UPDATE: MU Grade Scandal, Perdue Gets Apology Letters
Save Email Print
Bookmark and Share
Updated: 2:28 PM Jan 9, 2011
UPDATE: MU Grade Scandal, Perdue Gets Apology Letters
Apology letters were sent to the daughter of state Treasurer John Perdue after a tentative settlement was reached in a privacy lawsuit she had filed.
Posted: 2:28 PM Jan 9, 2011
Reporter: Carrie Cline; Anna Baxter
Email Address: news@wsaz.com
width:320 and height: 249 and picwidth: 205 and pciheight: 159
Font Size:

UPDATE 1/9/11
HUNTINGTON, W.Va. (AP) -- Apology letters were sent to the daughter of state Treasurer John Perdue after a tentative settlement was reached in a privacy lawsuit she had filed.

Emily Perdue received an $81,250 settlement last year over the lawsuit that claimed Marshall University and a professor violated her privacy by leaking information about her grades.

The Associated Press reported Marshall Senior Vice President F. Layton Cottrill Jr. sent Emily Perdue a letter in late October stating Marshall's regret that the situation caused any hardship to her and her family.

Perdue's former professor, Laura Wyant, also wrote a similar letter.

The AP last week obtained copies of the letters that weren't released at the time of the settlement. It says Perdue declined comment on the letters.



UPDATE 1/28/10
HUNTINGTON, W.Va. (WSAZ) -- Marshall University's Faculty Senate released a report Thursday on the grade change scandal of Emily Perdue, daughter of West Virginia State Treasurer John Perdue.

Faculty senate said Perdue completed all of her work with no parental influence. They also said there was no improper behavior by her parents.

Faculty senate did admit to a mistake in communication and pointed to the number of independent study hours as a problem.



UPDATE from 6pm
CHARLESTON, W.Va. (WSAZ) -- West Virginia's state treasurer finally broke his silence about the Marshall University grade change controversy involving his daughter.

It was a day of vindication Tuesday for John Perdue. The federal investigation is over, and he has been cleared of any wrongdoing. After all this time of sitting silent, he had a lot to get off his chest.

"Let me say this clearly -- I did nothing wrong except be a dad," Perdue said.

That's how Perdue started his news conference Tuesday morning. His attorney, Ben Bailey, received a letter earlier last week from the U.S. Attorney's Office saying the investigation regarding the grade change controversy has been concluded and no further action will be taken.

"There was a lot of publicity that was unfair and many jumped to conclusions and were wrong," Bailey said.

The controversy started last spring when Perdue's daughter, Emily, received incompletes for two courses at Marshall University. Her professor, Dr. Laura Wyant, said Emily did not attend class meetings or complete any of the work during the semester.

Then, Perdue and his wife met with the dean on separate occasions. That's when the dean decided to take over supervision of Emily's coursework. Several months later, after Emily turned in the completed work, the dean awarded her A's. A federal investigation was launched, looking into whether Perdue abused his power as an elected official to get his daughter special treatment.

Perdue says during the investigation, his attorney advised him not to speak on the matter. Now that that investigation is over, he had plenty to say.

"No one can understand the stress when a federal prosecutor is looking at you," Perdue said. “I want to know why my daughter’s privacy was violated, for what and by whom."

Those are the questions Perdue wants answered. He says Marshall University is looking into the matter.

Marshall University officials tell us any matter involving personnel is private, and they have no comment about any further investigation.
Perdue said he has not ruled out a run for governor and is highly suspicious this attack was politically motivated.



UPDATE @ 1:30pm
CHARLESTON, W.Va. (WSAZ) -- The West Virginia State Treasurer held a news conference Tuesday to clear his name in the grade controversy concerning his daughter at Marshall University.

The US Attorney's Office for the Southern District of West Virginia has informed John Perdue the investigation into the grade change scandal has been concluded and no further action is being taken against him.

"I have been practicing law for 30 years, and this is the first time that I can recall that the U.S. Attorney's Office has issued a letter like this, said Perdue's Attorney Benjamin Bailey. "I want to thank the U.S. Attorney's Office for realizing that the accusations against Treasurer Perdue and his family were unjustified and false."

Dr. Laura Wyant, Emily Perdue's professor at Marshall, testified last year she gave Emily incompletes in two courses because she failed to do the required work. However, she claims those grades were changed to A's after the dean met with her parents.

A federal grand jury heard the case last year.

Treasurer Perdue said he was pleased to hear the investigation was over.

"No one can really understand, without going through it, the stress an investigation like this puts on a family," Perdue sad. "My family and I would like to thank our family and friends who called to express their support during the last few months."

According to a news release, Perdue said he had no doubt that when all of the evidence was reviewed; he and his family would be cleared of all accusations.

"I am a public official and proud of my record as State Treasurer, and I understand that I am open to criticism," Perdue. "However, my daughter is not a public official and did not deserve the treatment she received from just about everyone involved in this."

Perdue tells WSAZ.com he was concerned that his daughter's privacy rights were violated when her name was released to the public.



ORIGINAL STORY
CHARLESTON, W.Va. (WSAZ) -- West Virginia's State Treasurer plans to break his silence on the grade controversy concerning his daughter at Marshall University.

According to a spokesperson, John Perdue plans to discuss the situation during a news conference at 1:00 p.m. Tuesday in the Governor's Press Conference Room at the West Virginia State Capitol.

Dr. Laura Wyant, Emily Perdue's professor at Marshall, testified last year she gave Emily incompletes in two courses because she failed to do the required work. However, she claims those grades were changed to A's after the dean met with her parents.

A federal grand jury heard the case and as far as we know, nothing has come out of that. We also haven't heard if the investigation is closed.

WSAZ will have a crew at the news conference. Keep clicking on WSAZ.com for the very latest information.

[ Copyright 2010 – WSAZ.com. All Rights Reserved. ]
This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.
Severe Weather and Breaking News Coverage

To send a news tip or submit a story idea, e-mail news@wsaz.com


Latest Comments

Posted by: fac2 on Jan 14, 2011 at 01:59 PM

Fac should know that incompletes are only issued for students who have completed most of the coursework,e.g. they need to finish a paper or take a final. By all accounts, Emily Perdue did not come to class and did not do ANY of the coursework, so she was NOT entitled to an incomplete. Marshall's President, Provost, College of Education Dean and lawyer caved in on giving her an undeserved A and a lucrative settlement to avoid a baseless suit. How the Heather Bresch incident was handled makes WVU look mighty good compared with Marshall, but so does everything else there. I think MU is overdue for a new president, provost, collection of deans and lawyer, as well as a new board of governors which will make better decisions on selecting a president. No doubt, MU will scapegoat Laura Wyant, the only person with integrity in this whole affair. In the future, perhaps we should just give every Marshall student an A to avoid the possibility of a costly frivolous lawsuit.
Posted by: fac on Jan 10, 2011 at 02:52 PM

Um…for those of you who can’t read, the article states that after turning in the coursework, she received her grades. I have given students incompletes, and when they complete the required coursework, their grades are changed. There’s nothing dubious about it. It sounds like the Perdue’s are moving on...you should, too.
Posted by: Mike on Jan 10, 2011 at 02:23 PM

So now she'll be driving a nice new car paid for by the tuition of other students and taxpayers of West Virginia because a professor changed her grade and admitted it??? We have too many lawyers in the this state with too much time on their hands. No wonder we are last in so many things.....except lawsuits.
Live Feed Now on the Always On Channel
Click here to send us your pictures and video pix@wsaz.com
WSAZ.com Sponsor Sections & Links
SOMC-Very good things are happening here SOMC
Very good things are happening here. Click here to learn more
Click here for closing and delays
Click here for school closings and delays
West Virginia Lottery nightly @ 6:59pm on WSAZ click here for numbers and drawings
Watch the Lottery Live Monday - Saturday @ 6:59pm on WSAZ NewsChannel 3. Need to check your numbers? Click here.
Ohio Lottery
Watch the Ohio Lottery Drawings weeknights @ 7:29pm and Cash Explosion Saturday @ 7:30pm on WSAZ NewsChannel 3.
WSAZ Children's Charitable Foundation
Click here to donate and help WSAZ help children at risk in our region. Thank you.
Making Moms LIfe Easier - with Diane Dimoff
Click here to see how our partners are making Moms and women's lives easier.