COMPLETE COVERAGE: Michael Merrifield Found Guilty of Murder
COMPLETE COVERAGE: Michael Merrifield Found Guilty of Murder Save Email Print
Posted: 10:08 AM Jan 23, 2008
 Last Updated: 2:26 PM Jan 25, 2008
 Reporter: Amanda Barren
Email Address: amanda.barren@wsaz.com
330 comments Poll Photos
VERDICT: 11pm Coverage
VERDICT: More Reaction at 6:25pm
VERDICT: 6pm Coverage
VERDICT: Judge Reads Verdict
VERDICT: State Reaction at 5:40pm
VERDICT: Reaction at 5:32pm
VERDICT: Reaction at 5:21pm
VERDICT: Just in at 5:13pm
Day 8: Noon Live Report
Day 7: Prosecution Rebuttal Witness
Day 7: Prosecution Second Closing
Day 7: Defense Closing Arguments
Day 7: Prosecution Closing Arguments / Part 2
Day 7: Prosecution Closing Arguments / Part 1
Day 6: 6pm Coverage
Day 6: George Nichols (Defense - Expert)
Day 6: Ken Campbell Testimony (Defense)
Day 6: Clint Gibson Testimony (Defense)
Day 6: Mark Hereford Testimony (Defense)
Day 6: Elijah Young Testimony (Defense)
Day 6: Noon Live Report
Week 1 Overview
Day 5: Merrifield's Friend Testimony (Defense)
Day 5: Merrifield's Friend Testimony (Prosecution)
Day 5: Medical Examiner Testimony #2
Day 5: Medical Examiner Testimony #1
Day 5: Medical Examiner Testimony (Setup)
Day 4: Paramedic Dale Kiddy Testimony
Day 4: Detective Arthur Testimony #2
Day 4: Detective Arthur Testimony #1
Day 3: Eren Testimony (Defense Questions)
Day 3: Eren Testimony (Logan to Hospital)
Day 3: Eren Testimony (Day-of Logan's Death)
Day 3: Eren Testimony (Setup)
Day 3: Noon Report (Pepper Eren Testifies)
Day 2: Overview
Day 2: Merrifield's Call to 911
Day 2: Paramedic Testimony
Day 2: Nurse's Testimony on Logan's Injuries
Day 1: Overview
VIDEO: Trial Introduction
A | A | A

VERDICT / DAY 8 INFO
Amanda Barren reports from Putnam County Circuit Court that Michael Merrifield has been found guilty of murdering Logan Goodall, his ex-girlfriend's son. Merrifield was also found guilty of death of child by guardian or custodian and guilty of sexual abuse by a guardian. He was found not guilty of sexual assault. The jury recommends no mercy on the murder charge, which means Merrifield will spend the rest of his life behind bars. Goodall was two years old when he died at his home in Hurricane in 2005.

 
Are you satisfied with the outcome of the Michael Merrifield trial?
Yes
No
 

The jury deliberated through most of the day with a break for lunch. The jury asked three questions to the judge. They returned their verdict shortly after 5pm. They took a little more than one day to deliberate the case.

Amanda reports that Merrifield stayed calm with his head down while the verdict was read. There was no emotion from anyone in the courtroom, although Amanda says it was very tense. Dr. John Merrifield, Michael's father, put his head down during the verdict reading. Dr. Merrifield also faces charges related to this situation. That trial is expected to go to court in March.

Amanda spoke with Donna Goodall, Logan's paternal grandmother. Ms. Goodall said she finally feels justice is served in this situation. She felt some closure after this verdict.

Putnam County Prosecuting Attorney Mark Sorsaia spoke with Amanda Barren Thursday night on 530 Edition. Sorsaia said, "it's been difficult."

"We worked hard for two years. It's been a lot of work and a lot of stress because the nature of the case and certainly the evidence we had," Sorsaia said.

Sorsaia said he's satisfied with the recommendation for a life sentence without the possiblity of parole for Merrifield.

"It's a relief. Obviously the outcome is something that we had hoped for and worked for," said Detective Lisa Arthur, who testified in the case. "We're all relieved we can move on from this now."


DAY 7 INFO:
The jury started deliberating the case around 3pm Wednesday afternoon -- and has gone home for the night without a verdict. We tried to update Patrick Merrifield's condition at CAMC General, but a hospital spokesperson says the family has asked that no information be released to the media.

A spokesperson with CAMC says Michael Merrifield's brother, Patrick Merrifield was under evaluation earlier Wednesday at CAMC General. A check to the hospital at 9:00pm Wednesday says they no longer have him listed. A source close to the Merrifield family tells WSAZ Patrick Merrifield was on a ventilator. The young men's parents were not in the courtroom Wednesday afternoon.

The defense rested its case at around 9:00am. That means Michael Merrifield will not take the stand.


DAY 6 INFO:
Four defense witnesses took the stand. A forensic pathologist, two of Merrifield's friends and a complete stranger to Merrifield. The stranger told jurors that out of the blue Pepper Eren came up and started talking to him one night at a bar. According to his testimony she told the witness she "didn't have time" to take Logan to the doctor. He also testified it seemed like she was bragging that Michael was in jail and she wasn't. The witness says that he saw Pepper doing drugs that night.

Patrick Merrifield, Michael's brother, was supposed to take the stand Tuesday, but he didn't. He invoked his 5th Amendment Right. It's law that allows a person the opportunity to not testify for fear of self-incrimination.

The defense expert Forensic Pathologist today told jurors he couldn't say 100% that Logan Goodall was sexually assaulted. He says that it's a possibility, but he can't say for certain that is what caused some of Logan's injuries. The WV Chief Medical Examiner last week told jurors, without other evidence to say what caused Logan's injuries, he believes Logan was sexually assaulted.


DAY 5 INFO
WV Chief Medical Examiner James Kaplan explained the injuries to Goodall and showed the autopsy photos to jurors. Also on the stand, Mark Zeigler. He explained that in the summer of 2005 he spent an afternoon with Logan & Michael at a pool in Dunbar. He told jurors Michael was roughhousing with Logan to the point he became concerned. He said Logan was pale and gasping for breath, yet Michael kept throwing him in the water. Zeigler testified that he jumped in the pool got Logan out and told Michael it was enough. "It shook me up for days afterwards," Zeigler testified.


DAY 4 INFO
Day four of testimony came to a close with two people on the stand. Detective Lisa Arthur with the Putnam County Sheriff’s Department and a third paramedic. Detective Arthur talked about her investigation at the home where Logan died. On the stand she said there was no DNA or physical evidence to link Michael to a possible sexual assault in the case. She also said it didn’t mean there are other things that support a theory of sexual assault. Investigators say that sexual assault is a possibility because of the nature of Logan’s internal injuries. Those injuries are what caused the toddler to die.


INTRODUCTION
Michael Merrifield is on trial in the death of Logan Goodall in Putnam County Circuit Court. Goodall died at his home in Hurricane and was the victim of abuse, according to prior testimony. His mother, Pepper Eren, is already in prison in relation to his death.


Here are mobile updates from our reporter, Amanda Barren, who will be sending text messages to keep you informed.


Remote Reporter
Amanda Barren, WSAZ
Reporting via cell phone through Twitter.com.



    REFRESH THIS PAGE FOR THE LATEST UPDATES.


    DAY ONE UPDATES

    08:47 AM January 14, 2008
    The trial is set to start in 20 minutes.

    09:14 AM January 14, 2008
    Michael Merrifield's parents are in the front row.

    09:54 AM January 14, 2008
    27 prospective jurors have been seated. 15 men. 12 women.

    10:15 AM January 14, 2008
    9 men 6 women selected

    10:30 AM January 14, 2008
    Opening statements to start in 15 minutes. Should take a little more than hour.

    10:43 AM January 14, 2008
    Openings underway

    11:21 AM January 14, 2008
    Prosecutor told jurors they will be angry at witnesses and might even cry when they hear the abuse Logan suffered.

    11:27 AM January 14, 2008
    Prosecutor says the explanations Merrifield had for Logan's injuries were bizarre.

    11:28 AM January 14, 2008
    Defense is giving its openings now.

    11:42 AM January 14, 2008
    Defense says Pepper is the one who wouldn't take Logan to hospital the day he died. Michael called the ambulance.

    11:51 AM January 14, 2008
    Defense says Merrifield was more of a dad to Logan than Pepper was a mom.

    12:09 PM January 14, 2008
    Opening statements are over. Things get underway tomorrow at 8:30.


    DAY 2 UPDATES

    09:52 AM January 15, 2008
    Trial day two is underway.

    09:56 AM January 15, 2008
    A second paramedic is on the witness stand.

    10:00 AM January 15, 2008
    Both paramedics say Logan was dead when they arrived at Logan's home.

    10:05 AM January 15, 2008
    The emergency room nurse that had observed Michael punching the walls at the hospital is on the stand.

    10:08 AM January 15, 2008
    The nurse is crying describing Logan's wounds. She says he looked like an abused child.

    10:17 AM January 15, 2008
    Merrifield was overheard by the nurse saying my life is over.

    10:27 AM January 15, 2008
    Another ER Nurse from Putnam General is on the stand. She says Logan's injuries were both old and new.

    10:40 AM January 15, 2008
    Amy Anderson is on the stand. She is Peppers cousin. She is active with West Virginians Against Abuse.

    10:46 AM January 15, 2008
    Amy says Logan became timid when Michael came into his life.

    10:49 AM January 15, 2008
    Amy says Logan looked yellow a month before he died.

    11:16 AM January 15, 2008
    Break until 12:15.

    12:26 PM January 15, 2008
    Back in session.

    12:59 PM January 15, 2008
    Logan died on a Tuesday. Robert says when Logan left his house Sunday his wounds were healing, he was happy and healthy.

    01:23 PM January 15, 2008
    Frank Chapman is on the stand. He is the Director of the Putnam 911 Center.

    01:26 PM January 15, 2008
    We are listening to the 911 call Merrifield made.


    DAY 3 UPDATES

    08:53 AM January 16, 2008
    Day 3 underway and Logan's mom Pepper Eren is on the stand.

    08:56 AM January 16, 2008
    Pepper says she failed as a mom.

    08:59 AM January 16, 2008
    Pepper says she used cocaine and crystal meth. She also drank.

    09:04 AM January 16, 2008
    Peppers mom Melissa is crying while her daughter is on the stand.

    09:04 AM January 16, 2008
    Pepper is crying now.

    09:09 AM January 16, 2008
    There are two female corrections officers here with Pepper.

    09:15 AM January 16, 2008
    Pepper says burns to Logan's lower half were so bad he couldn't sit down for days.

    09:26 AM January 16, 2008
    Michael called Logan 'little man' according to Pepper.

    09:43 AM January 16, 2008
    Logan never said he was being abused. Pepper also says she never asked.

    10:19 AM January 16, 2008
    Pepper is being cross-examined now.

    10:28 AM January 16, 2008
    Logan called Michael Daddy Mike

    11:30 AM January 16, 2008
    Pepper admitted she wanted to marry Michael. She also wrote him a letter saying she loved him days after his arrest.

    11:28 AM January 16, 2008
    Pepper says she has many regrets.

    11:32 AM January 16, 2008
    Days after the arrest she told investigators she didn't think Michael could hurt Logan. She says shes now changed her mind.

    12:52 PM January 16, 2008
    Tony Khoury is on the stand. He is a childhood friend of Merrifield.

    12:56 PM January 16, 2008
    Khoury owned a pawn shop in Charleston for 13 years. He is awaiting sentencing on a money laundering charge.

    01:00 PM January 16, 2008
    Khoury says Merrifield wanted money from him for a lawyer.

    01:14 PM January 16, 2008
    Khoury says he always thought Michael was 100 percent guilty.

    01:31 PM January 16, 2008
    We are watching a taped interview with Michael the day Logan died. Detective Lisa Arthur from the Putnam Sheriffs Dept.

    01:37 PM January 16, 2008
    In the interview Michael says 'that kid is my life.'

    01:51 PM January 16, 2008
    Michael is explaining Logan's injuries as he saw them. He said he couldn't stand up, that he was freezing, throwing up and his eyes were in his head.

    01:52 PM January 16, 2008
    Michael said he 'freaked out'

    02:03 PM January 16, 2008
    When questioned about Logan's bruises Merrifield said he 'could never do something like that.'

    02:05 PM January 16, 2008
    Merrifield: I never laid a hand on that kid.

    02:07 PM January 16, 2008
    Merrifield: I feel like I am in a nightmare.

    02:36 PM January 16, 2008
    Merrifield: I don't know if I can go back there (to the home he shared with Logan and Pepper) there are too many memories.

    02:39 PM January 16, 2008
    Based on Pepper's testimony they'd lived in that home for less than a week.

    02:41 PM January 16, 2008
    We are listening to another taped statement.


    DAY 4 UPDATES

    08:54 AM January 17, 2008
    Judge says no phones this am during three more video statements. Will update during the 1st break.

    10:08 AM January 17, 2008
    Video showed Pepper and Michael at the sheriffs department. Detectives left them alone to talk about Logan's injuries.

    10:10 AM January 17, 2008
    Merrifield's attorney Mike Clifford says they haven't decided if Merrifield will take the stand.

    11:24 AM January 17, 2008
    We are going to hear another audio tape with investigators. It will be the third hour of tapes today. The 6th total.

    11:27 AM January 17, 2008
    I will have a live update on NewsChannel 3 Midday.

    02:15 PM January 17, 2008
    We just heard 2 phone calls made by Merrifield.

    02:50 PM January 17, 2008
    Detective Lisa Arthur has been on the stand since yesterday afternoon, she is being cross examined this afternoon.


    DAY 5 UPDATES

    08:53 AM January 18, 2008
    The lawyers are arguing about some evidence in the case.

    08:57 AM January 18, 2008
    Now the West Virginia Chief Medical Examiner James Kaplan is on the stand.

    09:18 AM January 18, 2008
    We are looking at pictures of Logan's injuries from the autopsy.

    09:21 AM January 18, 2008
    The jury was warned the pictures wouldn't be easy to look at.

    09:29 AM January 18, 2008
    It doesn't appear Michael is looking at the photos.

    09:57 AM January 18, 2008
    Dr. Kaplan says it appears Logan was struggling to get out of hot water based on the burns on Logan's lower backside.

    10:02 AM January 18, 2008
    Logan's grandma Melissa Eren is crying.

    10:05 AM January 18, 2008
    Some people in the courtroom are covering their eyes.

    10:09 AM January 18, 2008
    Tissues were brought out for the jury. Some members seem disturbed.

    10:25 AM January 18, 2008
    Dr. Kaplan says some of Logan's injuries are the result of sexual assault that happened within 16 hours of his death.

    10:38 AM January 18, 2008
    Kaplan: Logan had injuries to his head and belly that each could have caused him to die separately.

    11:11 AM January 18, 2008
    Cross examination of Dr. Kaplan underway.

    01:25 PM January 18, 2008
    Back from lunch break- Kaplan still under cross.

    03:16 PM January 18, 2008
    Kaplan is done.

    03:33 PM January 18, 2008
    Childhood friend Mark Ziegler is on the stand.

    03:37 PM January 18, 2008
    Ziegler says he jumped in the pool and got Logan out in July 2005 when he was with Merrifield. He said Logan was pale and shaking.

    03:41 PM January 18, 2008
    Ziegler: I was shaken for days afterward.


    DAY 6 UPDATES

    09:48 AM January 22, 2008
    The defense is trying to get charges and testimony thrown out.

    09:49 AM January 22, 2008
    So far the judge has denied one of the motions.

    09:55 AM January 22, 2008
    Judge denied the second motion.

    09:57 AM January 22, 2008
    The State rests its case.

    10:03 AM January 22, 2008
    The defense has called Dr. George Nichols to the stand. He is a forensic pathologist. He was chief medical examiner in Kentucky for 20 years ago

    10:22 AM January 22, 2008
    Dr. Nichols says he cannot say whether or not Logan was sexually assaulted.

    10:23 AM January 22, 2008
    Last week Dr. Kaplan said that Logan's injuries were the result of a sexual assault.

    10:48 AM January 22, 2008
    Robert Eren (Pepper's Dad) is in the courtroom for the 1st time since testifying. Both sides decided he could be released from his subpoena.

    11:14 AM January 22, 2008
    Some of Michael's friends are taking the stand.

    11:17 AM January 22, 2008
    Ken Campbell the maintenance man where Michael took Logan swimming is on the stand.

    01:53 PM January 22, 2008
    Only the attorneys and the defendant are allowed in the courtroom right now. It's not clear what they are discussing.

    02:35 PM January 22, 2008
    Patrick Merrifield will not testify. He invoked his 5th amendment right. For fear he would self-incriminate.

    02:38 PM January 22, 2008
    Patrick is Michael's brother.

    02:51 PM January 22, 2008
    The man who just took the stand says that on New Years Eve two years ago Pepper told him out of the blue about Logan.

    02:54 PM January 22, 2008
    The prosecution has called a rebuttal witness: an FBI Agent.


    DAY 7 UPDATES

    08:59 AM January 23, 2008
    The defense rests.

    09:02 AM January 23, 2008
    The State has called a 2nd rebuttal witness. A forensic pathologist from Columbia, South Carolina.

    09:07 AM January 23, 2008
    He is a chief medical examiner in the county where he works. He does not normally testify out of his home county.

    09:10 AM January 23, 2008
    We are looking at pictures of Logan's injuries again.

    09:18 AM January 23, 2008
    The jury appears very attentive to the Doctors calculations.

    09:38 AM January 23, 2008
    The main point the doctor is discussing is whether or not some of Logan's injuries were caused by a sexual assault.

    09:39 AM January 23, 2008
    Both sides have rested.

    10:57 AM January 23, 2008
    The judge and lawyers are going over the jury instructions.

    12:24 PM January 23, 2008
    The judge is giving the jury members their instructions.

    12:26 PM January 23, 2008
    They will hear closing arguments next.

    12:44 PM January 23, 2008
    Michael's parents are not in the courtroom. They have been here the entire trial.

    12:49 PM January 23, 2008
    Logan's maternal grandparents are here. So is his paternal grandmother.

    01:16 PM January 23, 2008
    Closings arguments are underway.

    01:18 PM January 23, 2008
    Logan's autopsy photos are on the screen.

    01:56 PM January 23, 2008
    Many family members had to leave the courtroom because they got upset during the States closing statement.

    02:09 PM January 23, 2008
    Defense is giving its closings right now.

    02:26 PM January 23, 2008
    Defense is done.

    02:45 PM January 23, 2008
    Michael's parents are not here because they are at the hospital with a family member.

    02:48 PM January 23, 2008
    One juror is nodding while the judge tells them how to begin deliberations.

    02:51 PM January 23, 2008
    The judge says the jury will deliberate for as long as they'd like today.

    04:27 PM January 23, 2008
    Jury deliberations are done for the day. They've had the case since about 3pm.
    Click Pictures to Enlarge
    More Stories
    Free 4th of July Meal For Those In Need

    Man of "Monkee" Fame Comes to Summer Motion

    Tea Parties Scheduled for Huntington and Kentucky Saturday

    Holiday Weekend Outdoor Report

    		 Nitro Residents Upset Over No Thru Traffic Road Sign

    Floyd County Course Renewed

    Search for Missing St. Albans Man

    AP: Sarah Palin Resigning as Governor this Month
    Post Your Comments
    First Name:
    Location:
    Enter Comments: characters left
    Email (optional):
    By posting this comment I have read and agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy:
    You must agree to the Terms of Service to continue.
    Read Comments
    Comments are posted from viewers like you and do not always reflect the views of this station.
    Posted by: TickedOffMom on Feb 7, 2008 at 07:25 PM
    I agree with the verdict but I also think Pepper should serve life. I am so SICK of women letting men move in and abuse their children. My son is an adult now, but I told him from a very early age to tell me if ANYONE touched him inappropriately, even if it was his father or grandparents. and I would make it stop. Women need to stand up for their children and stop allowing this kind of abuse to continue. No "boyfriend" on earth is worth your child's well-being. I'm a Registered Nurse and I once had the mother of an abused child say to me, "You can always have more kids but a good man is hard to find." UNREAL! There is no excuse for the doctor's actions either. He should be banned from the practice of medicine. RIP Logan.
    Posted by: Curious Too on Feb 4, 2008 at 12:48 AM
    The full name and birth date seems correct. I wonder what happened that he was arrested?
    Posted by: Curious on Feb 3, 2008 at 04:23 PM
    Was Logan's real father arrested last night? There was a Jeremy Goodall listed on the daily incarcerations.
    Posted by: Hope on Jan 30, 2008 at 09:19 AM
    I just LOVE how MM is now speaking out and when he doesn't want to answer a direct question he claims "that's a part of the appeal". I also LOVE how he is saving his testimony for a "new, fair" trial "up north". OMG!!! I can't do anything but LAUGH at the idiocy. He claims he was "railroaded". LOL Oh goodness. I'd like to see him railroaded -- like on Rocky and Bulwinkle!!!
    Posted by: intelligent on Jan 28, 2008 at 09:50 PM
    to REMINDER....the "FACTS" have slapped you in the face and you are still in denial. the "FACTS" were presented to a Jury of his peers. There was NO hung jury. What does that mean? That means that all Jurors agreed and found MM **GUILTY**. You dont think they were given FACTS to base their decision? You think that 12 Jurors were wrong with their verdict? You think that not one of the Jurors were given any FACTS to make their decision? Why do you continue to embarass yourself? For attention? Well, as for myself and others should follow suit, I will no longer give you the satisfaction of any reply, comment or acknowledgement of the words coming from such a sick and sadistic mind. Keeping in mind the abuse that was inflicted over a period of time..and "COMMON SENSE" you have never had? I truly hope you will get psychological help and not risk CPS removing your children..Lacking the thought process of knowing right from wrong they should not be in your custody. I fear for them..
    Posted by: Anonymous Watcher on Jan 28, 2008 at 09:49 PM
    It is over!!! Thank God for the people who were there that day (Sep. 2005). They recognized that there was a problem and what it was. ie. nurses, paramedics, police. Also God Bless the prosecution, they did an outstanding job. May God Bless and Keep these people that they may be able to continue to protect the citizens of Putnam County.
    Posted by: Jenny on Jan 27, 2008 at 02:05 PM
    I can't see how anyone can lay down at night and sleep doing something as horrible as this. It is a shame! This breaks my heart to think of how this little angel suffered. Just by looking at his picture makes me cry I can say that Logan is in a better place. He can't be hurt anymore Jesus took him away from all the pain and torture he had endured. Little one you may not have been protected down here, but you are proctected by The Almighty God now and no one will ever hurt you again. As for Michael Merrifield and all who were involved, you know who you are. You will reap what you sowed, you will answer to God on Judgement Day. Romans- 12:19 VENGENCE IS MINE I WILL REPAY SAITH THE LORD..
    Posted by: happy with result on Jan 27, 2008 at 12:04 PM
    So what the hell is Reminder's problem? If all of these people who know him say he was violent, crazy, required suspension in 8th grade, and they can see that he was capable of doing this, why does reminder have such a hard time seeing it? Reminder even left her kids w/ MM & PM. And nothing happened! What a nut! Not only the comments of tons of people who knew him, what about the pit bulls & let's not forget the string of arrests from the age of 18 all the way up to TWO months before Logan was killed! Good grief!
    Posted by: Fan of Mark Sorsaia on Jan 27, 2008 at 12:00 PM
    Anna, I so totally agree! Mark Sorsaia did do an absolutely excellent job! I, too, loved his response to that stupid rock analogy! So true that every rock did have MM right smack underneath it! I made a comment earlier, but don't think I made mention of the jury. They definitely do deserve credit! I'd like to thank everyone of those jurors for their efforts. I'm sure it was very mentally exhausting & greuling. I know the content that they were dealing w/ could not have been easy & I'm certainly glad I didn't have to know all the gory details. I'd rather not know. I just know it couldn't have been easy! Thank you sooooo much for bringing justice to little Logan! It can't bring him back, but it sure can make things a little more right for him. I only hope that Kanawha County is able to get an equally intelligent group of 12 & alternates to sit on Dr. & Mrs. Merrifield's.
    Posted by: Anna on Jan 27, 2008 at 06:12 AM
    Mark Sorsaia did an outstanding job. Putnam County should be proud, not only of Mr. Sorsaia, but their citizens that sat on the jury. The way Mr. Sorsaia turned around the "rocks analogy" presented by Mr. Rebrook during closing arguments was awesome. Reminded me of Perry Mason. Congrats!!!
    Posted by: iwasatthetrial on Jan 27, 2008 at 06:02 AM
    Mike Clifford stated in a TV interview that no one will ever know what happened on 9-6-05. Based on evidence presented at trial and statements by all three parties there that day, Pepper was in Dunbar and going to work that afternoon. Patrick M spent the night with Michael M and Logan. Sometime between 11-12pm Patrick said goodbye to Logan and Logan said goodbye to him. Patrick left. Later on about 1:30 or 2pm Pepper got a frantic call from Michael stating that Logan was in bad shape and she should come home. Between the time that Patrick left and Pepper came home, something bad happened to that baby and that "something bad" was Michael M. Pepper finds Logan unresponsive, teeth clenched and eyes rolled back. There was no one else with Logan between 12pm and 2pm except MM. The "bad thing" that happened to Logan is called "1st Degree Murder."
    Posted by: anon on Jan 27, 2008 at 05:53 AM
    to NIKKI, i have known MM for a number of years, as a matter of fact we went to the same catholic school together, and yes he was violent as a child, very violent, he actually was kicked out finally in the 8th grade, the good dr. and the mrs were well aware of this behavior but have always covered for their boys. this is very tragic and i am sorry for all involved, but the merrifields knew this day would come mike has always been mean
    Posted by: Don on Jan 26, 2008 at 11:01 PM
    All I can say is the cold hearted (want to call him a bad name) had better be glad that this poor innocent child was not one of mine. I have 3 children and five grandchildren and I really don't think I could stand the thoughts of that monster living in a jail cellwhile a helpless child in dead by his hands and the people who tried to cover it up. They know who they are. I think that they would be better off in the ground also, they should not get any deals. why not reinstate the death penilty. Better yet go by the way of the Samari take their own lives save the taxpayers some money. I don't like having my taxes paying for their food and lodging. The Gov. needs to step up and bring the death penilty back for these cases and maybe some of this garbage will stop if the people knew that they would be put out of our misery for it. This is my oppinion and my oppinion only not any one elses but I am sure there are more that feel this way.
    Posted by: julie on Jan 26, 2008 at 09:18 PM
    I'm glad my comment was finally posted atleast one comment. DR and mother of mm would have let mm do time for the other 100 crimes he would have already been in jail. And logan would still be alive. mm is crazy and he was born crazy. Ican't believe it took a baby being killed to get him put away. He is pure EVIL!!!!!!
    Posted by: For Logan on Jan 26, 2008 at 06:05 PM
    Reminder, you're the 'critical' thinker with 'strong' reasoning AND you left your children with MM and PM? Yeah right! Hmmm...could've been your children he MURDERED!
    Posted by: wasattrial on Jan 26, 2008 at 10:55 AM
    Reading all the various scenarios in this message board, I'm glad the jury got the right one.
    Posted by: Sheila on Jan 26, 2008 at 10:29 AM
    To Hope: Well said! You are a voice of intelligence and reason. To Just a Reminder: Who killed Logan if not Mike? Remember, Mike called Pepper home BECAUSE Logan was already sick...also remember, please, all of the instances of abuse when Pepper was not around. This is a "whole picture" situation, not just one day or one hour. To Don: Yes, we need the death penalty in West Virginia for child murderers. To all who condemn paternal and maternal grandparents: How much control do you have over your grown child? How could they keep Logan from Pepper? Pepper wouldn't even bring him around for almost the entire last month of his life. But in their defense, they did all think he was "safe" with Dr. and Mrs. Merrifield. To all who defend the good doctor and Mrs - They covered the abuse to protect their child; this is NOT okay, epseically at the expense of a little baby who suffered horrible torture and died alone and unloved while their son "shook the s**t out of him" (his own words)
    Posted by: friend on Jan 26, 2008 at 09:20 AM
    This is to all the people out there that are defending mm...you are just as sick as he is!!! That was a poor innocent baby and anyone that could do something like this to a baby or just defending the person can rot in hell for the rest of their life....just think if that was your child...would you still feel the same way?
    Posted by: Don on Jan 26, 2008 at 01:00 AM
    The only thing I can say is the ones involved in this had better be glad that Logan was not one of mine I think there was 5 or more involved in this childs death and they all should be held accountable.THe Govenor should reinstate the death penelty for cases involving children that have been killed in this manner. However this is my oppinion and I may be alone in this and I my not be I have three children and five grandchilren I just dont think I could live with myself knowing the people responsible for the death of one of mine was being supported for the rest of their miserable lives by my tax dollers put them out of the worlds misery and put in the ground. They dont deserve to live while an innocent child is dead by the hands of phyco's
    Posted by: nmnmn,njnj on Jan 25, 2008 at 11:49 PM
    Thought: I would too! I'd be trying to figure out who did do it! I'd be naming someone! Especially if I was with the child the majority of the time. I'd have an idea who I left the child with the remainder of the time. So I'd be naming the real abuser. Plus, in spending that much time with a child, I'd love and be attached to the child & I'd probably want to kill whomever I thought was responsible for it! I'd get up there and make myself heard. That is, if I had any argument worth making. And if I didn't, I guess I, too, would just sit there quietly, eating my sprees & drinking my pepsi!
    Posted by: anony on Jan 25, 2008 at 11:36 PM
    We don't know what God has in store for Pepper. He could have in mind a much more effective way to punish her with a life full of torment outside of jail. He trusted her with an angel, with one of His children, and look how she cared for him. He will deliver His justice in His own way in His own time.
    Posted by: Hope on Jan 25, 2008 at 10:39 PM
    #1 to those who keep saying that Pepper should be in jail --- SHE IS. Not enough, but we'll take it. Pay attention. #2 To those who are calling for all the grandparents to be charged. Testimony said that Logan was not around the paternal or maternal grandparents much the month or so prior to Logan's death. Logan was mostly with MM and his family members. I agree that they should have realized Pepper was a druggie, but I don't believe they had ANY idea of the extent of what was happening. Their guilty for that is enough for me. #3 to those who want us to ignore Dr. Merrifield's bad act. ONE SINGLE bad act in an otherwise good life can define any of us. That's the nature of bad acts. Unlike his son, I don't think that Dr. Merrifield is a bad person entirely. IMO the Dr. & Mrs. failed as parents and failed Logan miserably. Depite a majority of good things, the two bad things they've done are pretty DARNED weighty. That's life.
    Posted by: Just a thought on Jan 25, 2008 at 09:45 PM
    JUST A THOUGHT. IF I WERE BEING ACCUSED OF MURDERING AN INNOCENT CHILD AND I WERE INNOCENT, I WOULD DEFINITELY WITHOUT A DOUBT GET ON THAT STAND AND TELL EVERYONE MY SIDE OF THE STORY. I MEAN SOMEONE HAD TO DO THE ACTUAL ABUSE, I WOULD BE SO UPSET AND WOULD BE DOING ALL THAT I COULD DO TO CATCH THE REAL ABUSER. THAT IS OF COURSE IF I WERE INNOCENT.
    Posted by: Just a reminder to Anonymous on Jan 25, 2008 at 09:25 PM
    1. as a matter of fact for your information I have let Mike and Patrick take care of my kids and nothing has happened. 2. Please be rational and talk rational. Please avoid being sarcastic and unprofessional. Give me your REASONING. How about that? Give me the FACTS and put them together for me and show me the trace of those facts that lead to the final verdict. As a matter of fact I am glad that I did not to serve as a member of Jury to make decisions under the influence of public's mainstream. Please remember folks!!!! give me the FACTS that lead to the final verdict. Put them together and help me see things that I don't see ONLY BASED ON FACTS.
    Posted by: Anonymous on Jan 25, 2008 at 08:12 PM
    I've often thought people should be able to attain a reasonable score on an IQ test in order to be able to sit on a jury or vote to filter out people with low mentality like that. I, too, am glad all of the jurors on this panel were intelligent. Otherwise, we'd have ended up with a hung jury! Think how hard it would be on everyone to have to go through all that again!
    Posted by: Anonymous on Jan 25, 2008 at 08:01 PM
    Reminder, why don't you give him a try and let him babysit your child then?
    Posted by: Anonymous on Jan 25, 2008 at 07:55 PM
    Thank God Reminder wasn't on the jury!
    Posted by: Anonymous on Jan 25, 2008 at 07:43 PM
    Thank God Michael Merrifield is off the streets & can't harm anyone else's children! And thank God he was taken out of society before he could have any of his own!
    Posted by: Anonymous on Jan 25, 2008 at 07:40 PM
    Let the poll show whose critical reasoning is strongest: Are you satisfied with the outcome of the Michael Merrifield trial? Yes 93.8% No 6.2%
    Posted by: Anonymous on Jan 25, 2008 at 07:35 PM
    Reminder Your thinking is just wishful. Come on back to earth.
    Posted by: Anonymous on Jan 25, 2008 at 07:34 PM
    Just A Reminder Why do we need to waste our time asking medical professionals and patients about Dr. Merrifield? We've got solid evidence in the form of a DEAD, MUTILATED boy! Of only 2 young years!
    Posted by: Anonymous on Jan 25, 2008 at 07:31 PM
    Just a reminder, are you saying your reasoning is stronger than that of the 12 jurors, the prosecutor, the doctors, nurses, paramedics, and detectives? As you can see, your reasoning isn't very strongly supported by many. I'm going to have to go with Gigi on this one . . .
    Posted by: Anonymous on Jan 25, 2008 at 07:23 PM
    Gigi, we can all see how weak your reasoning is. You're the one posting all the 'complex' questions. Thank you for listening so closely to the testimony!
    Posted by: Just a reminder to Anonymous on Jan 25, 2008 at 07:17 PM
    I am very glad that you brought that question about the father of Logan. I am sorry but don't you see that if someone makes a baby, he/she (both parents) are responsible for the baby unless if they are an animals. even animals take care of the babies. if you dare to get close to the babies of some animals the parents will chew your legs. I hope you see my point.
    Posted by: Fan of Mark Sorsaia on Jan 25, 2008 at 07:17 PM
    As someone who followed the trial very closely, I'd like to thank everyone for their hard work & dedication to getting justice for little Logan! Everyone stepped forth & gave their best efforts toward getting justice for him & making his short life count for something in this cruel world! Esp Mark Sorsaia! Awesome! He countered every single move the defense made to incite doubt in the minds of the jury! He played the statement of Michael telling Pepper that Patrick didn't do it because he never left him alone w/ Patrick. Also letting them know he wasn't accusing Pepper. He even brought the forensic path from SC, Clay Nichols, in to put some intelligent last thoughts out to the jury! That med ex from KY must only have 20 minutes of experience instead of 20 years! Either that or they paid him WAY more than he was worth! Kudos to you Mark Sorsaia--you anticipated & countered every single one of the issues I was afraid the jury might get hung up on! You couldn't have done a better job!
    Posted by: Just a reminder to everybody on Jan 25, 2008 at 07:12 PM
    I guess the point I am trying to make here is this: In order to convict MM in this case and anyone in general the court and the Jury needs more CORRABORATIVE evidence based on PURE FACTS and not a mixture of facts and interetations!!!! The defense has some plausible evidence based on pure facts, but the prosecutor didn't. All he stressed on was pure personal interpretations. such as this: MM said something about latex in condom so he has the awareness of how sexual assault works. I think 12 year-old teen knows that some condoms have latex. So What? I hope you see what my point is.
    Posted by: Just a reminder to Anynymous on Jan 25, 2008 at 07:04 PM
    I am going to have to remind you that we are looking for pure FACTS not our own interpretations. How do you know by putting the FACTS together that MM was guilty and Pepper was less guilty? Help me in that. Maybe I can't see something in the FACTS that you see Here is the situation. This is like a puzzle. You MUST have actual pieces to put together in order to get the true picture. simple as that. The fact is that she is the mother and primary responsible person for the child and she knew that her child was severely ill and she left to work. These are the FACTS. Now I am asking you if you had a kid in this condition would you leave that child alone or you'd take him to a doctor? I think you only avoid doing that if you intentionally want to get rid of the child. Also the baby had a prolonged illness for which she didnt take any proactive step. Also the formic acid level in the kid before the death was elevated. Who poisoned the child Can you tell me it was MM or Pepper?...
    Posted by: Just a reminder to Gigi on Jan 25, 2008 at 06:53 PM
    I am sorry but your reasoning is very weak. Think more critically. you can interpret MM's statements anyway you wish. remember! we are looking for pure facts not interpretations. Thanks for sharing your comments here.
    Posted by: Anonymous on Jan 25, 2008 at 06:50 PM
    To just a reminder: What does the father of the baby have to do w/ it? All you can say about him is that he wasn't around to help him anymore than she was!
    Posted by: Anonymous on Jan 25, 2008 at 06:48 PM
    To Just a reminder: I'm sorry, but she's the lesser of two evils. Given the choice, wouldn't you rather use her to get the peron who actually physically committed the abuse to the child instead of the passive participant?
    Posted by: Anonymous on Jan 25, 2008 at 06:45 PM
    To Just a reminder: The state probably did not 'want' to give Pepper Eren a deal, but they had no choice in the matter. Being that all the evidence was circumstantial (no DNA pointing specifically to MM), there was no way for them to get the necessary information to the jury. It would've been hearsay & couldn't have been introduced in court. It probably wouldn't have even gotten past the grand jury. He probably wouldn't even have been indicted. But w/ Pepper, that allowed them to introduce a lot of evidence that was supported by other evidence--corroborative evidence.
    Posted by: Gigi on Jan 25, 2008 at 06:38 PM
    To Just a reminder: We know that Pepper didn't do it because of the way MM reacted in the police station when she was wired without his knowledge. He never once accused her of doing anything to the child. Because he knew he was the guilty one. If you & I are talking and I know I didn't do something, then I'm automatically thinking you must have . . . If he knew he wasn't guilty, he would have been going in the direction of figuring out who did. Don't you think? Not to mention the fact that he told her that Patrick did not do it because he never left the child alone w/ Patrick! Thank God the jury got to hear him make that statement! That's the only reason the defense's manipulative little maneuver didn't work when they tried to shift the jury's focus over to Patrick & instill 'reasonable' doubt. Those attorneys were clowns! Complete clowns! They couldn't even round up any remotely intelligent witnesses to take the stand in his defense!
    Posted by: jJust a reminder 5 on Jan 25, 2008 at 06:38 PM
    I am wondering why my comments under Just a remindet #3 is not there???? Any explanations from wsaz moderators???
    Posted by: nana on Jan 25, 2008 at 06:23 PM
    to: just a reminder: if the good doctor helped all of those people, why, did he choose not to help a 2 year old little boy?
    Posted by: Fact Teller on Jan 25, 2008 at 06:19 PM
    Also, I have had enough of these comments because those for Mike and his family are just as guilty. Don't blame Logan's family except his Mother.....she deserves 10 years, and the Prosecutor was not happy to give her a Plea, but he wanted to put the real psycho killer behind bars for life, and he did just that. Justice was served last night, It may night bring back Little Logan, but it will keep someone other child from being abused by Mike Merrifield. I feel bad for the Merrifield family because all they tried to do was cover up for their son - and now he has ruined their name. So RIP little guy and those to you who defend the guilty.....May God be with you!!
    Posted by: A mother on Jan 25, 2008 at 03:34 PM
    Pepper Eren should not get out one day before her 10 years is up. I want to know what the chances are she will serve the ful 10 years. How do we make sure she doesn't get out before the ten years? Do we write to someone, do we have to show up at the parole hearings... What needs to be done for her to have the maximum sentence carried out?
    Posted by: Just a reminder 4 (cont'd) on Jan 25, 2008 at 03:09 PM
    Dr. Merrifield has served for more than 30 years in a small community in Dunbar, WV. He has helped numerous patients, physicians, students and people of any strata of the community who needed help. He has not hesitated to help anyone and not considered his benefits or loss when helping others. He has helped people because of the intense love of people and the love of God. Please don’t be sarcastic of him being the WV Doctor of the Year. He certainly deserves this title and may be more. Please don’t listen to the media who wants to put fuel in the fire. You can hear the other side of the story by asking medical professionals of how he cared for people and his patients. What kind of the justice is this to ignore all the humanity and not reward that and point their fingers to prosecute John Merrifield? Could you spend your time investigating Pepper, Mr. J. Goodall (the father of the baby) Erens and Goodalls families if you really care for justice and protecting the community?
    Posted by: putnam grandfather on Jan 25, 2008 at 03:02 PM
    Well Michael Merrifield will finally end up where he belongs - however there are still MORE GUILTY people to be dealt with! NO WAY should DR and Mrs get "plea bargains"! And what about the brother worried about "incriminating" hinmself - what did he do that was illegal?
    Posted by: Just a reminder 2 (Cont'd) on Jan 25, 2008 at 02:34 PM
    Don't you think that State should have avoided giving plea bargain to Pepper and don't you think Pepper should have been in the same seat as MM and given the same virdicts instead of taking a break in jail and thinking about requesting Parole? Does the Mr. prosecutor think that what kind of mother is Pepper to do such horrible things after the death her child. I am sure everyone would agree with me in that if you lost your child you would be grieving in the cemetery for your dead child instead of "partying, doing drugs and appearing as a hollywood star." Isn't Mr. procecutor obliged to investigate the history of child abuse by Pepper and her family before giving Pepper a plea bargain. I should in fact remind the Erens when you go to the cemetery to tell Logan that Justice has been served, make sure to tell him what your guilt was in this trajedy. 3.I have one fact to remind Mr. prosecutor. Did you investigate where the father of beby has been throughout your "hard Work?" ..Cont'd
    Posted by: Annette on Jan 25, 2008 at 01:05 PM
    While I believe in the verdict, it is a tradegy for all concerned - a beautiful child died a terrible death; a young man ruined his life, and a set of parents have lost their son for the rest of their lives. In all of this, it appears to me that Pepper Eren got off the lightest - she will get out of jail eventually and probably go back to drugs, men, and partying. This does not seem fair. She was, after all, the person on whom the most responsibility for Logan rested, and she will be free simply because she turned State's evidence to save herself. My opinion - she should be in jail for the rest of her life, just as Michael Merrifield will be. In this aspect, justice WAS NOT SERVED.
    Posted by: Just a reminder on Jan 25, 2008 at 01:00 PM
    There were some points that I thought to remind to individuals who have taken the stand against MM, including the Jury. 1. Why do you think that the possility of child abuse by Pepper is doubtful? Keep that in mind that evidence indicates that there was a child abuse but does not indicate by who!!! and since MM was the last person who was with Logan, everyone points their fingers to MM. Don't you think it is possible that Pepper harmed the child throughout and left to work and left the child with MM to strengthen the hypothesis of abuse by MM? Why didn't the Jury and the prosecutor didn't explore that possibility? 2. What is the reason for Pepper to celebrate the New Year and appear as a "Hollywood star" very shortly after the death of her child and "brag about it?" In this sort what is the reason for Pepper to write a "love letter" to MM right after when MM was arrested for the charge of "abusing her child?" Don't you think "State should have... cont'd in the next comment.
    Posted by: cindy on Jan 25, 2008 at 12:33 PM
    One question, where is logan's biological father?
    Posted by: Michelle on Jan 25, 2008 at 12:09 PM
    This is a responce to friend if you are praying for John and Diana Merrifield you are just as sick as they are. They didnt help that poor boy when they should have shame on you
    Posted by: grandmother on Jan 25, 2008 at 11:56 AM
    If Dr. Merrfield had reported the abuse, CPS possibly investigated, removed the child for a day or to, then given him back to a mother who could care less about him. The Erens and Goodalls must share resposibility. Why didn't they report!!! There are so many children being abused on a regular basis. Our welfare system is an enabler to this fact.
    Posted by: wondering on Jan 25, 2008 at 11:32 AM
    I'm glad justice has been served, but its a shame Pepper will be walking soon and she knew what was going on. She should of been charged with some of these charges as well.
    Posted by: Bec on Jan 25, 2008 at 10:53 AM
    I don't think that MM should have been the only person on trial here. There is other people as guilty as he is. I am just thankful that I am not the one who will hold them accountable in the day of judgment.
    Posted by: anon on Jan 25, 2008 at 10:44 AM
    Could someone explain why none of the other family members have been charged with neglect? They seemed to have turned a blind eye to the little guys bruises and injuries.
    Posted by: Lisa on Jan 25, 2008 at 10:22 AM
    If only Dr. Merrifield had reported it, Logan would still be alive and his son would not be going to prison for life.
    Posted by: DL on Jan 25, 2008 at 09:52 AM
    no matter that he is found guilty, he will sit in prison, with 3 meals a day and a bed. he isn't going to suffer in jail for his crime. he doesn't deserve the right to breathe oxygen. and anyone involved that could have prevented the death of this beautiful little boy should be held accountable as well.
    Posted by: WONDERING on Jan 25, 2008 at 09:33 AM
    Please do not think this man will do hard time. He will have recess time, t.v., libaray periods, movies and vistors. And think the baby might get flowers here and there. It's still lopsided. Where is the death penalty?
    Posted by: CURIOUS-NOT BI BUT CURIOUS on Jan 25, 2008 at 09:04 AM
    i havent followed the whole story but where is the childs father?
    Posted by: MARIDITH on Jan 25, 2008 at 08:38 AM
    I might be wrong, but I think the charges against Dr. Merrifield and his wife will not bring much punishment even if they are found guilty. I think they are only charged with not reporting this to CPS. I think if he is found guilty he will not see any jail time.
    Posted by: Marcus on Jan 25, 2008 at 07:47 AM
    Well its taken 2 years. And the jury looked in different ways to make the right choice that they thought this fit the crime. I'm sure that the attorneys for Micheal was in for a ride and they knew it. I can imagine what would make a person do what they do to children at any age like this. They try to say that there insane and put them into a hospital, this and others should be any case like that.
    Posted by: TYLER on Jan 25, 2008 at 07:35 AM
    I too am glad the jury found him guility, but are there few comments about Pepper ? She is quility as well. Pepper's mother is happy for the guility verdit and hope this can all put this behind us now, does she think her daughter did no wrong ?
    Posted by: and justice for all?????? on Jan 25, 2008 at 07:03 AM
    well Logan got half of the justice he deserves the other half would only have came from his mother/who gave birth to him and was suppose to protect him with her life spending the rest of her life in prision---she will walk free in 5 years and Logan was HER son---where is the justice in that I think she was the one who did it all and she will suffer in the after life too----Rest in peace Logan
    Posted by: Anna on Jan 25, 2008 at 06:50 AM
    To "nobody" Yes, there were three people at the house at some time the day Logan died. Michael by his own statements said that Patrick didn't do it. And why did Michael call Pepper? It was BECAUSE of Logan's condition. The assault had already taken place, otherwise Michael wouldn't have had to call Pepper to hurry home. Use your common sense.
    Posted by: Anna on Jan 25, 2008 at 06:41 AM
    Why all the sympathy for the parents. If Dr Merrifield had taken appropriate action when he first became aware of the abuse by his son, Logan would be here today. I don't feel sorry for them, they are just as guilty. Be sure your sins will find you out.
    Posted by: Nate on Jan 25, 2008 at 06:40 AM
    TO SHIRLEY-The difference is that assault is actual penetration. And whats it matter, hes not going to see the light of day again..Its like giving someone 3 terms of a life sentence..Im pretty sure hes not going to outlive that! But anyway..CONGRATS to the State of WV, we have yet another thug to pay $63 a day to take care of as taxpayers!! WE NEED THE DEATH PENALTY!!!
    Posted by: linda on Jan 25, 2008 at 05:23 AM
    HOPEFULLY DR.MERRIFIELD AND HIS WIFE WILL GET THE SAME AS MICHAEL. BECAUSE, IF DR. MERRIFIELD AND HIS WIFE WOULD HAVE REPORTED THE ABUSE TO CPS, LOGAN WOULD STILL BE HERE TODAY.
    Posted by: Shirley on Jan 25, 2008 at 12:58 AM
    On the Merrifield verdict - I fail to understand how they could say NOT guilty on charge 3 but guilty on charge 4! First degree sexual assault is done after your have thought about it and NO child molestor does that to a child without fore thought. They should have found him guilty on ALL charges. He doesn't deserve to ever see day light again. And his father should be held accountable because he knew what was going on with the little boy.
    Posted by: db on Jan 25, 2008 at 12:15 AM
    now for all these people commenting on this, you say you want harsher punishment , its time to bring these perverts to justice, lets start at home, if you were abused start telling, start paving the way for future generations to feel safer telling of their abuse. if you havent been abused, start writing the papers , the news stations ,every time you see an abuse case, show up in court and support the abused , you wouldnt believe how little support we have , from the system and our families.
    Posted by: db on Jan 25, 2008 at 12:14 AM
    to ,A REAL FATHER i agreed with your entire comment , except for the part where you said that "Over 90% of those who abuse have been abused. " where in the world did you find this statistic? first let me say that any statistic on child abuse , can not be fully trusted, when 90 percent of people sexually abused never tell, so these statistics are based on only 10 percent! Now, to address your theory on the abused abusing, that is the biggest crock of bull and copout ever !i was sexually abused for 14 years and id rather hang myself from the nearest tree then abuse anyone. I wouldnt wish what i went through on my worst enemy! what causes child abuse is a sick , twisted person who gets off on the pain they cause others! and if that person was abused as a child then abuses later, then they are sicker then the one that wasnt abused, because they know first hand, how helpless and how painfull abuse can be!
    Posted by: MIKE on Jan 24, 2008 at 10:34 PM
    I HOPE PEPPER GETS WHATS COMING TO HER ALSO, SHES JUST AS GUILTY
    Posted by: Hope on Jan 24, 2008 at 10:34 PM
    Logan's Voice: speak for yourself. I HAVE spoken out for a child that needed it and would have for Logan had I known. I'm also raising a child to do the same.
    Posted by: Mom of 2 on Jan 24, 2008 at 10:28 PM
    Thank God, justice for Logan! I feel that everyone (the Mother, brother, and grandparents) knew about the abuse, how could they not know? This is such a sad story, the loss of a child is terrible, but to have one beaten to the point that he can't survive! They will all eventually get what is coming to them! Thanks to all the Jurors! Logan can now rest in peace!
    Posted by: lori on Jan 24, 2008 at 10:15 PM
    Well thank you for your coverage of this case. Thank you to these brave jurors that had to set and look upon the evidence and may the Lord help you threw the next days coming. Justice was served as well as it could of been in WVA. It has given me hope now for when we go to trial in June 08 for the death of my nephew in Kenton Co. Ky. He, also was beaten to death by a temporary live in boyfriend. Oh, there are still honest people out there that give our justice system a good name. Thank you jurors, once again, may GOD always bless you for your work.
    Posted by: Logan's Voice on Jan 24, 2008 at 10:08 PM
    What has happened to our Children. Who is it that is making them responsible proud young adults.It is not us,we have failed all of them.We are all caught up in our own little worlds.We as a society are all responsible for Logan's death. We all turn our heads and don't get involved. No one needed to care about the parents or custodians of this child or any child, but all of us are responsible for the demise of this chid.We turn own heads, live in our comfortable lives and let the ravages of drugs and neglect run the world in which we live.We all sit by and watch as our children/loved ones disenagrate before our eyes. We are who they have learned from, they are who we have taught them to be. Where are our morals, where is our guidance?Who are we to blame our children for the beasts that they have become.Search your minds and your hearts and decide if you are capable of blaming anyone else but yourself for what it is that you fail to do to protect those that you supposedly love.
    Posted by: JULIE on Jan 24, 2008 at 09:52 PM
    thank God!!!!1 MM will be punished everyday for the rest of his life!!!!!!!
    Posted by: Anonymous on Jan 24, 2008 at 09:42 PM
    OK!Paramedic,John Merrifield WAS NOT Logans GRANDFATHER.Where did you get your information at?From one of the CLOWN witness that the clown defence team found
    Posted by: no name on Jan 24, 2008 at 09:29 PM
    i hope he does something bad to his self. for what he did to that baby. people make me sick when they hurt a child. my kids mean the world to me. anyone would hurt them i would make hell move. to save them. Logan rest in peace. you are angel now. very pretty baby boy!!!!!
    Posted by: sandra on Jan 24, 2008 at 09:22 PM
    i would love to know where this childs grandmother was when he was been hurt she seams to care after he died but where was she when he was been hurt i have 3 wonderfully grandson and i am allways in there life there is nothing in the world that would keep me away from them not even a job ill all ways be there for them no matter what
    Posted by: Sue on Jan 24, 2008 at 09:18 PM
    What a great job that Amanda has done in reporting this. Thanks Amanda, I have enjoyed this.Good job WSAZ.
    Posted by: mimi on Jan 24, 2008 at 08:57 PM
    WV doesn't have a death penalty so all you guys suggesting it, need to know that they punished him as much as they could
    Posted by: Jackie on Jan 24, 2008 at 08:57 PM
    Where is Tracy now running her mouth! Trying to tell us what a good guy this monster is and how he'll walk. Well hes walking alright striaght to prison. What a Great Day for Logan!
    Posted by: lindsey on Jan 24, 2008 at 08:55 PM
    my thoughts and prayers go out to logan's family. now little logan can rest in peace along with his family. he is now rejoicing with the angels above!!
    Posted by: intellligent on Jan 24, 2008 at 08:52 PM
    CASE CLOSED............. Guilty !*!*!*!*!*!*! Thank you Jurors.
    Posted by: Sue on Jan 24, 2008 at 08:45 PM
    I hope that Michael's dad, the doctor also loses all of his patients and does jail time. He should have taken care of this baby and he didn't. You are next DR.MERRIFIELD!!!!!! You need to pay just like your son is going to pay, IN JAIL> Your time is coming. Logan didn't deserve to be treated this way by your son.
    Posted by: citizen on Jan 24, 2008 at 08:32 PM
    I agree with all, that all should be made to pay for this act. Just tring to figure out if the brother, had a part in this since he took the 5th and is in the hospital being monitored.
    Posted by: Anonymous on Jan 24, 2008 at 08:06 PM
    WOOHOOO!!! I am soooo happy that he was found guilty. I hope he rots in jail.
    Posted by: Citizen on Jan 24, 2008 at 07:44 PM
    Justice did prevail - somewhat. I think that everyone that knew about the abuse and did nothing ie the grandparents,the mother,the brother, are as guilty as the jury said mm is. In a few years, when the mother is unfairly allowed to start her life over, Logan will be still gone. I hope that now the spirit of this small child can rest in peace.
    Posted by: Thank God! on Jan 24, 2008 at 07:23 PM
    This is such a blessing, this horible man is in jail. I think he should of fried.Atleast the other jail inmates with have a good time with him. I think the plan of the brother in hospital was a setup to throw the case off. In the hospital on a ventulator and then he was released that night. Come On, Get Real! Trying to cause reasonable doubt! I think the plan back fired! Thank you JURORS for doing the right thing! Logan can rest in peace now. Now it is time to bring justice on the Dr and his wife. It's their turn to be in the spot light NOW!
    Posted by: donetta on Jan 24, 2008 at 07:22 PM
    i think merrifield should have had the death penalty and then that wouldn't be enough for him!! there are already to many men that abuses kids and the law doesn't do anything about it. the whole government needs a change, even the federal. most of them are in it for themselves and what they can get and not care for us that are not so high classed. he really needs the death penalty but as long as someone doesn't get involved and try to get him out, then he deserves to stay in prison and maybe be punished that way or some of the other prisoners take care of him!!! i can't express how angry this makes me!
    Posted by: chuck on Jan 24, 2008 at 07:22 PM
    John and Diane are next to bad they didn't do the rite thing. Mike isn't laughing now like he was in the court room. ha ha ha mike your so funny
    Posted by: Paramedic on Jan 24, 2008 at 07:15 PM
    There is more than just one guilty person n this case. The abuser, the mother, and certainly the grandparents. Dr. Merrifield is a board certified physician who has a legal and ethical obligation to report any and all signs of abuse. What makes this pathetic situation even worse is that it was not some random patient that he turned a blind eye to. His inattention and lack of integrity resulted in the horrific and painfully traumatic death of his OWN grandchild!!! He needs to be the next on trial.
    Posted by: Melissa on Jan 24, 2008 at 07:13 PM
    I want to thank Mark Sorsaia for a GREAT JOB. And all the law enforcement,medical examiners.LOGAN CAN REST IN PEACE,AS LOGAN SHANE GOODALL.Thank you Amanda Barren for the good coverage you have done.
    Posted by: Robyn on Jan 24, 2008 at 06:53 PM
    My only regret in this case is that it happened in a state that doesn't have the death penalty. I'm from florida and we have the death penalty and he would be fried.
    Posted by: reader 2 on Jan 24, 2008 at 06:45 PM
    my thoughts and prayers go out to the beautiful baby Logan. I'm so sorry for your loss.
    Posted by: Sandra on Jan 24, 2008 at 06:41 PM
    While all of the hearings and everything was going on, Logan was an Angel, in a garden of love. Jesus made it, for all mankind. Especially children. Merrifield, has a soul, needs prayer, but he has a reckoning day in prinson, ENJOY Michael.
    Posted by: Sam on Jan 24, 2008 at 06:40 PM
    Thanks to the people of Putnam County..a very sick person has been removed from society. Someone finally stood up for this little boy.
    Posted by: Friend on Jan 24, 2008 at 06:38 PM
    John&Diane You will be in our thoughts and prayers....
    Posted by: Cris on Jan 24, 2008 at 06:28 PM
    I'm doing a happy dance!! I hope this evil man rots in jail for the horrible things he did to that precious little angel. How could any human lay their head down on a pillow and sleep at night knowing what they put that baby through.
    Posted by: Eg on Jan 24, 2008 at 06:28 PM
    could not of said it better "D". I have to completly agree with u. Its a sad day.
    Posted by: Anonymous on Jan 24, 2008 at 06:25 PM
    he had it coming
    Posted by: nobody on Jan 24, 2008 at 06:19 PM
    I frankly do not see HOW they found MM guilty. I sat in that courtroom and heard EVERYTHING. They proved what, and when, but they did NOT prove who! His mother should be the one sitting in jail for the rest of her life.
    Posted by: tim on Jan 24, 2008 at 06:19 PM
    How about doing something about the guys who lied under oath?
    Posted by: I'm on Logan's side on Jan 24, 2008 at 06:16 PM
    Now you can rest in peace Logan.
    Posted by: A Loving Grandmother on Jan 24, 2008 at 06:14 PM
    This to to DD how can you say they didn't have enough evidence if MM didn't do it why didn't he get on the stand and tell who did or why didn't he tell who else was at his house that night.
    Posted by: PAM on Jan 24, 2008 at 06:13 PM
    THE INMATES WILL GIVE HIM HIS JUSTICE. HE WILL GET WHAT HE DESERVES AND MORE!!! HE WILL HAVE TO ANSWER TO A HIGHER POWER !!!!
    Posted by: concerned citizen on Jan 24, 2008 at 06:11 PM
    I have lost a child at the hands to someone else not long ago and I express my sincere apology. I beleive that the judge should show NO mercy with his sentencing and teach a lesson to other offenders that this will NOT be tolerated. Again I sincerely aplogize and hope that the family will let GOD help them in their recovery.
    Posted by: D on Jan 24, 2008 at 06:07 PM
    Justice prevailed...somewhat. MM still gets to take air into his evil lungs... I hope that the people who feel justified in obtaining monetary gain over the death of this sweet child have a tough time sleeping for a long long time. It is a sad day when people don't take care of their children, yet get to reap financial benefits from their own neglect. This should never have happened!!! And although the relatives may be heartbroken, I can almost bet they bear some of the guilt as well!!! Just a word of advice, if you think a child is in harm, no matter who it is...get involved. If you KNOW your own daughter or son is a drug addict, get their children away from them. If your friends or family have trouble staying in a loving stable relationship, keep an eye on their kids!!! They do not deserve to live the problems adults bring into their innocent little lives. No one took care of that baby...or he would still be here.
    Posted by: MAXINE on Jan 24, 2008 at 06:07 PM
    I just saw Pepper's mother on the news say she is glad there is finally closure to this awful thing. Now will she finally get Pepper help with her drug and alcohol abuse ?
    Posted by: hopeful on Jan 24, 2008 at 06:06 PM
    i hope now when they try everyone else, (michael's dad), that they find them guilty too, because we know that they all knew about it and did nothing about it! thats horrible!! it saddens me to no end to think about poor logan and the things he went through!! i don't believe how someone can be so cruel. TO A LITTLE INNOCENT BABY!!
    Posted by: Anonymous on Jan 24, 2008 at 06:03 PM
    I am glad that he got what was do him, but where was all of this family of his when he was being neglected and abused. If these people cared half as much as they act, maybe Logan would still be here.
    Posted by: Rebecca on Jan 24, 2008 at 06:03 PM
    Great job by the prosecutors, law enforcement, medical examiner and everyone else who had a hand in justice for Logan!!!
    Posted by: kristen on Jan 24, 2008 at 05:58 PM
    that should never have tpo happen to a little child or to anyone i hope he gets the death penalty or dies in jail i dont know how him or the babys mother will live with thereselves
    Posted by: jean on Jan 24, 2008 at 05:49 PM
    karma will be all over him times 10
    Posted by: Diane on Jan 24, 2008 at 05:48 PM
    I'm glad he was found guilty. I wonder how long he will tie things up with appeals? I hope his Father is held accountable for his neglect as a physician. He fully knows he should have reported what he found.
    Posted by: CONCERNED FRIEND on Jan 24, 2008 at 05:48 PM
    I WILL BE PRAYING FOR JOHN AND DIANE THAT GOD GIVES THEM THE STRENGHT TO MAKE IT THROUGH THIS HORRIBLE TRAGGIC SITUATION.LOGAN IS AT PEACE NOW AND FOR WHOEVER DID THIS MAY IT LAY HEAVY ON THEIR MIND FOR THE REST OF THEIR LIVES. TO JOHN AND DIANE; MAY THE LORD STRENGTHEN YOU THROUGH THE MANY HARD TIMES STILL AHEAD.
    Posted by: relieved. on Jan 24, 2008 at 05:47 PM
    the rest of his life behind bars is the LEAST thing he could go through with all the things baby logan went through!! good thing!
    Posted by: Charlie on Jan 24, 2008 at 05:40 PM
    It is GOOD to know Logan had someone to stand up for him in the end.R.I.P. little Logan.
    Posted by: thankful on Jan 24, 2008 at 05:38 PM
    finally. i've said he was guilty from the start. poor little logan. at least now mm will suffer for what poor logan went through.
    Posted by: Finally on Jan 24, 2008 at 05:31 PM
    Now maybe poor Logan can rest in peace!!
    Posted by: A REAL FATHER on Jan 24, 2008 at 05:25 PM
    There is a growing understanding that sexual abusers are likely to be people we know, and could well be people we care about; after all more than 8 out of 10 children who are sexually abused know their abuser. They are family members or friends, neighbors or babysitters - many hold responsible positions in society. Some people who abuse children have adult sexual relationships and are not solely, or even mainly, sexually interested in children. Abusers come from all classes, racial and religious backgrounds and may be homosexual or heterosexual. Most abusers are men, but some are women. You cannot pick an abuser out in a crowd. Over 90% of those who abuse have been abused. WOW sounds like a text book case of sexual abuse to me don’t it to you? The Doctor had a responsibility to report this abuse and he knows it. If the child were anyone else he would have reported it. If he had done so Logan would have been here and his son would have been in jail. Now his son is a murder bound for hell
    Posted by: Lisa on Jan 24, 2008 at 05:17 PM
    GUILTY !!!!!!!!!!!! they should have gotten him on Sexual Assult to !!!!
    Posted by: DD on Jan 24, 2008 at 05:12 PM
    This is a sad case.The jury should find MM not guilty due to the lack of evidence.I blame Eren's parents just as much as Eren & MM. If they kept Logan as often as they did and had him the weekend before, they should have reported the abuse. I think law enforcement was forced to make a quick arrest by the public and did not fully investigate. There are too many lose ends.
    Posted by: DEBBIE on Jan 24, 2008 at 04:14 PM
    This jury is taking too long, don't like that.
    Posted by: MARIA on Jan 24, 2008 at 01:57 PM
    IT MAKES ME SICK TO SEE PEOPLE MAKING MONEY OFF THIS TRAGEDY. tHEY ARE A BUNCH OF VULTURES.
    Posted by: Hope on Jan 24, 2008 at 01:41 PM
    The jury is back BACK? or just back from lunch???????
    Posted by: pasha on Jan 24, 2008 at 01:28 PM
    Why can't WV have capital punishment. This looks like a good case for a argument on bringing it back.
    Posted by: Neglect Count? on Jan 24, 2008 at 12:58 PM
    Isn't there one count charged to mm whereby if a child is left with a guardian/custodian and medical attention is needed, but neglected results in the child's death? At the very least wouldn't this be a "no-brainer" in this case? If I'm not mistaken didn't mm's attorney admit that mm was guilty of such? or at least imply??????
    Posted by: lester on Jan 24, 2008 at 12:33 PM
    Mark Scorsaia did a good job and deserves a thanks from honest people who live a crime free life an cherish the love the children give us. Mike is so low that he would try and throw his own brother under the bus.
    Posted by: Sam on Jan 24, 2008 at 12:14 PM
    This verdict is the last chance an adult will have to reach out to little Mr. Logan Goodall. It will be a small price for merrifield to pay but its all thats left to do and that is to incarcerate this fool so that no other child will suffer from his hand.
    Posted by: TimboNunnery on Jan 24, 2008 at 12:06 PM
    Wow...this guy is done
    Posted by: Anonymous on Jan 24, 2008 at 11:50 AM
    a slow jury is a hung jury is what i always heard one thing that can be said for Logan is that the angel doesnt have to suffer anymore he is sleeping in God's arms now and if not convicted on this earth the guilty will be delt with after this life
    Posted by: Maridith on Jan 24, 2008 at 11:37 AM
    The stunt pulled by Patrick pleading the 5th was to put doubt in the jurrors mind. How low can lawyers go!
    Posted by: Maridith on Jan 24, 2008 at 11:35 AM
    Do you think the whole Patrick pleading the 5th is to put dobt in the jurrors mind? If so, may that all rot in ____, including the lawyers
    Posted by: Hope on Jan 24, 2008 at 10:17 AM
    Jury question!! Hope it is telling.
    Posted by: Shisrley on Jan 24, 2008 at 10:10 AM
    Let Us all pray for little Logan Goodall. I feel there should have been a much larger play for the parents, grandparents, and any other adult who did seen or could have seen something was wrong with this child. Same on all of them for not reporting any and all evidence of something wrong with this child. Being a grandparent of three, I would not hesitate to take my grandchild to hospital, police or DHHR for help. Let everyone who knew Logan take blame for what has happened to this baby. The mother from the beginning should not have been able to keep this child. Who would leave her child with anyone she did not know, other than sleeping with. My heart goes out to the everyone involved. Remember it must go beyond a reasonable doubt. I don't think they have it. Again, this is very sad.
    Posted by: anonymous on Jan 24, 2008 at 09:59 AM
    Does it not look fishy to everyone that Patrick is now in the hospital on a ventilator the day after he plead the 5th. He was at the house with MM and Logan the day before he died. MM's atty. says they never talked to Patrick. Come on does it take a rocket scientist to figure out something is really fishy here? Maybe MM and Patrick both abused the boy. But whether MM committed the abuse or watched it - he was there - in my mind he is guilty and should be punished. Maybe Patrick punished himself and that's why he's in the hospital. Couldn't live with himself. Who knows? Maybe at some point we will hear more about this. Thanks WSAZ for letting me get things off my chest and for doing a wonderful job of keeping up informed. Hope you do the same when the Dr. and Diana Merrifield's go on trial. Thanks!
    Posted by: PLEASE HELP ME UNDERSTAND on Jan 24, 2008 at 09:58 AM
    self-incrimination-the act of acussing one self..Does this mean that Patrick is saying if he HAD to tell the truth he would accuse himself of commiting the crime?? I dont understand....
    Posted by: Anon on Jan 24, 2008 at 09:45 AM
    The fact that Logan's liver bled out in a fairly short period of time proves that the blow that caused the death occured while MM was alone with the little boy.
    Posted by: Sam on Jan 24, 2008 at 09:24 AM
    I pray for swift justice in this case...after viewing the trial - this is definitely a no-brainer!!!!!
    Posted by: complicated on Jan 24, 2008 at 09:01 AM
    The latest does change my opinion of who may be involved in committing the murder. If Patrick tried or did take his own life I don't think it would be because his brother did it. On the other hand I don't think Mike would go to jail the rest of his life to protect his brother.Only explanation I can come up with is they were both involved so I stick with my verdict of guilty.
    Posted by: Leslie on Jan 24, 2008 at 08:29 AM
    I will admit that I am now wondering if MM did the actual abuse. I do know that he should still have to serve prison time along with Eren and his mom and dad. They all saw signs of the abuse and did nothing about it. No one can say that all the physical abuse Logan went through, and all the physical damage that was in plain sight, that no one noticed anything was wrong. I do agree with Go Herd about Patrick M. That makes no sense whatsoever.
    Posted by: Gunny Highway on Jan 24, 2008 at 08:20 AM
    WSAZ has done a great job reporting on this trial. Keep up the good work. I would expect a guilty verdict soon.
    Posted by: Debbie on Jan 24, 2008 at 08:00 AM
    As much as I hate to say it, the poor kids wounds being "likely" caused by sexual assault, does not meet the burden of proof.I REALLY hate to say this, but I can't see a guilty verdict. Poor baby. at least someone will spend some time for his death, his mom, and she deserves to, you're suppose to protect your kids.
    Posted by: Northern Exposure on Jan 24, 2008 at 07:24 AM
    This whole trial is twisted. Now Patrick in the hospital one minute and released the same day when on a ventilator. That was a quick recovery. Was this a stunt planned specifically for the jury? Again, very twisted.
    Posted by: Anonymous on Jan 24, 2008 at 01:56 AM
    I feel that MM is guilty after watching all of the court videos. I do not know any of the people involved in this case but am very distressed in our community's failure to protect it's children. As a member of this community, I want to think that each of us is looking out for the other, especially the young, the weak and the old. In this case I fear we've failed Logan and not spoken up soon enough and given him the protection he deserved. Hopefully this will serve as a constant reminder to us all to get involved when someone is in need.
    Posted by: Online juror on Jan 24, 2008 at 12:22 AM
    I have to agree with Go herd. As much as I hate what happened to this little boy, they only thing the P.A has proven is that this boy was abused, and assaulted. There is no proof given of WHO did it. Only the 'ol "You were the last to see him alive" RIP Logan, and God be with the Juror!!!
    Posted by: Go Herd on Jan 23, 2008 at 10:13 PM
    As someone who has watched every minute of the trial live, the evidence points does not prove MM has done anything. You also have to look at why Pepper Eren so quickly took a plea deal and why is Patrick Merrifield in the hospital the day after he was supposed to testify. Think about it. The police didnt even know to where gloves when collecting evidence so what makes a person think they could tell who is the correct person to charge. Too many things just dont add up. MM should be found not guilty on what the prosecution has presented which has been nothing besides the boy died and no evidence linking any one person to the crime. Everyone learn your constitution and know that this countries laws state MM should be a free man because nothing has been proven.
    Posted by: Anonymous on Jan 23, 2008 at 09:38 PM
    I can only thing of the hell poor Little Logan went through. For those, whoever they were who abused this child, I hope you get what you deserve, and I know you will, either on this side of the grave or in the hereafter. No child should have ever gone through what has been reported that little Logan went through. I know he is with God and is a very important angel.
    Posted by: reader on Jan 23, 2008 at 07:40 PM
    is it just me or did the two defense witnesses wearing leather jackets that did not fit them? wonder where they came from?
    Posted by: nana on Jan 23, 2008 at 07:36 PM
    To: itsashame, you must be a merrifield or a merrifield wannabe. they are a destroyed family, why? oh, yeah, because they hid the abuse of Logan...no sympathy here. where was their sympathy for Logan? oh, yeah, they had NONE..
    Posted by: shell on Jan 23, 2008 at 07:29 PM
    good point WVchuck, I see what your saying I totally didnt see that until i went back and looked it all over. Something certainly isnt right!
    Posted by: Mawmaww on Jan 23, 2008 at 06:39 PM
    This is another example of why it is not always best for the children that the mother gets custody. the women can move in man after man after man into the lives of their children and keep their children away from their real fathers and grandparents. The courts need to wake uo and see that sometimes it is best to give custody to the fathers.
    Posted by: CINDY on Jan 23, 2008 at 06:11 PM
    GOD BLESS THIS LITTLE BOY R.I.P WHAT COMES AROUND WILL GO AROUND
    Posted by: Katie on Jan 23, 2008 at 05:29 PM
    I have followed this trial since it started both on the news and online. And "yes" I do believe mm is so guilty!!! And I also believe all 4 grandparents and other people who came in contact with this precious little boy are also guilty of either covering things up, or just looking the other way!!! My God!!! Are people blind or what?
    Posted by: patty on Jan 23, 2008 at 05:19 PM
    ithank that the boy mon shouldbe ontrial she get offfreethat not right
    Posted by: maridith on Jan 23, 2008 at 03:50 PM
    is it just me or did Mr. Young look and act like he was on something!!! I don't know any of these people personally, just can't forget about what happened to this small child. I am sure he is well taken care of now in heaven. No more tears.
    Posted by: anonymous on Jan 23, 2008 at 03:35 PM
    If any of you knew Michael like I did you would know he is guilty! His daddy has always got him out of everything with his money well guess what not this time hes going to pay for it this time he is a horroble person and always has been
    Posted by: anonymous on Jan 23, 2008 at 03:30 PM
    This is so sad. How could any human abuse a child like that? MM, his parents, his family, her family, everyone who witnessed or saw this abuse needs help -- a lot of help. You can not tell me that someone other than MM and his father, did not see the signs of abuse and to think that his father was voted Family Practice Physician of the Year and saw the abuse on this child and fixed or tried to correct the infliction of this abuse without telling the authorities. That is someone I would want to be Physician of the Year. I am glad he is no longer practicing medicine. Just think maybe he saw other things and never reported them. I hope in their minds they can all answer for what they saw, did or did not do. I know Logan is in Heaven just wondering why he had to suffer this abuse. There is no excuse for a child to be treated this way. I hope whoever caused him to suffer (whoever it may be) suffers the same someday. What goes around comes around.
    Posted by: Deb on Jan 23, 2008 at 02:51 PM
    The issue at hand today is justice for Logan. The good Dr. and his wife will have their day in court and I am sure we will all know a lot more facts about the bad decisions they made. But for now, I am hoping Mike Merrifield gets a guilty verdict on all counts. He took a child's life and he needs to pay. I am thankful a deal was not made for him to plead down to. The prosecution was confidant of his guilt or they wouldn't have proceeded as they have. WV Against Abuse also deserves a hand for their persistance in justice for Logan. They are a great bunch of people and they never give up! Keep up the good work and God Bless you.
    Posted by: M on Jan 23, 2008 at 02:47 PM
    The saddest thing about this case is that little boy had no one in his life that cared ENOUGH. If they did they would have went the extra mile to do something when they had the slightest indication that abuse was taking place.
    Posted by: cindyy on Jan 23, 2008 at 02:11 PM
    were is michael merrifields remorse. sitting in the court room with a dumfounded look on his face. This could also be from years of drug abuse. How could anyone with a concious not look at these pics and be devestated. I hope he and his family get theres.
    Posted by: a loving mother on Jan 23, 2008 at 01:22 PM
    We need to stop CHild abuse and stop protecting the abusers. Unfortunately, there are many stories like this. Everyone should www.parentsbehavingbadly.com
    Posted by: Jewell on Jan 23, 2008 at 12:25 PM
    Every sex offender that had contact with Logan..needs to be on trial with the rest of the pathetic monster's!! HOW SICK!!
    Posted by: Jewell on Jan 23, 2008 at 12:22 PM
    Michael commented.. he didn't think he could go back to the home...too many memories... he has no reason to go back.. Logan is not there..
    Posted by: Sam on Jan 23, 2008 at 11:35 AM
    Oh my God...the witnessess for the defense ...some sick entertainment.
    Posted by: Northern Exposure on Jan 23, 2008 at 11:11 AM
    Thank goodness the jury has the case now. Let's hope they all can come to the same conclusion and resolve this matter as soon as possible. I cannot believe this has taken over 2 years to come to trial. Let this poor baby rest in peace now.
    Posted by: Charlie on Jan 23, 2008 at 11:06 AM
    To fathers out there that have kids being raised by their ex wives & girlfriends through no fault of their own. Please wake up if your not involved with your kids you should be. If someone is keeping you from seeing them (red flag).Your childern need you .Be there for them there is nothing more important than that. NOTHING.Sometimes you are the only person they may have to protect them....WAKE UP!
    Posted by: rainbow on Jan 23, 2008 at 11:04 AM
    Wow that Mr. Young sounded right silly on the stand, run for office I sure would not vote for him!
    Posted by: itsashame on Jan 23, 2008 at 10:45 AM
    To "a loving mother" -- this is West Virginia -- not some T.V. show. Defense witnesses are NOT paid to testify at trial. Expert witnesses are paid (which would be a medical examiner, a doctor, etc.) and there is a process the Court goes through to approve someone to be an expert witness. Character and fact witnesses ARE NOT PAID. Have you ever heard of perjury? Lying on the stand for someone is not worth any amount of money so you can rest assured that those under oath likely spoke they truth as they saw it. Additionally, Patrick Merrifield would not have invoked his 5th amendment right in order not to implicate his brother -- it was done in order to not implicate himself! This board is bordering on hysteria -- everyone should use their energies to do something other than run down an already destroyed family.
    Posted by: Moe on Jan 23, 2008 at 09:39 AM
    If ever there were a case meeting the criteria for the death penalty, this one is it. But of course the death of Merrifield would be considered cruel and unusual punishment for the short length of time it takes to inject the drugs, and from all the evidence, poor baby Logan went through MONTHS of torture. I am so proud of our law makers who decide these matters.
    Posted by: Hope on Jan 23, 2008 at 09:12 AM
    To CP. I have no doubt that Dr. & Mrs. Merrifield have done good things the majority of their lives. I believe that when it came to their child(ren), they lost sight of right and wrong because they have covered for and protected MM for the majority of his life. It's a cold hard fact that one act or inaction in a person's life can be what defines them despite all the other good.
    Posted by: Hope on Jan 23, 2008 at 09:05 AM
    Concerned Citizen said re: Patrick: "he couldnt even help his brother because he knows that his brother is guilty. He knows if he were to be put on the stand he would have to tell the truth about how his brother was abusive to logan." The 5th Amend. is used to protect oneself from SELF-incrimination. IMO Patrick is protecting himself, NOT Michael.
    Posted by: a loving mother on Jan 23, 2008 at 08:36 AM
    The kentucky ex-ME also did not review the body of Logan, he only reviewed Medical records and autopsy reports, for which he was paid for the review and his statements.
    Posted by: a loving mother on Jan 23, 2008 at 08:05 AM
    The witnesses do get paid, especially the doctors.
    Posted by: Interesting on Jan 23, 2008 at 06:43 AM
    So what is said by the judge when they guy says he witnessed alot of "illegal things"??? Lets see the un-edited version.
    Posted by: Anonymous on Jan 23, 2008 at 01:05 AM
    Sure would like to hear what was said at the end of the Mark Hereford testimony..judge got involved there for some reason..And this is all just opinion NO FACT...It is MY OPINION that he exagerates, it is MY OPINION that he lies. If they know when someone is lying so well, they should become detectives themselves...Is it true what someone else said that these witnesses get paid???
    Posted by: nate on Jan 23, 2008 at 12:48 AM
    "Dont get ahead of me Elijah" I know we went over this story 100 times..just slow down..you have to say exactly what i taught you..Not a "steady paced" story to convince me..I think I recogonize that guy..Yea he was holding a Will Work 4 Food sign..thats where the Defense got him from....COME ON...LETS GET REAL!!!
    Posted by: CP on Jan 22, 2008 at 11:26 PM
    I NOT ONLY WAS A PATIENT OF JOHN MERRIFIELDS, MY PARENTS WERE CLOSE FRIENDS OF HE AND DIANE. NOONE MENTIONS ALL THE HELPFUL THINGS THE TWO HAVE DONE FOR EVERYONE!WHEN MY MOTHER PAST AWAY THEY TOOK MY SISTER AND I TO TEA ROOMS FOR BRUNCH,THE LIBRARY,AND AS I GOT OLDER THEY CONTINUED TO MAKE SURE ME AND MY FAMILY WERE OK. THEY ARE THE MOST LOVING,GIVING,THOUGHTFUL PEOPLE AND ARE NOT CAPABLE OF LETTING AN INNOCENT CHILD BE ABUSED. DR.MERRIFIELD TOLD PEPPER AFTER SEEING LOGAN TO TAKE HIM TO ANOTHER DOCTOR FOR THE BURN ON HIS BOTTOM AND ONCE AGAIN SHE PUT HER CHILDS HEALTH TO THE SIDE TO TEND TO HER DRUG ABUSE. SHES HIS MOTHER MIKE WAS NOT HIS FATHER SHE SHOULD HAVE FOLLOWED UP WITH THE OTHER DOCTOR. SHE NEGLECTED THIS CHILD TIME AND TIME AGAIN WHY DOESN'T ANYONE MENTION THIS.THIS CHILDS GRANDMOTHER SHOULD HAVE NOTICED THE ABUSE I WOULD NOT OVERLOOK IT W/MY CHILDREN. THIS LADY INSTEAD GOES TO THE COURTHOUSE TO SALE YES I SAID SALE T-SHIRTS W/HER DECEASED GRANDSONS PICTURE ON THEM.WHAT'S THA
    Posted by: Anonymous on Jan 22, 2008 at 10:16 PM
    I seen some of the trial today,and I just wonder were did the Defense team get those crazy witness at.And want is up with Patrick?
    Posted by: intelligent on Jan 22, 2008 at 09:38 PM
    There are convictions every day based on circumstancial evidence. How many crimes are actually "SEEN"? Anybody, I say ANYBODY that listens or reads the testimony given by the ME and would still give MM the "DOUBT" of not inflicting injuries to this baby have to be callous, black hearted and hopefully does not have a child themselves !!! Even if there was not sexual abuse (which is stupid not to think!)any ONE of the injuries that happened during the period of time that he was in the care of Mike Merrifield would indicate he participated or approved of the abuse. Therefore, let him be guilty of just ONE ! just ONE I say is all that is needed to put MM, Pepper, Dr. Merrifield, Mrs Merrifield,Merrifields family, Jeremy Goodall(and family)and the Eren's (family also included) and any other individual to be sent to jail for the remainder of their lives. Let them think about what they could have prevented and why they will never have freedom again. Prisoners will also remind them !!
    Posted by: JERRY on Jan 22, 2008 at 09:31 PM
    iF PEOPLE COULD SEE THE WAY THAT MIKE M ACTS IN COURT YOU WOULD BE SICK, HE SETS AT THE DEFENSE TABLE AND EATS SPREES AND DRINKS PEPSI LIKE HE HAS NO CARE IN THE WORLD, HIS DEFENSE ATTORNEYS MUST BE SUPPLYING HIM WITH SNACKS FOR THE TRIAL.I HOPE HE ROTTS IN PRISON AND MAYBE HIS FAMILY CAN BRING HIM SNACKS FOR THE REST OF HIS LIFE, HE MAKES ME SICK
    Posted by: Mom of 5 on Jan 22, 2008 at 07:40 PM
    I think this case is a perfect example of what can and does happen when your life revolves around drugs. Only Pepper, Logan and Michael truly know what happened to that precious little baby, but the sad fact is that there is no possibility of caring appropriately for a little one when your life revolves around drugs. We all know that Pepper was on drugs, and although Michael had prescriptions for his pills he sure wasn't taking them as prescribed, just ask all the friends his dad wrote scripts for so he could feed his habit. Pepper is doing her time and no matter how many days she serves in prison she will have to live with a life sentence of knowing what that baby endured, I just hope Michael and his parents get the same. My fear is that the sentence will have to come from the courts because I can't imagine that they would have a conscious when they were so willing to cover up the abuse that sweet little baby was suffering.
    Posted by: goodness on Jan 22, 2008 at 07:37 PM
    the child never had a chance, every where you turned, there was a pedophile
    Posted by: Baffled on Jan 22, 2008 at 05:42 PM
    To Mandy...I guess it is just a coincidence that MM was with Logan everytime one of the discussed injuries were brought up. Man, he must have horrible luck.....
    Posted by: concerned citizen on Jan 22, 2008 at 05:14 PM
    mike is soooo guilty... why else would patrick not testify.. he couldnt even help his brother because he knows that his brother is guilty. He knows if he were to be put on the stand he would have to tell the truth about how his brother was abusive to logan. It doesnt take a genius to figure this one out.. oh and mandy is so in denial.
    Posted by: Concerned on Jan 22, 2008 at 04:45 PM
    Mandy, many are guilty in this case but Mike is the one on trial right now; there has been nothing to show his innocence, much to show his guilt....there are ramifications to his guilt that are far reaching, including causing pain to you, his family, Logan's family, etc. I feel bad that you are hurting, perhaps you are close to Mike or a member of his family, but listen to the testimony - the fatal injuries occurred 8 to 24 hours before his death; Pepper wasn't there until 1/2 hour before his death, they didn't occur during that time - Mike was there Mandy, Mike and Patrick!
    Posted by: a loving mother on Jan 22, 2008 at 04:30 PM
    The evidence was not refuted, he merely said that, he could not say one way or the other if he was sexually abused. DO you also know that the defense witnesses are paid large amounts to come and testify at Trials?
    Posted by: Heather on Jan 22, 2008 at 04:12 PM
    RIP Baby Logan, you're safe now in Jesus's arms. May these people live in Hell on earth for the rest of their lives!! How could you leave your baby with the devil? We will never forget you Logan.
    Posted by: Mandy on Jan 22, 2008 at 04:04 PM
    Too often, we hear about people who have been imprisoned for crimes they did not commit. These indictments arose from circumstantial evidence. In my opinion, the evidence presented thus far in this case is purely circumstantial. Admittedly, I have not heard today's testimony. Today, the prosecution's premise that Logan was sexually assaulted was refuted by a peer of the ME. At this juncture, you have accused, tried, and sentenced a person who may only be guilty of loving the child's mother and honoring her wishes prior to the child's death. Guilty until proven innocent?
    Posted by: Someone Amused on Jan 22, 2008 at 03:40 PM
    *****Jonathon Hereford of Cross Lanes said he had been with Merrifield and Logan on several occasions. "I saw nothing but love for that kid from Michael," he said. Hereford also said that he had met Logan's mother, Pepper Eren, through Merrifield. He said two days after Logan's death she dropped by his house and then went along with him to a bar called Julie J's on Kanawha Boulevard in Charleston. Hereford said he saw her drinking and about 2 a.m., he said, she was obviously under the influence of cocaine.***** I'm sorry- I just saw this in the paper and had to laugh... I have been following this case because I have been "acquainted" with some of the people involved. Honestly, anyone that has ran with that crowd knows that ALL of these guys do cocaine. Pepper has admitted her problem, what about the rest of them?! When do they fess up to their drug use?! Give me a freakin' break! I really hope these "witnesses" have been drug tested...
    Posted by: EEE on Jan 22, 2008 at 03:25 PM
    Poor Logan!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
    Posted by: a loving mother on Jan 22, 2008 at 03:07 PM
    If patrick is pleading the 5th, then we know he is also involved. Their guilt is undeniable.
    Posted by: Diana on Jan 22, 2008 at 02:52 PM
    There is something to be said for "an eye for an eye" in a case such as this. Little ones do not deserve to go thru such pain. Merrifield and all who knew or had an incling of what was being done to Logan should be punished in the same way that was inflicted on Logan!!!
    Posted by: Tonya on Jan 22, 2008 at 01:57 PM
    What I dont understand is why they can not just give a lie dector test.I am sorry but he is gulty and so is the mother.Any mother should of known something was not right. But for the Dr to not report it becuase it was his son he should be threw in jail and throw away the key.Reading these stories make me sick at my stomach that someone could hurt a child like this and have no remorse.He just sets there with no remorse if he really loved this boy like a son he should be showing some emotion when others have testified to what the boy looked like.I know the little boy is in a better place but M stills needs to pay for what he did.I think WV needs the death penalty back, then maybe we wouldnt have these situtations. A Eye for a Eye, A life for a Life! Is Tracy a girlfriend now? She sure takes up for him!
    Posted by: concerned citizen on Jan 22, 2008 at 12:35 PM
    I agree with both Debbie and "D". First the Eren's testify to seeing injuries and on the next breath they say they haven't seen Logan in quite some time. It was the Eren's responsbility as well as the Merrifield's to say something to the proper authorities. The money that was obtained by the settlement on Dr. Merrifield's civil case should be given to charity. I am curious to know if part of the settlement agreement indicates the good doctor admitted to negligence by not reporting suspicious injuries. May this child rest in peace while the rest of his dysfunctional family point blame to everyone else.
    Posted by: a mother of three on Jan 22, 2008 at 12:33 PM
    Debbie, its so easy for you to say what you would do but you are not in this situation so until you are then you should not judge anyone. I believe the reason why the grandparents did not report was because there was always an excuse for logans injuries and he was being seen by a medical physician. This Dr has been a family physician for many of the eren's relatives over the years. They had no reason not to trust him or his judgement. I believe these are loving grandparents who helped raise logan and i think your remarks are uncalled for and very judgmental. To my knowledge, cps was called but before they could investigte, logan had died. Remember pepper had only been with mike for 4 months. The bottom line is if this child was not abused, he would still be alive today. Lets put the blame where blame is deserved and not on the loving grandparents who i feel so sorry for. My thoughts and prayers go out to his family because i know they are suffering greatly.
    Posted by: DEBBIE on Jan 22, 2008 at 11:09 AM
    As a grandmother of 4, if one of my grandchildren came to my home with the bruises and injuries that the Eren's said Logan had I myself would call CPS. I blame all of them, the abusers, Dr. M for hiding it and the Grandparents who saw these injuries and done nothing. Too many people saw the injuries but not one person done anything about it. Had Peppers parents done something when they saw these bruises they may have their grandson with them today.
    Posted by: Hope on Jan 22, 2008 at 09:38 AM
    To D. I share your disgust at the details of this case, however, I believe it is imparative that the details are shared. To not reveal the horrifying details of this matter would be hiding the truth and protecting the murderers.
    Posted by: myrtle on Jan 22, 2008 at 05:25 AM
    how could any one do a baby like that,i think that they should put merrifield to death he needs to die for what he did to that sweet little boy,
    Posted by: Mom on Jan 22, 2008 at 01:53 AM
    hey guys try this one on-I think the final abuse that killed poor, beautiful Logan was done by dear sweet mom. However, MM doesn't have clean hands-I think he is the one that put this sweet angel in scalding hot water. I also think Pepper is not getting all that she deserves. Those tears were fake-she neither loved or cared about Logan-I think she got off way too easy mr. prosecutor.... They were both abusing this child.... am I the only one that can see this?
    Posted by: CURIOUS on Jan 22, 2008 at 12:10 AM
    Mandy, is it you? Are you guilty of the ATROCITIES? Did you abuse Logan? You said it could be you. It seems that you are the only one not listening to the facts. Isnt it a fact that Mike treated this child abusively at the pool. So much so that it upset another male adult and obviously others since the abuse was reported by someone other than the witness that testified. Or maybe you think it is funny to throw a young child in the pool repeatedly while he is gasping for air and turning pale. Im sorry that you are having such a hard time for seeing mm for the monster that he is. Thats okay, he will get his paybacks while he spends the rest of his life in prison. I am certain of that! The only conjecture on my part is wondering as to what mm was thinking when he thought he could get away with this. No diversionary tactics here, just the facts. Something you obviously know nothing about.
    Posted by: lori on Jan 21, 2008 at 11:55 PM
    mandy, of course pepper is guilty i think everyone knows that including pepper. She is right where she should be. But you must not be listening to the testimony closely. Everytime logan was hurt guess who was with him. Lets see, logan fell down the bleachers at the power game, who was with him, Yes that would be mm. Logan was burned by chemicals, who was with him mm again. Logan was bitten by a dog (doubtful) who was with him. That is not judging, that is known facts. Did you not hear the testimony involving the swimming pool? or did you choose to just ignore that? Do you consider that normal behavior to treat a baby that way? oh and the cps investigation you are referring to happened about two weeks before logan died. So yes, pepper and mike were together then. So the folks that know some folks have sadly obtained the wrong information. Working in the medical profession, it is unlikey that it would take DAYS for symptons to show up especially when a child is bleeding.
    Posted by: Mandy on Jan 21, 2008 at 10:12 PM
    Lori, Are these more diversionary tactics? My information is neither supposition nor insider information. I know some folks who know some folks. I have never met MM. I am not part of the inner circle, but I am an objective person. I know that if someone were to hit you in the stomach hard enough to cause internal bleeding that your symptoms may not show up for days. If you died while standing next to your mother, would she then be guilty? The only conjecture on my part is wondering as to what Pepper was afraid of. Why would anyone plead out to a crime that would put them in jail for two years if they were not guilty of something more egregious? If she was not guilty of something more heinous, why did she not plead to something on a smaller scale with less time involved?
    Posted by: Sunny on Jan 21, 2008 at 09:43 PM
    I agree with Mandy. I have often heard that people who are insistent of blaming others are usually guilty themselves.
    Posted by: Mandy on Jan 21, 2008 at 09:11 PM
    To Baffled: Based on ME's testimony, there is no doubt that the child was physically abused. The issue is whether or not MM inflicted the abuse. Pepper has already pleaded out to lesser charges, making me wonder what she was trying to avoid. How can you be certain that MM perpetrated the abuse? How can you be certain of who abused the child based upon the testimony to date. From what I've heard so far, anyone close to the child COULD be guilty of the atrocities...mother...boyfriend...grandfather...grandmother (wields a wicked cane). For all we know at this point, it could be you or me. You are not listening to the facts; you are pre-judging.
    Posted by: Rainbow on Jan 21, 2008 at 05:30 PM
    FOR SUNNY: How much are getting paid ? saying you would leave your kids with MM you must be a complete idiot! I feel for your children!
    Posted by: D on Jan 21, 2008 at 01:30 PM
    First, I have to say I cry every time I read, hear or see anything about this little boy. I wish they would not share the graphic details, as it only paints a more vivid picture of the torture inflicted upon little little baby boy. I, did not know him or anyone related to him but feel very affected by this situation as would anyone with human emotion. I feel the person accused is guilty. I feel for the family of Logan Goodall, but I can tell you that there is no REAL excuse for not knowing what was going on. NONE! Especially by the so called father of this little boy. The Mother, well she will live hell for what she allowd to happen to the child she gave birth to, or so we hope. But, for the so called father. I have a question to you? Are you going to take that enormous sum of money you won from the Merrifield's by way of your child's death after your own neglect as well, and give it to a charitable fund that will help keep other little children safe? I hope you do, but I doubt it.
    Posted by: Baffled on Jan 21, 2008 at 01:18 PM
    How can anyone who actually listened to the ME's testimony believe that MM isn't guilty?
    Posted by: lori on Jan 21, 2008 at 08:38 AM
    Mandy you are so sadly mistaken and uninformed. I would love to know where you got your information from. Im sure it is all personal opinion and definitely not FACTS. I personally know the family of Logans and they never harmed that child nor would they ever. Obviously you are friends of the good Dr and MM and sorry to say that you HEARD WRONG. And im also sorry to say that your good friend was the only one home with logan when he passed away. NEED I SAY MORE.And if that was true about cps, then we wouldnt be here right now , now would we? get a life, your friends are going DOWN! Oh and you just admitted that Dr. M obliged to hekp her.. so he did cover it up... hmmm thanks for the info..you people are unreal!
    Posted by: a loving mother on Jan 21, 2008 at 08:19 AM
    I pray that your children haven't sustained any damage that they didn't tell you about while staying with MM. You obviously hold some personal relationship with him. I'm glad you can post on here while remaining anonymous, or I'm sure people would tell you to your face how wrong you are.
    Posted by: Chuck on Jan 21, 2008 at 12:34 AM
    Terry you have your facts mistaken. Logan wasn't anywhere near me for 3 months before his death. And I was accused of a misdemeanor that was 25 years ago and it was involving one person. I never got a chance to face my accuser and I was never accused of anything violent at all. Nor have I ever been in trouble with the law before or after I was accused of this one time incident. They've got who they want in this case and he will pay! "Chucky"
    Posted by: Tracy on Jan 21, 2008 at 12:22 AM
    To alice, you are wrong everyone of the merrifields will prove the inocent. No actually the defense has to prove them guilty. Wich is imposablewhen the isnt any.
    Posted by: to niki phillips on Jan 21, 2008 at 12:03 AM
    quit lieing he didnt lock his parents in the basement. You all are just a buch of sickos for dwelling on the anyways, Let the fscts decide not some sickos.
    Posted by: Mandy on Jan 20, 2008 at 11:46 PM
    The judge in this case is a kind, caring person who is genuinely interested in children. I truly believe that the truth will come out in this trial. MM may or may not be guilty of physically abusing Logan, but I personally believe that Pepper & her family abused the child (see Kanawha CPS records) long before MM came into the picture. As I heard it, Doc M wanted to report abuse when she and Michael took Logan to him, but Pepper talked him out of reporting abuse due to her history with CPS. Doc M obliged to protect her, not MM. I surmise that comments on here by Pepper's family are purely diversionary to hide their own guilt.
    Posted by: Anonymous on Jan 20, 2008 at 10:00 PM
    Dr.Kaplan did so well on the stand.And I think the Jury beleives that after seeing the pics.MM is guilty.Wthe defence team brings in there so call witnesses they would have to be telling lies.They need a back ground check on some of them.And why hasn't Patrick been to the trial?IS HE HIDEINIG?IS HE ONE OF MM SO CALL WITNESS
    Posted by: Misc. on Jan 20, 2008 at 05:42 PM
    John if you are correct about "Chucky" then I'm sure the defense for MM will bring that up.
    Posted by: Im on Logans side on Jan 20, 2008 at 01:01 AM
    For Sunny: did u not listen to the med examiners testimony? Someone had sexually abused that child 12-16 hrs before his death! Hmm wonder that was? I DO think Mike M did this..and I think Pepper is just as guilty, because she knew what was going on..I wouldnt even let someone hurt an animal like that..How can u see cuts and bruises on your child and not care? HOW!! Doc M may be a good dr, but he let a innocent child suffer..so his son could keep taking his anger and rage and sickness out on Logan! BOttom line is this..there is so many people to blame: NO ONE CARED ENOUGH TO CALL CPS OR THE POLICE FOR LOGAN. PEOPLE KNEW WHAT WAS HAPPENING TO HIM..BUT THEY TURNED AWAY..TURNED AWAY FROM A CHILD WHO WAS TOO YOUNG TO SAY HE NEEDED HELP..OR IF EVER DID ASK HIS MOTHER, WELL SHE DIDNT WANT TO GET IN TROUBLE. IF SOMEONE WOULD HAVE TAKEN UP FOR LOGAN- HE MIGHT BE IN A NICE WARM HOME TONITE..BUT HE HIS DEFINETLY BETTER OFF WHERE HE IS...IN A PLACE WHERE HE WILL NEVER KNOW PAIN AGAIN.
    Posted by: mother of 2 on Jan 20, 2008 at 01:01 AM
    I think there's 3 people who know what happened, that's baby Logan, Michael, and God.I don't think Pepper abused Logan, but after time was in denial about Michael abusing him. I think Michael's parents were protecting him, because dr's have reported alot less suspicious situations to protective services. I also think since Pepper admitted to drug use, that possibly meth was being made in the home and that's why baby Logan felt so sick the day he died, considering they found high levels of a certain acid in his little body. Maybe Pepper left for work and Michael became pissed off because he had to care for the boy and went into a rage and began a physically abusing him which led to his unfortunate death. I do believe he was sexually abused also, maybe it wasn't by Michael and maybe it was. My personal opinion is that he was the person doing it, considering he was the person with baby Logan all the time. Sometimes things are right in front of us. Just read between the lines.
    Posted by: Anonymous on Jan 20, 2008 at 12:05 AM
    the person(s) responsible for this will pay for this..God sees everything...that poor little child is in heaven and not in pain anymore...although he lived a rough little life here on earth hes in good hands now
    Posted by: TAMMY on Jan 19, 2008 at 10:28 PM
    I HOPE WHO DID THIS ROTS IN HELL
    Posted by: Jennifer Royston on Jan 19, 2008 at 07:46 PM
    I can't believe after hearing all the testamony, that a jury would have any choice other than to find him guilty. When he is in prison, the other inmates will take care of him as he deserves. They will make his life miserable and thank God for that.
    Posted by: Niki on Jan 19, 2008 at 07:11 PM
    To Answers: I fully agree. The list of injuries to that poor defenseless child are heart breaking. Only an animal could have done such things to a child. My questions are just trying to understand the psyche of MM....He was 30 years old, same age as my son; in fact, he was born days before my own son was in Thomas Memorial. I knew his father...now, parents generally love their children (Pepper and Michael are excepted here); however, do you love your child so much that you excuse their behavior all of their lives until they harm an innocent child? This is what I cannot understand and am trying to get a handle on...John Merrifield is a doctor who's entire career has been treating the sick and injured. Did he simiply stand by and know his son was abusing an innocent baby? How could Diane and John Merrifield NOT know what was going on? Cuts and bruises on a toddler - yes, they all have them. But these types of injuries? NO WAY.
    Posted by: Mother, Grandma, and Nurse on Jan 19, 2008 at 07:01 PM
    To Tracy, got kids? If so we should call CPS now, if not, we pray you never do. What is your motive defending the scrum? The doctor's money? Pepper kept Logan from Jeremy and grandparents? Relationship lasted too long to have kept me from him that long. The child would have died from either the bleeding in the skull or cuts to the liver and pancreas. "Doctor of the Year" and Grandpa wow, how terrifying, guilty as Michael. Mrs. Merrifield, Grandma,lets not leave her out. No dog bite is a straight cut. Listen to the testimony of the medical examiner. What that poor baby endured! That God he is no longer in pain. Take comfort and rest assured, that in prison there is no lower scum that child killers and child molesters. Michael will feel the pain that a little boy felt and hopefully so will Mr and Mrs Merrifield and Pepper. What kind of Mother doesn't notice those bruises and believes thos lies? She didn't even question Logan? Hope Daddys money doesn't affect punishment.RIP beautiful baby
    Posted by: Sunny on Jan 19, 2008 at 06:14 PM
    First for disbelief, you are the idiot, it was not Clifford asking about the girlfriend it was Rebrook. For you Asia, yes I would leave my child with Michael, as a matter of fact I have left my children with Michael and Patrick and nothing happened to them, and as for Patrick working that has nothing to do with this but for you information-yes. As for Terry, I believe Micheal is innocent and I have had my head checked several times, there is nothing wrong with it. Brenda, you need to get your facts straight about the sexual abuse, there was no DNA evidence of any sexual abuses. It is speculation as is this whole case. Everybody has speculated what happened, nothing concrete has been proved.
    Posted by: Answers on Jan 19, 2008 at 12:53 PM
    Niki, no one has said if MM was on drugs; he stated in testimony he worked in Alaska (seasonal)....he has a long history of arrests but nothing this violent; Patrick was working...MM said in interview with investigator he had a good relationship with his parents. It doesn't matter that he couldn't drive, he had a phone to call for help. For the full truth, you probably have to ask him and/or family...regardless, nothing accounts for the way this child had to suffer
    Posted by: Niki on Jan 19, 2008 at 10:03 AM
    Some help here, please. I only see what the videos show and the newspapers write. Has it come out in the trial that Michael Merrifield was perhaps on drugs, too? Why wasn't he working like Pepper was? Why did he not have a vehicle? Has any testimony come out about his physological evaluation? What about his past? Arrests, DUI's, trouble with the law? His childhood? Any knowledge about that? All of these would indicate someone who had problems and would severely harm a child. I read that he was violent.....Is that true? Any help here would be appreciated in helping me understand this situation. Also, does anyone know anything about his relationship with his parents? And Patrick - does he work? What does he do? Was one parent the enabler and let him do whatever he wanted, while one sat back and closed their eyes? Did he ever suffer consequences for any trouble he may have gotten it? Anyone who knows the truth about these questions out there and who could respond?
    Posted by: Asia on Jan 19, 2008 at 08:34 AM
    My question to the people here that have made statements proclaiming merrifield's innocence...would YOU leave your children alone with him after hearing all this??!! Deep down I don't think you would
    Posted by: disbelief on Jan 19, 2008 at 07:03 AM
    Clifford is an idiot. What does that guys ex-gf have to do with anything. Who would want to be involved in something like this. NOT ME-but if I get served..i get served. Its not intimidation that if you dont show up you go to jail-ITS THE LAW-You get papers you better be in court! What an A**. Witness0"Ive never heard that" Clifford "Well you have now" MTV's JACK***
    Posted by: heather on Jan 19, 2008 at 02:07 AM
    IT TAKES A SICK PERSON TO LAY A HAND ON A LITTLE KID LIKE THAT
    Posted by: Terry on Jan 19, 2008 at 01:55 AM
    I think anyone who thinks Michael Merrifield is innocent.Needs their heads checked.
    Posted by: lid on Jan 18, 2008 at 08:37 PM
    i would like to say that there is evil lerking everywhere in this world and we all need to be aware of people like them.it is soooo awful what happened to little logan, no one really knows the depth of pain and torture the little baby had to go through this world is so messed up with politics and so called friends doing friends a favor its like a private cult. anyone verbally,physically,mentally,abusing a child should not be allowed to live their lives only in prison but took out and tortured every minute of the day, but know when judgement day comes there are going to be some very sorry people in this world. people better get right with God and stay away from the devil and his doings. i only pray that those who are at blame get their deserved sentence. and those who are not may GOD BE WITH YOU AND SOFTEN YOUR SORROW.
    Posted by: Brenda on Jan 18, 2008 at 08:26 PM
    Charlie, John is incorrect; the child molestor he is referring to was not around Logan for several months before his death; it hasn't been brought out because it's not true...people need to get their facts straight. The injuries were multiple and inflicted over a long period of time; he was sexually and physically abused in the last hours of his life....that man was not around.
    Posted by: beth on Jan 18, 2008 at 08:03 PM
    I have known michael for years, i was friends with an ex girlfriend who he abused physically and mentally. I believe he is guilty he is the only one who had acess to this child everyday all day. His mother shows remorse and admits she is a bad mom. He is a monster and his parents would have turned anyone else in that would have shown injuries caused from child abuse. Money talks but not in this case. I hate to think of what this baby went through. Im sure he looked for comfort from his mother but she wasnt there. They will all meet there maker one day and its not gonna be pretty.
    Posted by: April on Jan 18, 2008 at 07:13 PM
    Luke 8:17 For nothing is secret, that shall not be made manifest; neither any thing hidden, that shall not be known and come to light.
    Posted by: Jack on Jan 18, 2008 at 05:59 PM
    If merrifield and the mother did not cause the abuse, who did. give me a break, they both abused the little boy. if he was sexually asualted hours before he died, and merrifield was the only one with him, it dosent take much to figure it out.
    Posted by: sadmom on Jan 18, 2008 at 05:58 PM
    This case is sooo upsetting. Just looking at that baby's picture and hearing what happened to him makes me want to cry. As a mother, I know that children have accidents and get bumps and bruises. They get injured. I do not know what Dr. Merrifield saw on this baby, or what he treated him for, but you would think a physician would know abusive type injuries. As far as the burns on his bottom, one would think it would have to be scalding hot water to burn so bad he couldn't sit. As a medical professional, you are required by law to report suspected abuse. I feel sorry for this innocent child, that had no one to protect him. If your child was lethargic, why would you keep him home and feed him soup by a syringe? Why would you not take him to the ER? If you had nothing to hide, why would you be affraid. Also, if your child had a seizure, why would you squeeze him or put him up against a wall? That seems extreme. God can now protect this baby, its a shame no one could here!!!!
    Posted by: john on Jan 18, 2008 at 04:36 PM
    Well it looks like the media better start getting there check books out.
    Posted by: Charlie on Jan 18, 2008 at 03:12 PM
    To John what are you talking about 6 time convicted child molester 3 days before his death...Haven't heard anything about that if it is true WHY has it not been brought out? Someone verify this please!
    Posted by: Charlie on Jan 18, 2008 at 03:07 PM
    Everyone is entitled to ones own opinion no matter how ridiculas. This is the bottom line it is not an opinion but fact-Mike & Pepper have both admitted to having knowledge of Logan's injuries prior to his death. NO WAY the child could have done this to himself either by falling or otherwise & he sure did not sexually assault himself. Mike is lying when he told Pepper & everyone else that he fell causing his injuries. Mike knows how Logan got the injuries but he is lying either to protect himself or someone else. If you are reading this you must be able to read what is in this transcript you don't believe your own eyes,ears & sight or just plain dumb.I believe some of the comments are from immature people who just want to start an argument. Well you are not being taken seriously no one pays much attention to off the wall remarks anyway. Either Mike done it which I think he did or he knows who did either way life in prison is to good for anyone who did this to this precious child .
    Posted by: Tammy on Jan 18, 2008 at 02:27 PM
    Come on people he's guilty!!! This sweet innocent child suffered a horrible death and was not protected by anyone in his presence. This man who calls himself a Doctor should have recognized abuse but covered it up to protect his sick & evil son. I hope and pray that justice is served for all involved. God be with this little boy's so called mother who has to live with this the rest of her life. I sure would'nt want to be in her shoes.
    Posted by: Lori on Jan 18, 2008 at 01:37 PM
    Well, it is a tragic day, another little one suffering from abuse and neglect. I currently have custody of a 5 yr.old little nephew,whose little brother, 1 yr. old was beaten to death in Kenton CO. Ky. Oct. 06. We are waiting for justice, which will never be served in jail, because our little one suffered from blunt force trauma, back of the head, trauma to forhead,which unattached his retina, bruising from head to toe, broken femur bone. The mother,also was on drugs but worked a nightshift job. She left her three children, 7,4,1,yrs. of age with a 20 yr. old drug addict, temporary boyfriend of 3 mo. So the abuse was ongoing with these kids, I lived 2 hours away and was not aware of the abuse/neglect. But when you get a call at 3:00 a.m. calling the family in, the death of a 1 yr. old with injuries like this, to the point of a death of a child, somewhere the system is failing, they are murdering our babies every day and getting by with it. Blaming drugs. Pray to God for the little ones.
    Posted by: someone who cares on Jan 18, 2008 at 12:28 PM
    How dare you people to blame logans family. The family that loved him so much and that pratically raised him until Mike came into the picture. It is so easy for you to sit here and say I would do this and I would do that, but until you ARE in this situation, you have no right to put blame on a loving family. You ALL ought to be ashamed of yourselves. Logan was in the care of a doctor and like said so many times before, LOGAN WAS KEPT AWAY FROM HIS FAMILY WHEN PEPPER MET MIKE.And when questioned, their was always a reason to everyting that happened to logan. The grandparents loved their grandchild so much and have never been the same since this happened. You Judgemental people are so evil, i hope you never find yourself in a similar situation. Im sure you ALL ARE PERFECT.
    Posted by: Rebecca on Jan 18, 2008 at 12:14 PM
    Innocent people don't tell so many inconsistent stories. If he is so innocent, then he WILL take the stand to defend his actions and the Merrifields WILL do the same without pleading the 5th. Innocent people have nothing to hide.
    Posted by: GodsChild on Jan 18, 2008 at 10:57 AM
    God saw Logan's abuse and scooped him up in His arms and took him home. I sincerely pray that everyone involved begs forgiveness and comes to know God's mercy. I look at my 2 yr old son and cannot imagine why anyone would hurt a baby. But we can all rest easier knowing that Logan has no pain now, no bruises. God bless those who loved Logan and have to live each day knowing his fate. Remember, vengence is mine saith the Lord.
    Posted by: Mom of 2 on Jan 18, 2008 at 10:09 AM
    Being a Mother of 2 children ages 1 & 2, I can not describe how heartbreaking this story is to me, this makes me so sick what that beautiful baby boy went through..GOD BLESS LOGAN GOODALL's FAMILY! MY THOUGHTS & PRAYERS ARE w/ YOU!
    Posted by: Lena on Jan 18, 2008 at 09:49 AM
    When the jury gets done looking at the photos of Logan after he died and listening to Dr. Kaplan they will see that Michael was the only person that could have murdered the baby.
    Posted by: Rachel on Jan 18, 2008 at 09:16 AM
    Tony, please - bad decisions and neglect in this case?? Logan had a ruptured liver and severe head trauma - He was covered with bruises. This is not neglect, it is murder!
    Posted by: lea on Jan 18, 2008 at 08:59 AM
    To anon maybe thats who the GOOD doctor wanted you to see how do we know what went on behind closed doors.
    Posted by: B on Jan 18, 2008 at 08:30 AM
    I agree with Tracy and ask myself how many of you actually know what you are talking about. I believe you just see testimony from one side, read the comments and agree with the masses. This is America have your own opinion and also INNOCENT UNTIL PROVEN GUILTY is still in play correct? Enough said just continue to stay glued to your tvs and computers while the TRUTH unfolds.
    Posted by: reader on Jan 18, 2008 at 08:12 AM
    i agree with anon, i too have wondered how many in that family was involved. to overlook it, says that they also had a hand in it.
    Posted by: rainbow on Jan 18, 2008 at 08:08 AM
    Money Talks! I am sure Mike will get off with nothing! is the good doctor still in practice??
    Posted by: john on Jan 18, 2008 at 12:54 AM
    why hasen't anyone brought the fact that the child was whith a 6 time convicted child molester 3 days before his death.
    Posted by: Tony on Jan 18, 2008 at 12:13 AM
    I feel there is nothing other than bad decisions and neglect in this case. It such a tragic loss we look for answers in blame and speculation. Let it play out, and I think they will find neglect and child endangerment ONLY in this case. I have years of court room experience. Not looking good for the prosecution.
    Posted by: ANON on Jan 18, 2008 at 12:05 AM
    I HAVE BEEN A PATIENT OF DR. JOHN MERRIFIELD FOR OVER 30 YEARS. I WOULD CONTINUE SEEING HIM TODAY IF POSSIBLE. I WAS SHOWN NOTHING BUT LOVING CARE AND CONCERN WITH THE BIRTHS OF MY CHILDREN AND WILL NEVER BELIEVE HE IS CAPABLE OF LETTING A CHILD BE ABUSED IN SUCH A HORRIBLE WAY. I CAN'T IMAGINE THE HORROR LOGAN WENT THROUGH. I ALSO CAN'T IMAGINE HIS GRANDPARENTS AND OTHER FAMILY MEMBERS STANDING BY AND SEEING THIS CHILD ABUSED. GOD KNOWS WHO IS GUILTY AND WILL PUNISH TO THE FULLEST.
    Posted by: TRACY on Jan 17, 2008 at 11:26 PM
    FREE MIKE!!!
    Posted by: Concerned Mom on Jan 17, 2008 at 11:08 PM
    There will be a special place in hell for all of these monsters that hurt this poor child. I would be ashamed to be this man's attorney
    Posted by: A Mother on Jan 17, 2008 at 10:16 PM
    Who caused the bruises and severe trauma Laura if logan spent so much time with Michael????!!! NONE OF THESE PEOPLE ARE INNOCENT AND NONE OF THEM DESERVE TO SEE THE LIGHT OF DAY EVER AGAIN. THAT POOR BABY SUFFERED AT THE HANDS OF THIS MONSTER, AND HIS MOTHER FAILED HIM. THEY SHOULD ALL ROT WAKE UP!
    Posted by: Jerrica on Jan 17, 2008 at 09:36 PM
    Thanks for the videos, and the continuing coverage of the trial WSAZ, I live in another state and was wondering what happened to the case since back in 2005. I think based on the testimony so far Merrifield is guilty with a capital G.
    Posted by: Nurse on Jan 17, 2008 at 07:57 PM
    for Laura... Wonderful people?????? A doctor who treats a child, places stitches in his scrotum and does not report this is not wonderful nor comptent!!!! He was more concerned about protecting his adult son than a 2 1/2 year old child. Michael does deserve to be found guilty and the only sad thing is that WV no longer carries the death penalty!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
    Posted by: anon on Jan 17, 2008 at 06:09 PM
    I agree with, a mother who protects her children. CPS does nothing. I called for a case to be reviewed and nothing happened. Guess what? That child ended up with burns on his legs because supposedly the bath water was too hot! Not the first time I had seen incidents of this. But CPS failed this child. So blaming CPS does nothing for Logan. It sure won't change how they operate for other children either.
    Posted by: Laura on Jan 17, 2008 at 05:57 PM
    This is in regards to Sandy's comment and the winking and note passing to the camera man. The camera man knows Michael and he was the one who made the first gesture the on the first day of the trial. It was the second day when Michael sent him a note and it was during a recess not during the trial. I know this because I was there and saw the whole incident. So what, he was saying hi to a friend.
    Posted by: a mother who protects her children on Jan 17, 2008 at 04:56 PM
    CPS........could someone please tell me who came up with this so called service???.They serve no purpose,they do not protect kids.They are people just sitting there collecting a check while kids are being abused and killed.That is why these animals can do what ever they want,no one punishes them.The kids are defenseless they have to take whatever treatment is given them.Just because people can give birth to an innocent baby does not mean they can treat them how they want.I wish someone could tell me where to start to stop this insanity.I just don't know where to start.Why would they even let these animals be heard in court?? Who listened to Logan? Who gave him rights?? NO ONE CARED!!!!!!!!!!!!!
    Posted by: Laura on Jan 17, 2008 at 04:28 PM
    I agree with Tracy. You people passing judgement haven't been in the court room to hear the defesene questions. I do have a child. I did hear the nurses testimony. He had bruises. I am praying that Michael does come out innocent. Putting an innocment man in jail is not justice for Logan. Everybody, especially the media had Michael convicted before he even had a trial. What kind of justice is that? If you all would think-Pepper only changed her story and opinion after the plea bargin to save her own behind. As for Michael's parents-thety did not covery anything up. These are wonderful people. I just pray none of you have to go through anything like this at all. You may think differently if you do.
    Posted by: Bobbie on Jan 17, 2008 at 04:02 PM
    Pepper and Michael are the responsible ones. Pepper especially. She had to know what was going on and did nothing. As a mother I don't know how this is even concievable.I have known Dr. Merrifield for 40 years and have never known a more kind or more gentle man. I am sure the pain of this is almost more than he and his wife can bear and they will have to live with it the rest of their lives. We weren't there, we weren't in their shoes, we may think or hope we would know what we would do. But the fact remains that until we are in that situation we DO NOT KNOW what we would do. People should stop playing god and leave it in His hands.
    Posted by: Anon on Jan 17, 2008 at 12:33 PM
    Considering that little Logan also spent lots of time with Dr. Merrifield and he was covering up injuries has anyone ever suspected him as being one of the "abusers" as well???
    Posted by: Friend of Logans on Jan 17, 2008 at 12:32 PM
    From what I understand from family is that Pepper kept Logan from anyone that she thought would report abuse. Inculding Logan's father,grandparents,and all other friends and family. That tells me that she new what was going on. I also belive that CPS was trying investigate Pepper and Mike. So someone did reprot the abuse.They weren't able to find them to investigate. I belive that is how Diane Merrifield became involved. She was hiding her son from CPS. I know that Logan has lots of family and friends that would have protected him, if they had only known what was going on.It also pains me hear them say that Jeremey was not a good father to Logan.Pepper made it impossible for anyone in the Goodall family to be apart of Logans life after she met Mike. I think the laws for fathers who are not married to the childs mother should be changed.It is my understanding that Pepper had total custody of Logan because she was not married to Jeremey. Joint custody may helped save Logan!!!!
    Posted by: Anon on Jan 17, 2008 at 12:29 PM
    Pepper should have the same jail term as Michael .. she knew exactly what was going on .. drugs or not .. and if she were driving while under the influence of drugs, and killed a child or anyone, she would be in jail. This was her baby, and she let the torture continue until that beautiful baby died. She admitted to lying before taking the plea .. why cant prosecutors tell her they lied about giving her the deal and since her story changed, theirs has also changed. She should be in prison for the rest of her life .. and most definitely not be allowed to reproduce again.
    Posted by: a loving mother on Jan 17, 2008 at 09:41 AM
    I disagree with Tracy. If Michael Merrifield was not guilty, then why did his parents try to cover it up. He is guilty and if you listen to the video testimonies posted on this website, you will see that he is guilty.
    Posted by: lea on Jan 17, 2008 at 09:40 AM
    Tracey must be stupid to make such a comment.I think CPS needs to pay more attention to cases that are called in. I hope this opens up eyes but it probably wont children are not protected.
    Posted by: lea on Jan 17, 2008 at 09:07 AM
    As a grandmother I can PROMISE that baby would have been out of that house and out of the country if need be the 1st TIME I SAW bruises and cuts!!!!
    Posted by: Angry Mom on Jan 17, 2008 at 08:30 AM
    For Tracy, if Merrifield comes out not guilty then there will be no justice for Logan!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! He is as guilty as guilty can be, and will never be punished as he should be. And Tracy do you have children??????? Did you even listen to what the nurses and EMS staff had to say??? Or are you really just that stupid?
    Posted by: rainbow on Jan 17, 2008 at 06:02 AM
    well I hope they all suffer like this poor innocent child did I hope everyone involved has problems sleeping, maybe the one good thing that will come out of this is Pepper will come clean of her drug habits, since she is behind bars! R.I.P. little Logan!
    Posted by: Anthony on Jan 17, 2008 at 05:25 AM
    Is Pepper Eren locked up right now?
    Posted by: Parent of an abused child on Jan 17, 2008 at 12:15 AM
    I think they all need to rot.. I don't think the child would have got any more attention if it would have been turned into CPS unless the CPS there is better and more careing then in Mingo Co. I reported abuse of my daughter in Dec.of 06 and so did her doctor and my child had an injury to her bottom which indicated sexual assult to me, my wife and the childs doctor once cps was called by the doctor they took my child from me for 5 days and placed her with one of my family members and went out to the mothers home and did a home inspection and sent my daughter right back in the same situation. I was not concerned about her home I wanted to know and to this day want to know what happined to my daughter. When I finally go in touch with the investigating CPS worker he was unaware of my daughter having any injury or that is what he told me but yet the childs doctor was the one who called cps when my wife and I told her how the child was acting so my heart goes out to Logan and His bio-father.
    Posted by: tonya on Jan 16, 2008 at 11:25 PM
    I TOTALLY agree with CHARLIE AND FRAN! This makes me sick. He is guilty,the mom is guilty and the doctor is GUILTY. That child depended on those people for his life and they all were responsible for his death.
    Posted by: NEV on Jan 16, 2008 at 10:17 PM
    Why is the focus on Pepper? She is on the one on trial here. She has openly admitted that she had a drug problem and that she should have paid more attention, and she has taken accountability and is serving her time. Isn't it bad enough that she has to live with that everyday? You all need to focus on the monster on trial here - that would be michael merryfield, and his parents as well for covering up the horrendous things that he did to that poor child. Dr. Merryfield was a licensed professional who definitley knew what was going on, so in my eyes he is just as sick as his son is and should get the same punishment that he does, which should be LIFE WITHOUT PAROLE. Pepper is doing her time and lives a nightmare evryday, i'm sure. Leave her alone!
    Posted by: Charlie on Jan 16, 2008 at 10:10 PM
    I have seen this story several times & I saw it on the news when it happened but I have avoided reading it because I cant think about this little child without bringing me to tears.This is the saddest thing this cruel world has to offer.I did not know him but I did not have to meet him to know what a sweet little innocent child is like.Then after reading this my thoughts turn to anger.I can't think of a good enough punishment for the person or persons responsible so just bring back the days of public hangings so we can all watch justice being served.And if we catch anyone else doing this they will meet the same fate...............God bless his little heart I know you have him now.
    Posted by: Fran on Jan 16, 2008 at 08:42 PM
    I find it very hard to believe that a mother who is bathing her child, changing his clothes etc would not notice or be concerned with numerous bruises, cuts and burns. I think most parents know how their child has gotten their injury. Pepper knew what was going on and just did not care. The drugs were the most important thing to her. She is equally responsible and I can not believe she only received 1 to 10 yrs. That really makes me sick. I don't understand women who seem to think they need to let their boyfriend or new husband abuse their child in order to keep him. Are women that desparate to have a man in their life? I hope Merrifield will receive life in prison. I also hope his father will lose his medical license and that he and his wife receive some jail time for not reporting the abuse and for not helping that helpless child. This whole case make me sick to my stomach.
    Posted by: Tracy on Jan 16, 2008 at 08:12 PM
    I think everybody needs to see the outcome of the trial before anybody makes any comments. In my eyes merrifield will come out not guilty.
    Posted by: Sadden on Jan 16, 2008 at 07:19 PM
    Again do not think th inmates will do the system's dirty work. It is not happening like in the past. The system have cracked down on inmate assaults regardless of the reason.Look at them do they look as if they have been bangled in jailed? Neither she nor he deserve to ever see this side of a penal fence- not even for medical care. Put a bandaid on the site and life goes on...and that might be too much for either of them.
    Posted by: rainbow on Jan 16, 2008 at 07:09 PM
    this is for ASHLEY..... have you re thought your statement? IF a MOTHER does not protect her child then who is??? Wake up and smell the coffee!
    Posted by: Rebecca on Jan 16, 2008 at 06:21 PM
    Ashley. I think you may have an UNinformed opinion. If you read the testimony of Pepper Eren herself you'll see that even she now realizes that she failed her child. She was a drug addict who put everything before her child.
    Posted by: Concerned citizen on Jan 16, 2008 at 05:33 PM
    I live in another part of the country and I have been following this story for over a year now. I appreciate WSAZ making this coverage available online as I have no other way of reviewing the case. I find it interesting that in testimony Robert Eren said after his daughter became involved with Michael Merrifield, the child seemed to have more injuries than a typical toddler. He was quoted saying "I felt that he had accidents more than he ever did when he was with us," Eren said. "More than you'd think a child should have." Eren told the jury he specifically noted two bruises on the child's cheeks, bruises up and down his spinal cord, burns on his back, buttocks and heels and stitches on his scrotum. In a post below by: someone who knows (hmmm could this be Melissa Eren) indicates Logan wasn't around them much after Pepper met Merrifield. If so, how can Robert Eren's testimony be true and to top it off the Eren's never reported it. Both families should be considered responsible.
    Posted by: a loving mother on Jan 16, 2008 at 04:14 PM
    I just can't believe all of these people knew he had injuries and burns and did nothing about it. I don't know of any way that a toddler could "accidentally" have burns and blister on his bottom. This is just tragic and ridiculous. I hope he gets the punishment he deserves. I can't imagine the pain and suffering of that Little baby suffered. I know Logan is an angel in heaven now and will suffer no more. I hope everyone involved suffers a lifetime in prison for this
    Posted by: Megan on Jan 16, 2008 at 03:42 PM
    As I look at the sweet innocent face of Logan I wonder to myself...How could a human being be so very vicious. I cannot imagine what this child was going through. As for his mother...(being a mother of 2 small children) how could Pepper not know that something was going on!?! Neither Mike nor Pepper should EVER be allowed to have children. I think that they should live the rest of their lives with the memory of Logan fresh in their memory....they should be reminded daily what they put a CHILD through. Shame! Shame!
    Posted by: Rebecca on Jan 16, 2008 at 02:38 PM
    Yes Sick. Bravo to the prosecutors, law enforcement, medical personnel and everyone else who has worked to bring justice for Logan. However, I don't mind Merrifield's photo being up here. Photos of him and his type should be put up everywhere to SHAME them and so that we can protect our children from them. I agree though that looking at him makes me want to puke.
    Posted by: Ashley on Jan 16, 2008 at 02:35 PM
    I think its wrong to make the mother sit behind bars while the one that did the crime is out free. I dont see how its her fault when she was not aware of what was going on behind her back. The laws today and the people that enforce them are wack and something needs to be down. My prayers out with this young lady. I cant imangine what she is going threw.
    Posted by: Sick on Jan 16, 2008 at 01:50 PM
    WSAZ please remove his photo from your website. It makes me sick everytime I see him. You should replace it with the good guys like the prosecuting attorney.
    Posted by: Rebecca on Jan 16, 2008 at 12:27 PM
    Cases like this are why WVians should have the right to vote for the death penalty to be reinstated. Most of the people I know not only believe in the death penalty, but would also volunteer to administer it!!!
    Posted by: Rebecca on Jan 16, 2008 at 12:24 PM
    THANK YOU WSAZ!!! I really appreciate how you are covering this case. A case like this deserves the attention you are providing.
    Posted by: Natalie on Jan 16, 2008 at 11:37 AM
    I have been following this for quite some time now. I really feel for poor little Logan. He is now in a better place. Not only is Michael responsible for this, but his mother should be punished just the same way. And her family should of said something to authorities if they felt he was being abused. How could a mother take a lesser plea to get herself off from a crime? She had to of known what was going on and should of stopped it. But she said herself she did drugs, which in most all cases drugs come before family. To know my son died because I made the decision to live with a man who abused him would kill me. I would not want to live in society. But she gets the lesser plea and will be out walking the streets for another set of drugs soon. Her son is paying for her freedom. She should of stepped up to the plate and been a mother. No decent mother would allow her child to live in that situation. Don't worry WV she will have more when she gets out.
    Posted by: concerned on Jan 16, 2008 at 09:23 AM
    How could anyone treat an innocent child this way? I would not even treat an animal in such a horrid manner. I pray that these people will be imprisoned for life. If they do not pay for this gruesome crime in this life, God will definitley be swift and furious with his punishment. Is this what we call human beings? In my opinion, they are not worthy of that name, they are barbarians. I only wish this would have never happened. That poor child. He is resting in God's arms now.
    Posted by: reader on Jan 16, 2008 at 08:57 AM
    is this so called "man" still a doctor? i have heard of spoiling kids, but, letting them do this unspeakable crime just to keep his son happy, is insane. i sure hope to God that his medical license will be taken away FOREVER
    Posted by: West Virginians Against Abuse on Jan 16, 2008 at 07:27 AM
    Let's clear something up - Amy Anderson is NOT a member of West Virginians Against Abuse. She worked with us to get Logan's Law passed, but has not worked in any other capacity with us. Families often participate when we are calling for justice for victims. As far as the Eren family not reporting the abuse, - their only fault is that they BELIEVED their family doctor (Dr. Merrifield) when he treated Logan and assured them that Logan was going to be okay. Furthermore, regarding the incident where Mike Merrfield winked and sent note to Channel 3 camera man - several people in the court saw this happen.
    Posted by: ??? on Jan 16, 2008 at 04:02 AM
    JIM AND SANDY..WHERE DO YOU GET THIS INFORMATION??? AND IF IT IS TRUE, I THINK WSAZ SHOULD BE ABLE TO EXPLAIN IT...AND SHOULD DO SO.
    Posted by: For: INOCENT VICTIMS on Jan 16, 2008 at 12:38 AM
    Why didn't Doctor Merrifield and his wife,the PARENTS of Micheal Merrifield and the COUSIN Amy Anderson who is ACTIVE in West Virginians Aganist Abuse REPORT THIS! Does Amy Anderson who is said to be ACTIVE in West Virginians Aganist ABUSE, work with Abused Children? Where was CPS?Little Logans Severe Wounds were healing but Happy? Dr. Merrifield must have known being a DR. Again where was CPS! Did the real FATHER make a STATEMENT once that he tried to tell CPS Several TIMES? What a SYSTEM!COVERUP & LIES!ALL OF THESE PEOPLE ARE TO BLAME FOR THEIR PART IN IT,THE ONES WHO DID IT should get Life in PRISON and NEVER let out.This Child was another INOCENT VICTIM of a VIOLENT CRIME! POLICE should go afer these People who KILL & Severely Injure Inocent Victims,who Die or LIVE.Life as they knew,is GONE FOREVER! GIVE the TRASH LIFE IN PRISON with NOTHING!THESE VICTIMS HAS NO LIFE,IF THE SEVERELY INJURED LIVES FOR A WHILE or YEARS Needing 24 HR.CARE MOST GET VERY POOR MEDICAL CARE UNFAIR!!!
    Posted by: timbo on Jan 16, 2008 at 12:07 AM
    I can't believe somebody would do such a thing. This is why west virginia should implement the death penalty
    Posted by: Chuck on Jan 15, 2008 at 11:46 PM
    I'm the paternal Grandfather of Logan Shane Goodall. I agree with what most have said here. Just for the record Logan was hid from the Goodall side of his family the last 2 months of his life. My guess is to protect Pepper and Mike from being arrested. Had I seen Logan with bruises much less burns I would've called the State Police immediately!! Logan's favorite song was Jesus Loves Me. And I know he's happy with God right now and God will repay vengence is his! Chuck Goodall
    Posted by: someone who knows on Jan 15, 2008 at 10:53 PM
    Okay all of you people that are blaming Logans extended family and saying they are responsible have no clue. How dare you blame a loving family who loved him so much. You werent around the family and have no clue about what happened so you you should just keep your mouth shut. When Pepper met michael, she started keeping Logan away from her family..They were not around Logan like they used to be. All kids have bruises. Anyone that has kids knows that. If his extended family thought for one moment at the time that logan was being abused they would have reported it in a heartbeat. So unless you know this family or what really happened, I think you should mind your own business and pray that you never find yourself in this position.
    Posted by: Niki on Jan 15, 2008 at 09:47 PM
    I have been following this case with interest since Dr. Merrifield was my physician 30 years ago when I lived in WV.I am appalled at what I am reading-a child so badly abused that he died. Where were the adults in his life other than Michael and Pepper? Where were his grandparents, cousins, aunts, uncles, etc? Say what she will, Pepper's mother is just to blame as the rest-let me see horrible burns and bruises on one of my grandchildren, and no matter how much I love my children, I would immediately take the child away and call in the authorities. That poor baby was defenseless, and NO ONE IN THAT FAMILY or circle came to his aid, and he died all alone. I don't know if Michael Merrifield is guilty or not, but Dr. Merrifield certainly is - if he did not suspect that his own son was abusing the child, why in God's name didn't he report the abuse and get the child out of that environment? What kind of parent suspects that their child is doing such and remains silent? Not the doctor I knew.
    Posted by: Sandy on Jan 15, 2008 at 08:07 PM
    Why is a defendant allowed to get away with winking and passing notes to a camera man in the court trial while the trial is going on??? He is being tried for killing Logan Goodall. What is going on with this!!! Who is really in control of this court room?
    Posted by: HOW COULD THEY on Jan 15, 2008 at 07:14 PM
    JUST DON'T KNOW WHAT TO SAY EXCEPT THAT SOMEONE SHOULD HAVE REPORTED THE ABUSE, NOONE DESERVES IT ESPECIALLY A LITTLE ONE
    Posted by: Jim on Jan 15, 2008 at 06:52 PM
    On Day 1 of the trial, Mike Merrifield winked at grinned at the WSAZ cameraman. On day two, Mike sent the WSAZ cameraman a note. What's up with that?
    Posted by: Jerrica on Jan 15, 2008 at 05:57 PM
    This little boy didn't have to die, where were these relatives and extended family when he was being abused? Why didn't they intervene for the child.
    Posted by: Mer on Jan 15, 2008 at 05:43 PM
    Abuse happens more than we will ever know. I think it is a very sad situation, and what I find astonishing is how Dr. Merrifield was Dr. of the year, only in WV. If this happened to my child you would never have to worry about me filing the first charge, I would take the law into my own hands. If anyone is going to lay up in jail and be a mennace to society, eat free, have free clothing, a free education, etc. its sure isnt going to be someone who did this to my child, they would be 6 foot under and I would be the one getting all the free stuff. Its awful what America has come to. People need to wake up and bring the death penalty back, Im tired of the law breakers getting my hard earned money. May Logan Goodall rest in piece and the rest of his family rot in hell, you should have spoken up and did something for this baby.
    Posted by: Lauren on Jan 15, 2008 at 05:25 PM
    Who is Robert and if he knew of these wounds why in the world did he not call someone or do anything?
    Posted by: tonya on Jan 15, 2008 at 05:25 PM
    What a terrible thing to happen to such a beautiful baby.It makes me sick that people are given the chance to be parents and thisis what they do.From all of ous couples who would love to have a baby.....SHAME ON YOU1111
    Posted by: rainbow on Jan 15, 2008 at 05:12 PM
    Well I must give my thoughts on this matter, I think whom ever saw this child was abused and DID not report it well then in my eyes they are guilty and played a part in this childs death, and if it was reported and the CPS did not help then they also should be held accountable, In time each person involved will get paid back, if you know of abuse and do not report it then you are GUILTY if that child dies!!!! Think people open your eyes!
    Posted by: a loving mother on Jan 15, 2008 at 03:32 PM
    I think WSAZ is doing a great job keeping us informed on what is going on during the trial. I am very interested in the trial and I hope justice is served for Logan.
    Posted by: Anon on Jan 15, 2008 at 01:51 PM
    Since when is a journalist sitting in a courtroom considered an embedded journalist? This story is sad and horrible enough without WSAZ adding any more drama and flare. Just give us the news!!!!
    Posted by: Waiting for Justice on Jan 15, 2008 at 01:09 PM
    I blame both Pepper and Michael Merrifield equally for what happened to little Logan. The abuse that sweet little boy suffered is almost beyond belief and both of them are responsible. Hopefully, justice will prevail.
    Posted by: Shelia on Jan 15, 2008 at 12:33 PM
    I would like for someone to do exactly what he done to that precious little boy...As far as i am concern they should meaning everyone from his mom, her boy friend and those who covered it up about knowing what was going on and not coming forth when they knew about it, should all get the death penalty, because Logan could not help himself..Thank god that he is not suffering anymore...
    Posted by: dumbfounded on Jan 15, 2008 at 11:45 AM
    why didn't any other people notice the abuse and turn it in? If the cousin said he looked yellow a month before, why didn't she or anyone else see the abuse? Someone should have noticed and turned them in. Now look what happened because no one did their duty. I'm so glad God has you in His hands where you are happy and safe. I didn't know you, Logan, but I sure do love you. Poor little thing.
    Posted by: a loving mother on Jan 15, 2008 at 08:36 AM
    i'm sure he will get the death penalty from the other prisoners. Rest in peace, little angel Logan.
    Posted by: grace on Jan 15, 2008 at 06:14 AM
    I hope, no I know God will punish you swiftly and severly michael merrifield and your dad too for helping you. I wish west virginia had the death penalty then maybe people like you would think twice before doing what you do
    Posted by: Sandy on Jan 14, 2008 at 10:06 PM
    That beautiful little boy is in Heaven now. It is a true shame the way he was done what little bit of time he had here. I pray the mother, father, grandmother and grandfather pay their life for what they ALL did to that little guy. I don't understand the grandmother, I'm a grandma and i would be the first to see something wrong,better still, i would be the first to take a board to my children if i even thought they were abusing my grandbaby!! It's a good thing i'm not on their jury...
    Posted by: reader on Jan 14, 2008 at 09:58 PM
    rot in jail? you got to be kidding, right? daddy helped him out by hiding the truth, what's to stop daddy from buying all three of their way out now?
    Posted by: melissa on Jan 14, 2008 at 09:21 PM
    Micheal Kent Merrifield is a liar, and should be locked up for the rest of his sorry life.
    Posted by: jessica on Jan 14, 2008 at 07:59 PM
    this is a sick,sick thing and one to ten is not enough she should get life ,they all should .they took advantage of this poor BABY they should get the electric chair or worse.
    Posted by: Jessica on Jan 14, 2008 at 06:18 PM
    It is just me but I think that this guy should be turned over to Logans grandparents and let them do what ever they want with him.If it was my kids who he did that to I would have the same things done to him and he would never have the chance to hurt another kid agian
    Posted by: Jessica on Jan 14, 2008 at 02:32 PM
    I hope he rots...I think Pepper Eren should rot too. Any mother who sees the marks and the injuries she saw should be standing right there beside him. She had more responsibility to the well being of that baby than anyone! However, her sentence is less than his will ever be. they should both be tried for Murder. She force fed Little Logan soup before she left for work.
    Posted by: Lauren on Jan 14, 2008 at 01:51 PM
    I hope they all FRY for this. If the justice system fails in this we can all take comfort in knowing that someday they will answer to GOD!!!!!!!! Payback will come for all involved in this disturbing crime!!!!!!
    WSAZ.com Most Popular / Most Comments
    National Headlines - MSNBC.com
    First Warning Hour-By-Hour Forecasts
    + Ashland, KY
    + Athens, OH
    + Beckley, WV
    + Charleston, WV
    + Clarksburg, WV
    + Clay, WV
    + Gallipolis, OH
    + Huntington, WV
    + Ironton, OH
    + Logan, WV
    + Morgantown, WV     		+ Paintsville, KY
    + Parkersburg, WV
    + Pikeville, KY
    + Pomeroy, OH
    + Portsmouth,OH
    + Ripley, WV
    + Spencer, WV
    + Sutton, WV
    + Wayne, WV
    + Wheeling, WV
    + Williamson, WV
    SearchKOW Business of the Day
    WSAZ.com Sponsor Sections & Links
    Healthy Tri-State
    Live a healthier lifestyle in 2009
    SOMC
    Very good things are happening here
    Moms4Moms
    By moms, for moms
    WV Lottery
    Nightly drawings and numbers
    Big Sandy
    For all your furniture and appliance needs