think this person will strike again. I am the mother of a 20 year girl and I have always been very protective but I am now to the point of being forced to be overprotective. My daughter lives in Huntington and she must call me before she walks out her front door of her home, work or school and I talk to her until I know she is safely in her car and then she calls before getting out of her car and again I talk to her until she is inside. She is robbed of any privacy now that I must know where she is going and who she is with. My prayer are with Leah's family and every young girl in the City of Huntington.
Posted by: Marshall Grad. Student on Jan 3, 2008 at 10:25 AM
I am a Graduate Student at Marshall. I travel to Huntington only at night for night classes. By the time I get to MU the parking lots are full and I must walk a great distance to my classes...at night...in the dark...alone. I'll tell you the truth, after all of this...I am scared to go back to class on the 15th. Something needs to be done to help us students feel safe on campus, because right now...we don't.
Posted by: Judith on Jan 3, 2008 at 10:00 AM
If there is no imminent danger, why should the police have to givee information? Why should the police tip their hands and jeprodize their investigation? I think this is just silly.
Posted by: A loving mother on Jan 3, 2008 at 08:48 AM
Finally we may have some answers by this weekend. A report on the radio this morning said they have received back some test results and that more info will be released by this weekend. I believe the police and FBI do have a suspect or suspects.
Posted by: Mason Co. on Jan 3, 2008 at 08:14 AM
The story on TV was that the building was being under consturction! Word on the streets here is "That the workers on that Job have packed up and moved on"Is this what happened and if so where are they and why did they go???Everyone watching this coverage was feeling pain for the FAMILY AND FRIENDS,yet as of today nobody knows anything about her death!What is the big secret that is NOT BEING TOLD?Everyone has the right to hear something.If there are no leads then how could the answers hurt the Invest.of this young ,beautiful womans murder?
Posted by: anon61 on Jan 3, 2008 at 07:46 AM
This is not the work of a serial killer. This is someone very close and the police know this. Something will be said after the lab work is received. This is someone who knew the layout of the building, knew she was alone in the huge apartment complex and knew no one would hear her. This person knew someone was out of town and the other 2 apartments were vacant. It only leaves a handful of people if you know what I mean. HPD knows exactly what they're doing. The person who did this is reading everything and I hope so. They're coming after YOU and always be looking over YOUR shoulder, male, female or both.
Posted by: Bevy on Jan 3, 2008 at 12:37 AM
I am a Marshall Grad student, and I lived in Huntington while doing my undergrad courses. There is crime everywhere, in every city. It seems that colleges/universities always bring a lot to the community, business, money, crime, drugs, etc. It's not the universities' fault we have crime areas in Huntington. I hate to hear about a family loosing a loved one for any reason, and I hope the culprit in this case is caught. Whether a stranger or a familiar, he/she deserves to be punished. What scares me the most is hearing everyone talking about carrying weapons. I don't have any problem with weapons, if a person really knows how to use them, and doesn't let fear control them. People beware of carrying weapons in fear. That can really turn ugly. I foresee a lot of "accidental" deaths from people trying to protect themselves against nothing. It scares me to think I might be walking down the street and some paranoid person pulls a weapon on me, thinking I might be bad. Scary thought
Posted by: Donna on Jan 3, 2008 at 12:29 AM
this is to sarah- you mentioned angela schnieder, who is she maybe you need to get the word out so we know.
Posted by: Marshall Student on Jan 2, 2008 at 11:07 PM
People think they know how to use a knife or know how to protect themselves, and I think if it came down to someone grabbing you, you wouldn't. I'm very afraid to go back, even though I live on campus. The Huntington Police Department haven't showed us any information as to why we think we'd be safe, I just hope Marshall police will be out heavier than ever before to protect the students on campus. No one ever thinks this will happen to them, I'm sure Leah didn't, so no one has the right to say "Yea, I'm safe" or "Yea, I can take care of myself". I think in a time like this, we just need to pray for our own safty and our friends and family. This could happened and has happened in other areas, but it hitting so "close to home" has made us realize.
Posted by: MU Student on Jan 2, 2008 at 11:00 PM
It is easy to sit back and accuse the Marshall student community of being too scared or anxious however your not the one that has to walk to your car alone after evening classes or live by yourself in a cheap student apartment in downtown Huntington. I think a little understanding and compassion towards others feelings would go a long way.
Posted by: RIP Leah on Jan 2, 2008 at 10:26 PM
One of my favorite quotes is "God breaks our hearts to prove to us He only takes the best." I have lost too many precious people in my life and this always brought me comfort. Leah didn't deserve to die the way she did, but she is among the best now. I continue to pray for her family. HPD, I hope you can bring closure soon.
Posted by: Student on Jan 2, 2008 at 09:36 PM
You're right Kathleen. It is different because Leah was one of our own. We can't help but wonder, 'Why Leah?'...it could have been me, it could have been my best friend. Those are scary thoughts; realistic thoughts. You're right, it is the real world...and sometimes, the real world is scary. I pray for the police to bring justice for Leah and peace for her peers. Rest in peace Pretty Angel.
Posted by: Martha on Jan 2, 2008 at 09:20 PM
I am sick of hearing about how incompetent some feel our police department is. Let's consider personal responsibility for a moment. Those accusing our police of doing a less than professional job...I guess all of you are perfect law abiding people who have never broken any law? If the public acted more responsibly, then the task of keeping order would actually be possible. Further, anyone who harbors a criminal is as guilty as the one who commits the act. We have a subculture that believes it is wrong to rat out one of their own. Expect crime in your neighborhood when you protect the criminals.
Posted by: Tell me if im wrong !! on Jan 2, 2008 at 09:08 PM
The person who has done this horrible thing knows what he or she did . The last thing they would want to do is run (YOU WOULD THINK) !!! . So why not let people know what happened . The only reason I could think of is in respect of the family . However the ones that are scared don't even know what it is they are scared of . I'm just thinking you could say what happened without saying who you thought did it . If the police are scared that someone might come foreword and say they was guilty and them not be ( witch is crazy ) then just don't release every single little detail (which they shouldn't do anyway's).
Posted by: MU Student on Jan 2, 2008 at 08:58 PM
Some of those posting on here seem so heartless. I fear now because, although I have my opinion on who I think committed this crime, I really have no idea who did it! Should I continue to be afraid thinking that some crazy killer is on the loose or should I feel relieved thinking that someone close to Leah carried out something so tragic?? Which is worse?
Posted by: Concerned2 on Jan 2, 2008 at 08:23 PM
we need to hear from the hpd soon..i cant believe that they have no leads they are too smart not to have leads..those of us that live near the area need to know more..was this an isolated case, or is there a killer on the loose to harm others...was this just directed toward leah..hpd has got to know something...i cant help but wonder if the person responsible was someone leah knew and not just a person off the street..most of those that knew leah have expressed how wonderful she was.. could it have been a jealous friend, old aquaintance or someone closer to leah...was she able to fight the person or persons who did this to her...if the public or young women should really be in fear then let them know...it would relieve a lot of people if we knew that the hpd had some type of leads...just tell us that they have leads so that we know our hpd is on the case spring classes begin in less than 2wks i am afraid to even walk after my night classes to my car....hpd please catch this person.... .
Posted by: tri-state resident on Jan 2, 2008 at 07:36 PM
Although I did not have the pleasure of knowing Leah, she is someones daughter, sister, family and friend. I know there are alot of questions and fears, but let's try to do something good in this and PRAY for her familt and loved ones who now have the hard task of trying to make it through each day. Only GOD above and the "killer" know the true story and I pray that the "hidden things" will come to light as this person will be prosecuted. I ask all of you to join with me daily, in prayer for Leah's family. God Bless Them
Posted by: Kathleen on Jan 2, 2008 at 06:07 PM
To Lisa, AMEN Its time for some of the students on campus to realize that this is real life and not some 1 hour crime show. Where all the information is known and oh so easy to obtain. Stop living in fear. Go about your life and just be careful.Crime does happen in Huntington but over all Huntington is still a very safe place to live. I fully understand why the policeman may not want to realise all the information known about the case. But for some reason those on here want to jump to conclusions and walk around all in fear. Don't be afraid. Huntington is no different than what it was before Leah was killed. The only different is that this time it was one of their own. So welcome to the real world
Posted by: Our Town on Jan 2, 2008 at 05:08 PM
As a city resident I would challenge Huntington to step up and not live in fear. It's time that we become more involved in our communities and not let fear dictate our lives. How many of you know your neighbors or take the time to meet the new person that just moved in? Do you realize that there are monthly community meetings that take place all over Huntington? These aren't just for certain people, they are for us, the concerned citizen! We need to create more organized community groups, neighborhood watches, On-Campus groups, etc. and reenergize ourselves to work more closely with police and let these thugs know we're all watching. Let's not be so quick to jump to conclusions on this case or to criticize the police. It's not a 1-hr CSI episode, getting the facts in order takes time and must be done properly. Let's let the police do their jobs and we as citizens should start doing ours so that hopefully we can avoid tragedies like these in the future.
Posted by: MU Student on Jan 2, 2008 at 01:30 PM
I now live in Barboursville but still do not feel rested due to worrying about this case. I am praying for Leah's family & friends AND the police dept. We need to support our city. I have a feeling the HPD have good reasoning behind not telling us more information. I have my opinions on who committed this crime, as do others, and I hope that person will be caught & punished.
Posted by: citizen on Jan 2, 2008 at 01:27 PM
did anyone hear what condition she was in or how she died?
Posted by: Haines on Jan 2, 2008 at 01:19 PM
Typical HPD, They will never find the killer. The only thing they will find is the comfort of their paychecks.
Posted by: Debbie on Jan 2, 2008 at 01:18 PM
Kathy, Samantha Burns' killers were convicted and that's hard to do without a body. Again, apples oranges. Forensics proved the killers of Samantha and will also get this one. There was very little forensics in the gunning down of the other 4 kids.
Posted by: Anon on Jan 2, 2008 at 01:08 PM
Does everyone really think that the person that did this wasn't close to her? Come on, it had to be someone she knew well and it had to be pre meditated. The police aren't letting ANY details out about this whole thing and I personally think that is a good thing. Who ever did this to her knew where she was going to be and when. I haven't heard anything about her cell phone? Was it ever found? I know they said it was turned off and went straight to voicemail? Any way of tracking that down or getting the record from the carrier on what numbers called the phone or text messages? I know they keep track. Come on people, let this girl rest in PEACE in knowing the cruel person that did this is punished!
Posted by: Anonymous on Jan 2, 2008 at 12:40 PM
I work a few blocks from the house Leah was found. I go to work early and I am now afraid. Please find the killer.
Posted by: Anonymous on Jan 2, 2008 at 12:32 PM
It is hard to believe that the police can't say anything. I don't think they are hiding anything I think they don't know anything. They are stumped. Who ever this was must of been very sneeky. Where was she killed at in her apartment or someone else in the building. She could not have been killed in the crawl space unless she was knocked out and they carried her there. I agree with alot of other people. I think it was someone she was close to. Everyone just keep praying for this case God will open it up when the time is right.
Posted by: Anon on Jan 2, 2008 at 12:23 PM
To anonymous Marshall student: I know what you mean! I'm also a 21 year old student living alone and it's terrifying! I've slept with lights on ever since and have not felt rested or safe since returning to Huntington. I'm graduating in May, and I've never been more ready! Something has to break in this case soon!! Good luck HPD, don't let us down!
Posted by: Jewell on Jan 2, 2008 at 11:27 AM
To snowbunny... I don't think this person is out to get anyone!! I truly believe this person wanted Leah only!! This was a friend or relative! MY OPINION ONLY!!
Posted by: Jewell on Jan 2, 2008 at 11:25 AM
The police will handle this their way!! I have a feeling, we are all in for a big surprise!! Our officers need our support!! They know what they are doing, and I have no doubt they know exactly who commited this horrible act!
Posted by: Kathy on Jan 2, 2008 at 11:12 AM
Lisa, I have faith in Holbrook & the "beat" cops but not in these "detectives". I'm smart enough to know real life's not "Law & Order" BUT tell me what these "detectives" here HAVE solved? THEY didn't solve Samantha Burn's case. They haven't found who shot those 4 teens. IF they have a suspect, WHY haven't they arrested someone yet? How CAN you possibly defend them for overlooking her body in her own building? Come on. Would you buy that if she were YOUR child? This is a college town where students are now scared BECAUSE they don't know if the killer is some nut running loose in town or if she was THE target so they're safe. THEY too have a right to know something because THEY are scared & rightly so. Yes, things happen here as everywhere BUT at least other places they TRY to clean up the streets. Here the BEAT cops do THEIR best but someone shuts them down letting the scum back out Huntington's safe as ever? PULEEZE. You must live among the rich folks
Posted by: Kathy on Jan 2, 2008 at 11:04 AM
Lisa, I must disagree. Huntington is as safe as it's "always been"? How long have you lived here? I've lived here since 1980 & I (along with a LOT of long-time residents)can tell you that it is a LONG way from being "like it used to be" in ANY way It's NO longer SAFE in any sense of the word any more than it's a clean, economically viable city anymore! You must live/work/attend school in another city other than the rest of us do because I'm not the only one who sees what Huntington has become! You tell me ONE area that is still safe in Huntington ok? Show it to us. The only one even remotely safe is the rich section around the Park & the drugs are getting THERE too so it won't be safe soon either We used to walk downtown even after dark in the 80's/early 90's; walk at River Park etc. Can you do THAT now safely? Well, if you can, then more power to ya cause the rest of us are afraid to! They've let the 4 kids case grow COLD & so will Leah's. Get real!
Posted by: stella on Jan 2, 2008 at 10:36 AM
I think alot of people believe like anonymous stated earlier that it might be someone very close to Leah.
Posted by: Debbie on Jan 2, 2008 at 10:27 AM
The police are just not telling anyone what they know, they know the cause of death, but that haven't told us that either. I bet they've got an idea who did it.
Posted by: Anonymous on Jan 2, 2008 at 10:08 AM
I wish the police would say at least SOMETHING. I also am a 21 year old female journalism student and I am terrified of leaving my apartment, day or night. I have not slept well since. It's times like these I wish I had a room mate, or that my apartment allowed dogs. All of my female coworkers and friends are afraid as well, and even some males too. Huntington police need to STEP UP and at least say SOMETHING to ease the minds of the hundreds of young women coming back to campus in a little over a week. They have to know at least some information by now.
Posted by: Lisa on Jan 2, 2008 at 09:48 AM
Some of you people making comments act like a true Crime scene and murder cases are like Law And Order shows on TV. In the real world they do use dogs to sniff out corpes. Dogs have better senses than we do. And in the real world it does take time to build a case and find the true killer. Huntington is just as safe as it aways has been but gone are the days when we could be careless and think this never happens here. It does happen here. So wake up and be safe.
Posted by: ohio resident on Jan 2, 2008 at 09:26 AM
I truly believe the HPD is working hard and not taking any chances in letting anyone slip through the cracks....Mother of 3.....I agree totally.....100% .....jealousy is the root of all evil......Enough said......Thoughts and Prayers to family and friends
Posted by: Kathy on Jan 2, 2008 at 08:53 AM
Are they even LOOKING for a suspect? This case already seems like it's been placed on back burner & forgotten. What are they DOING about finding who killed this young lady? Huntington residents & Marshall, are you going to just sit here & allow this girl's murder to become a "cold case" like the other 4 young people who were shot and killed? Articles keep saying Leah is "at peace" now...how CAN she be? As far as most of us can tell, NO ONE is doing ANYTHING about finding her killer! Her spirit is NOT going to rest until they do. Leah, those 4 other kids and EVERYONE who is murdered deserves JUSTICE period. Their parents deserve JUSTICE. Their children have been brutally taken away which is THE worst thing any parent could experience. No, catching the killer(s) will never bring back their children BUT they deserve to know that who ripped their lives apart & took their precious childrens' lives is punished And closure? There IS no closure in death, especially children
Posted by: Huntington Resident on Jan 2, 2008 at 08:45 AM
As a husband and a parent I can assure you that I am applying for my concealed weapons permit A.S.A.P. I just purchased my first home in Huntington and now am wondering if I should have looked across the river in Chesapeake. That town is 5 minutes from that crime sceen and has less than half of the crime. Nice to see cops that do there job.
Posted by: Britt on Jan 2, 2008 at 08:25 AM
I think Leah's myspace pic is rally eerie now considering th e cicumstanes.I wonder how long it had been her profile pic and who took it?
Posted by: sarah on Jan 2, 2008 at 08:18 AM
I can't help but notice that Samantha Burns And Leah Hickman look alot similar in they're physical appearance.Does anyone know about Angela Schnieder???
Posted by: snowbunny on Jan 2, 2008 at 06:32 AM
Huntington: arm yourselves.
Posted by: anonymous on Jan 2, 2008 at 01:00 AM
If the police focused on doing their jobs as much as they focus on their fund raisers and satisfying vendettas, they may be able to regain the confidence of the public. Whatever happened to the days when police officers weren't just sniveling little chest beating brats? If they cared more about their work ethic and protecting the public, as they swore to do, many of these incidents would not occur. What about patrolling the streets? Why insinuate that the victims weren't cautious enough, when it is supposed to be the duty of law enforcement to protect them? Where is law enforcement when you need it? Who is really to blame? City, county and state law enforcement officials, why not accept some of the responsibility that rightfully belongs to you?
Posted by: misty. on Jan 2, 2008 at 12:41 AM
to confused: there is no lead,no motive, you try being in there shoes wondering how done it, and why. think about that next time before you point fingers.
Posted by: Anonymous on Jan 2, 2008 at 12:04 AM
I feel that it was not a random act, And the monster that did this had to know about this craw space in the apartment...No outsider or stranger would have known about it unless they had been in there before. I agree with mom of 3 daughters. Hopefully justice will be done for Leah.
Posted by: Anonymous on Jan 1, 2008 at 09:39 PM
Thank you so much wsaz for keeping everyone so informed on this heart wrenching case...my prayers go out to the Hickman family, and we are all praying for justice to be served. I didnt know Leah, but am so drawn to this case and look on here for updates everyday. I do believe and pray too that police have leads and are just staying quiet to build there case. God bless and RIP LEAH!!!
Posted by: Confused on Jan 1, 2008 at 06:53 PM
What is with this why did the HPD use dogs to help find the body. Are they afraid that a dog is smarter than they are. It is a shame that Leah's family had to wait for the HPD to learn what a dog already knows how to do. My prayers go out the the family and friends of Leah.
Posted by: Anonymous on Jan 1, 2008 at 05:37 PM
Someone knows who killed Leah... please let the police know anything you have seen or heard in relation to this case. We need to get this killer off the streets of Huntington!
Posted by: wiggy on Jan 1, 2008 at 05:19 PM
imagine this1\!watch csi bros!
Posted by: anon1 on Jan 1, 2008 at 03:32 PM
This is such a sad case. We moved from the tri state and am glad we did. Dead teenagers on prom night, unsolved...as I remember another young girl Angela Schnieder found naked and dead a couple years ago unsolved, Samantha Burns what a blunder of a case, and now Leah... The police look like such a JOKE to those out of the tri state. Get it together! Your city is falling apart.
Posted by: Bill on Jan 1, 2008 at 03:17 PM
The Huntington Police cannot even find who killed 4 in the housing projects 2 yrs ago.
Posted by: mom of 3 daughters on Jan 1, 2008 at 03:01 PM
I hope for dear Leahs soul to rest in peace that the monster that took her life will be brought to justice and like others i too believe this wasn't random...seems like an act of jealousy from someone close to her..its so frustrating and i didn't even know Leah..but I look here everyday to see if theres an update that they caught her murderer. RIP Leah from a family that didn't know you but thinks about you everyday.........
Posted by: anonymous on Jan 1, 2008 at 02:57 PM
I wish someone would wake up. The majority of people you talk to believe the same way...the person you are looking for is right under their nose...someone they would least suspect.
Posted by: John on Jan 1, 2008 at 02:17 PM
Unfortunately this sad event will probably end up just like Samantha Burns. No arrest, no clues. If the police had a person in mind they could have picked them up and expedited the lab tests. If your beliefs allow, buy a gun learn how to safely use it and practice with real world situations. Practice, practice, practice, the next time some scum bag may be after you. Don't depend on the police. They have demonstrated, time and again, their impotence in doing anything productive.
Posted by: amber on Jan 1, 2008 at 12:11 PM
i am so glad that finally someone cares enough to tell us all the truth. thanks and kudos to WSAZ and the HPD. you all are doign a wonderful job. keep up the good work. thoughts and prayers to the hickman family always.
Posted by: Jacquie on Jan 1, 2008 at 11:41 AM
I live on the Southside, a few blocks toward the park away from where the murder happened, and people in my neighborhood are very afraid. Women that normally walk their dogs or walk alone after dark are afraid to do so, and my husband keeps our outside lights on at night. We just don't feel as safe as we have in our beautiful, formerly safe neighborhood. I would like to see more of a police presence in the area. There are always people on foot walking through the southside looking for work or cutting over to downtown that I seem to be more suspicous of. It makes everyone in the area extremely upset that there are no leads.
Posted by: Martha on Jan 1, 2008 at 10:30 AM
We seem to forget that there are lots of things that the public never knows. I believe that the police know exactly who did this and are simply waiting for the validation to come back from the forensics lab in Charleston. Our legalistic society has put us in a place where before we can detain a murderer, we must prove that the person is, in fact, the murderer. Forget about the damage that can be done in the meantime. Our police department is handling this in a wonderfully professional way and I think that it's important that we continue to support their efforts and trust that they will keep our city safe.
Posted by: Judith on Jan 1, 2008 at 09:19 AM
I dont think you should be afraid. Use commen sense, stay aware. I think thr HPD knows who did this. They are building their case, holding info close to their vests. I belive if the public was in any more danger then we usueley are they would tell us. Watch and see. Live your life your to young to live in fear dont fall for the HYPE. Stay Strong Pray And Live Everyday!!
Posted by: Mandy on Jan 1, 2008 at 05:54 AM
It is a shame that in today's society, it has become that surviving victims become victims all over again in the world of law enforcement when they are mocked at and not believed. It becomes a total life-changing demoralizing experience for someone to come forward. I would hope how soon this changes as we look at the number of unsolved crimes all over the nation. This is sad, but I do not see this changing in today's "justice" system. Perhaps there would be less psychos walking the streets and involving themselves in cases, even, if someone took the time to actually listen and look into a victim's words. To what extent does one have to go to get someone to listen? Perhaps, to their grave.
Posted by: RENEE' WOLFE on Jan 1, 2008 at 05:44 AM
HAVE THE POLICE THOUGHT ABOUT BRINGING IN A PROFILER. LIKE A YOUNG LADY I'VE SEEN ON A&E CRT TV,OR THE DISCOVERY CHANNEL HER NAME IS DALE SOMETHING OR OTHERFROM FLORIDA AND SHES ALWAYS ON THE MONEY. SHE CAN START WHERE THERE IS NOTHING TO GO ON.
Posted by: Travis on Jan 1, 2008 at 02:16 AM
I know it was a mere syntax problem, but I wish to point out that the last quote in this article seems to suggest that Leah Hickman was incapable of common sense and did not know any of the basics of protecting herself. The fight for human survival lies in all of us, for common sense is... well... common.
Posted by: Anonymous on Dec 31, 2007 at 10:05 PM
There is a reason the police are not issuing alerts, it is because they know it wasn't a random act!! It doesn't have the appearance of a random act. Think about it. I wrote an opinion earlier but the powers that be didn't publish it in the comments. So much for freedom of speech.
Posted by: Rob on Dec 31, 2007 at 08:28 PM
People need to be cautious. With the murder of Ms. Hickman and the home invasion, which took place only a couple of blocks away, and all the other crime in that area, people should arm themselves or give serious thought before going to downtown Huntington. Always keep your eyes open. People, lets make being a criminal a risky occupation.
Posted by: Student on Dec 31, 2007 at 08:17 PM
To the family of Leah and the HPD: I am praying for you. May justice be served as soon as possible. As a Marshall student, I was also nervous about returning to Huntington, and the first night back was terrifying. HPD, we're counting on you. Keep us safe. Rest in peace Leah.
Posted by: ashland on Dec 31, 2007 at 08:01 PM
I am confused as to why the police department appear to be playing this down. No reason to be paranoid? A beautiful young lady was murdered and there are many, many other beautiful young ladies in that neighborhood. I would imagine it was someone familiar with the area.. The way her body was disposed of would lead one to believe that. For the love of all that is holy any young lady in that area be extremely careful. Do not walk alone. My heard felt sorrow is with her family and friends.
Posted by: Question? on Dec 31, 2007 at 07:30 PM
WSAZ, how does her parents feel about there being no arrest and no suspects? There has to be more to this and police are just not saying.
Posted by: Anonymous on Dec 31, 2007 at 04:41 PM
Thank you WSAZ for writing a story demonstrating exactly what I am feeling. I am a young, female college student and it is definitely frightening that a killer is still on the loose in Huntington. I continue to feel very anxious being in Huntington. I continue to pray that an arrest is made very soon!
WSAZ.com Most Popular / Most Comments
National Headlines - MSNBC.com
First Warning Hour-By-Hour Forecasts
+ Ashland, KY
+ Athens, OH
+ Beckley, WV
+ Charleston, WV
+ Clarksburg, WV
+ Clay, WV
+ Gallipolis, OH
+ Huntington, WV
+ Ironton, OH
+ Logan, WV
+ Morgantown, WV 		+ Paintsville, KY
+ Parkersburg, WV
+ Pikeville, KY
+ Pomeroy, OH
+ Portsmouth,OH
+ Ripley, WV
+ Spencer, WV
+ Sutton, WV
+ Wayne, WV
+ Wheeling, WV
+ Williamson, WV
SearchKOW Business of the Day
WSAZ.com Sponsor Sections & Links
Healthy Tri-State
Live a healthier lifestyle in 2009
SOMC
Very good things are happening here
Moms4Moms
By moms, for moms
WV Lottery
Nightly drawings and numbers
Big Sandy
For all your furniture and appliance needs