Kanawha County Official: Bayer's Response to 911 was "Unacceptable"
Kanawha County Official: Bayer's Response to 911 was "Unacceptable" Save Email Print
Posted: 4:25 AM Sep 5, 2008
Last Updated: 9:45 PM Sep 6, 2008
Reporter: Mike Waterhouse and Amanda Barren
Email Address: mike.waterhouse@wsaz.com; amanda.barren@wsaz.com


A | A | A

Update: Friday 9/5 @ 6 p.m.

INSTITUTE, W.Va. (WSAZ) -- When it comes to the explosion at the Bayer CropScience plant, there are still more questions than answers.

A spokesperson for the company said they will sit down with metro 911 next week to talk about what worked and what didn't. But county leaders have made it clear that there was a massive communication failure.

WSAZ obtained a letter from the county to Bayer on Friday, claiming that Bayer told emergency crews from all over the western part of the county nothing in the crucial moments following last week's explosion.

Kanawha County Commission President Kent Carper said 12 pages of transcripts show Bayer gave little information.

On Friday, Bayer said, "We believe we established the correct communications with metro 911." Site manager Nick Crosby, however, won't give any specifics.

Carper called it a "complete abdication of Bayer’s responsibility to your neighbors and our first responders." Crosby said he is "somewhat surprised to see his (Carper’s) words and will take them into account."

Given several chances, Crosby would only say they established correct communications. He would not answer who they talked with at metro, who called from his plant or even why a guard was tying up an emergency line to give out information they claim they were giving off a recorded line.

One thing Bayer already has said it has learned is that there has clearly been a change in the public’s expectations of communications in these incidents.


UPDATE: Friday 9/5 @ 11:25am
Kanawha County Commission President Kent Carper sent a letter dated September 4 to Bayer Plant Manager Nick Crosby, criticizing the plant's communication with Metro 911.

In the letter, Carper says Metro 911 "repeatedly asked for information and was refused." He adds that the company did not provide information to the public in a timely manner.

"This was a complete abdication of Bayer's responsibility to your neighbors and our first responders, who were sent uninformed to an explosion because no one was 'allowed' to inform us," wrote Carper.

Carper included the transcripts of the 911 calls made to/from Metro 911 the night of the explosion.

[ click here to read Commissioner Carper's letter to Bayer ]

Bayer issued a response to these calls. Scroll down below the timeline to read the company's statement.



UPDATE: Friday Morning 9/5
WSAZ.com has compiled a timeline of events the night of the explosion. The information for the chart comes from Metro 911 records and electronic communications WSAZ.com received the night of the emergency.

[ click here to read the transcript provided by Metro 911 ]


10:33 PM
thursday 8.28
First call to Kanawha County Metro 911 comes in from a resident. County emergency crews are dispatched to the Bayer CropScience Plant in Institute. WSAZ.com obtained recordings of some of the first calls.
10:39 PM
thursday 8.28
Metro 911 tried to contact Bayer via telephone. The phone rings 7 times before a guard at the main gate answers and confirms an emergency at the plant.
10:42 PM
thursday 8.28
Metro tries to contact Bayer again. The phone rings 7 times before the same guard answers and tells the dispatcher an ambulance is needed for a burn patient. The employee says he can't give more information. Police close Route 25.
10:45 PM
thursday 8.28
WSAZ.com confirms the explosion with Metro 911 dispatchers and a story is posted to this site.
11:07 PM
thursday 8.28
WSAZ's crew arrives at the scene and takes the first picture via cell phone and shows it on the air (click on image to enlarge)
11:12 PM
thursday 8.28
WSAZ e-Reporter Johnny Walls of St. Albans captures video of the fire and sends it to the station where it is immediately played on the air.
(click on link to watch the video)
click here to watch the clip (WMV)
11:15 PM
thursday 8.28
A guard at the main gate at Bayer calls 911 and speaks with a supervisor at Metro. He says he has been trying to call, but had trouble getting through. He says Metro should alert the community to an emergency at the plant.
11:32 PM
thursday 8.28
County leaders activate the Emergency Alert System (EAS), prompting a shelter in place for the cities located around the plant. It spans from South Charleston to Nitro.
11:34 PM
thursday 8.28
A guard at the main gate at Bayer calls 911 again and informs the dispatcher that the plant is still in "emergency condition" and the community should remain alerted.
12:06 AM
friday 8.29
A guard at the main gate at Bayer calls 911 and tells the dispatcher the plant remains in an emergency response condition. He says a representative from Bayer is on the way to Metro's EOC.
12:40 AM
friday 8.29
The guard at the main gate at Bayer calls 911 to give an update. He says the plant is still in an emergency response condition.
12:40 AM
friday 8.29
Metro sends out a notification to media organizations advising that the shelter in place remains in effect, and that I-64 is shut down in both directions near Institute.
1:12 AM
friday 8.29
The guard at the main gate at Bayer calls 911 to give another update. He says the plant's response team is "responding to our emergency" and that the plant remains in an emergency response condition.
1:18 AM
friday 8.29
Metro 911 extends the shelter in place warning for the areas surround the Bayer Plant. This includes South Charleston, Dunbar, Jefferson, St. Albans, Nitro, Cross Lanes, and Institute.
1:21 AM
friday 8.29
WSAZ.com contacts West Virginia State Fire Marshal Sterling Lewis. He says there is a possibility of more explosions at the plant. He confirms one person is burned, another missing.
1:40 AM
friday 8.29
Mike Wey, spokesperson for Bayer, holds a news conference. He says the fire is still burning, but it's contained. He also says the chemical involved is a non-toxic waste product.
1:43 AM
friday 8.29
The guard at the main gate at Bayer calls 911 to inform Metro that the plant's emergency team is still responding to the emergency.
2:01 AM
friday 8.29
County leaders cancel the shelter in place warning for western Kanawha County and reopen Interstate 64.
3:01 AM
friday 8.29
The guard at Bayer's main gate calls 911 to inform Metro that their response has "things under control," but that the plant is still in an alarm state.
3:33 AM
friday 8.29
The guard at Bayer's main gate calls 911 and tells the dispatcher that there is still an alarm going on at the plant and their emergency squad is on the scene.
5:50 AM
friday 8.29
The guard at the main gate at Bayer calls 911 and tells the dispatcher that there is an all clear except for the Larvin unit.

[ click here to download one MP3 file containing all of the calls ]



UPDATE @ 5:09pm Thursday 9/4
CHARLESTON, W.Va. (WSAZ) -- Kanawha County officials are criticizing Bayer CropScience for not releasing enough information quickly during the explosion at the Institute plant last week.

On Thursday, Kanawha County Metro 911 released recordings of the calls between Bayer and the 911 center. The recordings start at 10:39 p.m. last Thursday after the explosion happened, and run through 5:50 a.m. Friday morning.

[ click here to read the transcript provided by Metro 911 ]

Call after call, a person who says he's a guard at the front gate at the Bayer Plant tells Metro 911 that there is an emergency at the plant and he hasn't been authorized to release any more information.

"My supervisor informed me to tell you to uh alert the community that there is an emergency uh in the plant right now," said the guard at Bayer.

Commissioner Dave Hardy calls the information provided by Bayer following the blast unacceptable. He says Bayer needed to let Metro know as much as possible so that the county could provide the proper response.

Late Friday, Bayer issued this statement about the recordings:

    "We shared all available information with Metro 911 as that information became available over the course of the incident.

    The transcripts of the calls to Metro 911 which were released today represent only a portion of the communication between Bayer CropScience and emergency response officials during this event.

    A number of other contacts were made over the course of the event to the Office of Emergency Services, indicating the nature of the event and providing more details.

    Further, there were several county and state emergency services representatives present in the Emergency Operations Center (EOC) at the Bayer CropScience Institute site. These personnel had full access to all information pertaining to the incident.

    Also, when requested by Metro 911, we had two people from our site go to the mobile command center and had another liaison dispatched to the Metro 911 Operations Center on Corridor G.

    We fully support and count on the 911 system and, together with the media, we count on them to carry important messages to the public.

    We will continue to work with Metro 911 to improve our information flow. As part of this commitment, we will be actively participating with them in the critique next week."

We are continuing to add more information to this story as we dig through the data and talk with more county and Bayer officials. We will also add the recordings. Keep clicking on WSAZ.com for more information.



SUNDAY UPDATE
The US Chemical Safety and Hazard Investigation Board announced Sunday that it will be on site at Bayer until Friday to investigate the explosion and safety concerns in that area of the plant.

The chairman of the board, John Bresland, says the purpose is to make recommendations to the company, OSHA, the Environmental Protection Agency and the county about what can be done to keep an incident like this from happening again.

They'll examine the accident site and talk to employees and managers at the plant. Their recommendations will not be mandates for the company, but suggestions.

The board will hold public meetings on the findings.

UPDATE @ 1:14pm Saturday
WSAZ.com has obtained some of the first 911 calls to Kanawha County Metro 911 following Thursday's explosion at the Bayer Plant in Institute.

Click here to listen to five calls released by Metro (MP3 / 1.42MB / 4:08)
NOTE: the calls have been edited to remove personal information (names, addresses, phone numbers)



UPDATE @ 12:25pm Saturday
The Kanawha County Commission and the U.S. Chemical Safety and Hazard Investigation Board will hold a news conference about the Institute explosion Sunday at 3:00pm.

Keep clicking on WSAZ.com for the latest information.



UPDATE @ 10:36pm
WSAZ.com has learned that the worker burned during the explosion is Bill Oxley. He was taken to the West Penn Burn Center in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania.



UPDATE @ 7:02pm
We spoke with friends of explosion victim Barry Withrow Friday. Click here to read more about Barry.



UPDATE @ 6:49pm
WSAZ.com has obtained surveillance video that captured the flash and sound of the explosion. The surveillance system is configured to record both video and audio. It was provided by the Moose Lodge on Route 60 in Jefferson.

Click on the link above to watch the video.



UPDATE @ 6:00pm
By WSAZ reporter Amanda Barren
INSTITUTE, W.Va. (WSAZ) -- While the people who work at the Bayer CropScience site are trying to cope with the aftermath of Thursday night's explosion, investigators are trying to figure out what went wrong.

Broken glass and caution tape are two signs that Thursday night’s explosion reached far beyond the confines of the Institute plant.

Jill Oliver of Oliver Oils and Fuels had some glass shattered at her business from the explosion, but knows what she lost can be replaced.

"I hated that that man lost his life," she said Friday, referring to Barry Withrow, the Bayer CropScience employee who was killed. "There is a family that is grieving the loss of a loved one right now."

Investigators said they will thoroughly sift through the scene to determine what happened.

"We will pull this apart with a toothpick and, until we can flush out the real cause of it, we are not going to start that unit again," said Nick Crosby of Bayer CropScience.

The unit is located on the west end of the plant. Crosby said there was no indication of trouble.

"It was running, it was producing product, it was normal," he said. "Things were progressing well."

But in a split second that changed. Flames started shooting at least 100 feet in the air when a chemical residue ignited.

"I know there was some concern about offsite air pollution," Crosby said. "We monitor the pollution, and we found no evidence of any chemicals or injuries or harm to people."

Crosby put things in perspective at a news conference Friday, saying that people are safer working inside their chemical site than they are crossing the road. Investigators from both the state and federal government are now investigating, and the investigation could take several days.



UPDATE @ 5:07pm
Metro 911 says it took 2,859 calls between 10:35pm and 3:00am, most of which dealt with the explosion in Institute. On an average Thursday evening in the same time period, Metro says it takes about 284 calls.

Metro also tells WSAZ.com that for the first time employees can remember, so many 911 calls came into the center that the lines were overloaded, causing some people to get a message saying, "all circuits are busy."

There was also a problem with the information line that Metro 911 set up at its emergency operations center (EOC) for residents to call in and ask questions. County officials tell us some sort of glitch caused only one line to work at one, causing most callers to get a busy signal. A phone technician had the problem repaired by about 3:00 a.m.



UPDATE @ 12:46am
Bayer officials tell WSAZ.com that the explosion happened in the same general area where an explosion happened on August 18, 1993. Two people were killed in that blast on the west end of the campus.

Officials say the 1993 explosion occurred during the initial part of the process, while Thursday night's explosion happened at the end part. They say the company spent millions of dollars to correct the 1993 problem, and will do the same to correct whatever caused the most recent explosion.

WEB EXTRA: watch our coverage of the 1993 explosion. Click on the video links above.



UPDATE @ 11:35am
The U.S. Chemical Safety Board says it is sending a five-member investigation team to the scene of the explosion. They are expected to arrive Friday evening.

According to the news release, the CSB is an independent federal agency charged with investigating industrial chemical accidents.



UPDATE @ 10:46am
From The Associated Press
INSTITUTE, W.Va. (AP) - One worker has been killed and another injured in an explosion and fire at the Bayer CropScience plant in Institute.

Kanawha County Emergency Management Director Dale Petry identified the victim of Thursday night's accident as Barry Withrow, but didn't know his age or hometown. Petry didn't know the name of the injured worker, who was transferred to a Pittsburgh hospital.

State Department of Environmental Protection spokeswoman Kathy Cosco says that the chemical primarily involved in the fire was methyl isobutyl ketone.

Methyl isobutyl ketone, also called MIBK, is used in the production of the insecticide Larvin.

Cosco says the chemical isn't particularly toxic but highly flammable.

The company says air monitoring found no signs of chemical exposure, either on or off site.

Bayer also produces methyl isocyanate -- or MIC -- which killed at least 15,000 people in a leak in Bhopal, India, in 1984. But Petry said that chemical is stored in steel-wrapped underground containers located far from the blast site.

The explosion occurred at about 10:25 p.m. and could be felt miles away. The fire was extinguished at about 2 a.m.

The cause hasn't been determined.



UPDATE @ 7:02am
Bayer Plant officials say the company is "devastated" after an explosion killed one worker, and injured another. They say a vessel ruptured, and the contents inside that vessel caught fire.

Bayer says its last accident at that plant was at least two years ago.

Officials say the shelter in place was issued for precautionary reasons, and no toxic chemicals were released.



UPDATE @ 5:42am
During a live news conference Friday morning, West Virginia Fire Marshal Sterling Lewis Confirmed that one person died, another was burned in an explosion at the Bayer CropScience Plant in Institute Thursday night.



UPDATE @ 4:39am
The missing worker's brother, Chris Withrow, tells WSAZ.com that emergency crews found Barry Withrow dead inside the Bayer CropScience Plant following Thursday night's explosion.

Chris says Barry was from St. Albans and worked at the plant for more than 20 years. Barry was working overtime Thursday night, according to Chris. The last time Chris spoke to Barry was Tuesday night while Barry was at work.



UPDATE @ 2:59am
From The Associated Press:
INSTITUTE, W.Va. (AP) - One worker is missing and a second was injured in an explosion at a Bayer CropScience plant that forced thousands of nearby residents to shelter in place.

Bayer spokesman Mike Wey says the explosion occurred about 10:25 p.m. Thursday. The explosion, which witnesses say sent a fireball hundreds of feet into the air, ignited waste residue in a section of the plant that produces insecticides.

Wey says the injured worker suffered burns and was transferred to a Pittsburgh hospital for treatment. Wey said both workers are senior employees at the plant.

He said a search for the missing worker won't be conducted until the fire is extinguished.

The plant is located about 10 miles west of Charleston.



UPDATE @ 2:09am
Brent Pauley, Kanawha County Manager, tells WSAZ.com that the fire is now completely out at the Bayer CropScience Plant in Institute.

Crews are going to assess the situation before going in to look for the missing worker.



UPDATE @ 2:04am
911 dispatchers tell WSAZ.com that the shelter in place has been lifted for western Kanawha County. Interstate 64 has also re-opened to traffic.



UPDATE @ 1:40am
Mike Wey with Bayer CropScience is holding a news conference right now. He says the fire is still burning at this time, but it is contained to the area where the explosion happened.

Wey confirms that one man was burned and is being taken to a burn center in Pittsburgh. Another worker is still missing. Wey says both have worked with the company for some time.

Wey says a waste product appears to be what exploded. It's a very flammable product. Wey says it was NOT Larvin. He says the product released to the area after the explosion is not toxic.

Eight operators were working in the area where the explosion happened--six of them were in a safe area and were not hurt.



UPDATE @ 1:21am
State Fire Marshal Sterling Lewis tells WSAZ.com that there is the possibility for more explosions at the plant.



UPDATE @ 12:45am
An emergency worker at the scene tells WSAZ.com that one of the chemicals possibly involved is methomyl.



UPDATE @ 12:40am
A Bayer spokesperson is expected to give a statement soon.

Metro 911 says I-64 is closed in both directions near Institute. It's shut down in the west bound lanes at the Dunbar exit--and at the Nitro exit east bound.



UPDATE @ 12:25am
Emergency workers at the scene tell us one person was burned, another is missing.

Right now, there is now word about school Friday.

Anyone wanting more information should call the EOC at Metro 911: (304) 746-8828.



This is the message from the EAS Alert:
THE FOLLOWING MESSAGE IS TRANSMITTED AT THE REQUEST OF THE KANAWHA METRO 911.

DUE TO AN EXPLOSION AT THE BAYER CROP SCIENCE PLANT IN INSTITUTE...A SHELTER IN PLACE HAS BEEN ISSUED BY METRO 911 FOR THE FOLLOWING LOCATIONS...SOUTH CHARLESTON...DUNBAR...JEFFERSON...SAINT ALBANS...NITRO...CROSS LANES...AND INSTITUTE UNTIL FURTHER NOTICE. EMERGENCY OFFICIALS ARE ON THE SCENE.

ALL PERSONS IN THE AFFECTED AREAS SHOULD REMAIN INSIDE THEIR HOMES OR SOME OTHER CLOSED BUILDING. AN OFFICIAL ANNOUNCEMENT WILL INSTRUCT YOU WHEN IT IS SAFE TO LEAVE. TURN ON YOUR LOCAL RADIO OR TV STATIONS FOR ADDITIONAL EMERGENCY DETAILS.



ORIGINAL STORY @ 10:45pm
INSTITUTE, W.Va. (WSAZ) -- 911 dispatchers in Kanawha County are reporting that there has been an explosion at the Bayer Cropscience Plant in Institute.

Reports indicate that fire is shooting into the air from the plant.

911 dispatchers say people should stay in their homes and stay clear of the area.

Route 25 is shut down at this time.

WSAZ has a crew on the way to the scene. Keep clicking on WSAZ.com for more information.

[ Copyright 2009 – WSAZ.com. All Rights Reserved. ]
This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.
Severe Weather and Breaking News Coverage

To send a news tip or submit a story idea, e-mail news@wsaz.com

Click Pictures to Enlarge
More Stories
Day 2: Washburn Baby Death Trial

St. Albans Man to Serve 30 Years for Sexual Abuse

Man Disappears After Leaving for Church

Financial Fitness Can Raise Quality of Life

Flags to be Lowered for W.Va. Soldier

Charleston Man Pleads Guilty to Hurricane Katrina Fraud

Humane Officer Suspended Pending Drug Investigation

W.Va. Fares OK in Adult Literacy, but Gaps Persist

Post Your Comments
First Name:
Location:
Enter Comments: characters left
Email (optional):
Email will not be displayed on site. For station contact purpose only.
Read Comments
Comments are posted from viewers like you and do not always reflect the views of this station.
Posted by: get over it on Sep 30, 2008 at 12:10 PM
First of all, I would like to say to the family of the man that was killed in this explosion my prayers are with you. To everyone else, let it go. Why do you want to nit pic the H3!! out of this? Its like you wont be satisfied until somebody says, A harmful chemical was released, the guard really let the phone ring 45 times, and no body really really wanted you to know at all. Let me tell you, the world is still spinning, ur still breathing, quit nit picking and do something constructive!! Some people arent happy until they make a soap opera out of everything

Posted by: DISAGREE ANONYMOUS on Sep 21, 2008 at 07:35 PM
Since you wont list your name I will asume you Work for the Company. YOUR STATEMENT IS FALSE MISLEADING AND TOTALLY INEPT-Posted by: Anonymous on Sep 6, 2008 at 07:09 AM Come on people the reason for the delay in shelter in place was the fact the potenial release wasn't going to accure until the fire was put out. Any potenial realease was being consumed by the fire (all escaping chemicals were being burnt up).-Your an IDIOT-Yes The Chemical may have been consumed by the flames but what about the TOXIC fumes emitted into the atmosphere from this reaction to the flames.Get it straight the company didnt and still dosent want us to know what chemical reaction took place because of the fire. I doubt we will ever know the truth. So Stop adding to the Lies being told by the Company.

Posted by: ND on Sep 11, 2008 at 10:44 PM
Agree with Anonymous Sep 6 709- You are right on! If people only knew what went down the RR tracks everyday they would FREAK! Bayer knew what they were doing. All the information metro just "had to have" was nothing more then nosey information. OBVIOUSLY there was an explosion, OBVIOUSLY there was a fire. It made NO DIFFERENCE to Metro OR THE PUBLIC what unit it was in (not that knowing the chemical name would mean anything to them anyway) or the fact that someone was killed, and someone was injured. When they needed the ambulance they called, and when the needed the Medical Examiner Im sure they called. The guard was just doing what he was told to do but whoever was in charge. But the lesson learned is, that in the future, all media inquires should be directed to the Institute VFD e-reporter team who will have all the latest rumors and cellphone footage.

Posted by: To Bob on Sep 7, 2008 at 04:25 PM
St.Albans is in Kanawha County! Maybe you should look at a map Bob. I know that out right murder is more important but how many other things are?? Stopping an obviously drunk driver should be an important act. You might want to pray that someone you love isn't killed by one of the 100's of wreckless and drunk drivers that 911 is too busy to deal with.

Posted by: Anonymous on Sep 7, 2008 at 04:13 PM
when will you people every learn its always who's buttering your bread sounds like in this case thou cup runing over

Posted by: Ron on Sep 7, 2008 at 11:09 AM
OK, enough of this. Next!

Posted by: Bob on Sep 7, 2008 at 07:24 AM
Bev -- Someone needs to look into the 911 system in "Charleston" yet you didn't call until you were in Putnam & Cabell County? Might want to look at a map there. And 911 has a lot more important things to deal with than the 100's of wreckless and drunk driver calls received every day.

Posted by: Bev on Sep 6, 2008 at 05:50 PM
Yes it should "D"! Somebody needs to check into the 911 system in Charleston. We followed a drunk driver from St.Albans to Ona. We called right before we left St.Albans and the dispatcher was not sympathetic at all. This woman was so drunk she kept running off the road and swerving left of center( Yes she was drunk, we looked her in the face. This was not a medical situation.). It took 30 minutes to get her stopped and it was Cabell County who finally did it. We had to call 4 times from St.Albans to Ona. We passed 2 cops in Milton who just looked the other way. However we looked on the Regional Jail website and we never did see her picture. Did they arrest her or maybe the reason for the delay in stopping her was so she could be in a county of cops who know her?? It remains a mystery right now.

Posted by: D on Sep 6, 2008 at 02:46 PM
OK, enough of this already. Should this still be in your top headline, WSAZ????

Posted by: Anonymous on Sep 6, 2008 at 07:09 AM
Come on people the reason for the delay in shelter in place was the fact the potenial release wasn't going to accure until the fire was put out. Any potenial realease was being consumed by the fire (all escaping chemicals were being burnt up). Is this the real issue here or is it the fact the guard who was only doing as told didn't tell metro that someone got burnt and another had passed away? Just what did Metro have to know? They were fighting a fire and yes there was an Explosion. What realivance was it that it was in the Larvin unit? Did that cause more concern or less, just don't know why that has to be played over and over? Yes I have alot of questions as to why the hype. Concerned about chemicals at the Bayer plant, why people they roll down your streets and back yards everyday and some are as bad as it can get as far as chemicals are concerned and no ones yelling about that.

Posted by: Anonymous on Sep 5, 2008 at 09:38 PM
just a big bunch of exaggerations from a bunch of dumb people. They'll probably sue for getting a bruise on their rear end after getting "blown out of their chairs" What a laugh! Its no wonder people think West Virginia is full of morons. You can shut your mouth and let people think you're dumb, or open your mouth and remove all doubt. KEEP UP THE GOOD WORK!!!

Posted by: WV Resident on Sep 5, 2008 at 04:34 PM
Although I do not live in the Kanawha Valley, I do live near two chemical plants. I was told Tuesday that our community was under a shelter in place and yet I saw no alerts on the TV nor was told anything about it until I picked my kids up from school.It was then I found out that my preschooler had been in shelter in place for 40 minutes with the sixth grade class. I can understand why the people of Institute were so upset by this matter. After reading the 911 transcripts, I think it was very poor judgment on Bayer's part to leave the poor guard as the relay person in this matter. Don't they have someone to handle these situations with the authority to produce the information needed? Sounds like they need to get it together for the sake their employees and our communities!

Posted by: jaf on Sep 5, 2008 at 03:45 PM
Now living in the ral world - I believe bayer did the fastest communication they could under the situation. A part of the chemical process exploded - no more radio contact with 2 men - flames and chemicals in the air - no one is going to put someone out in that so they can pin point EXACTLY what was released and how much. It takes electricity to gather that data on the modern tracking controls to put amounts together for information to the public and agencies. As far as the security guard - he said what he can - with all the lawsuit happy folks - someone like him cannot guess or provide incomplete information. It really could have been worse if it wasn't for the knowledge and care of the staff and the emergency responders.

Posted by: Anonymous on Sep 5, 2008 at 02:30 PM
To anonymous on Sep 1, 2008 at 03:05 AM, How humble of you to say the things about the people that worked for Bayer, when you are one of the unsung heros. I was going to read all of the comments below but now I've changed my mind. Instead, I will thank all of the unsung heros that worked hard that night and every other night to ensure everybodies safety. Y'all do things above and beyond the call of duty, you're amazing. This thanks goes out to everybody that puts there life on the line to save mine in a time of crisis. I too am proud to be an american...

Posted by: RoaneCo. on Sep 5, 2008 at 01:45 PM
Don't you people have more important safety issues to complain about, like me smoking a cigarette at the Moose Lodge!! I don't think these people that called in and said they got knocked out of their dining room chair (from 10 miles away) are more experienced at handling the situation than Bayer.

Posted by: genie on Sep 5, 2008 at 12:56 PM
exactly carl@! they hire very few people and then do not care enough about our people to issue a shelter in place or evacuation until it would have been too late if there HAD been a major leak. It is time for them to accept responsibility for this mess and senseless death. No amount of money could be worth the lives that could have been affected with no one ever knowing until too late.

Posted by: To Nate on Sep 5, 2008 at 12:32 PM
First off you need to know what you are talking about. Just because people are volunteers DOES NOT mean that they are not TRAINED PROFESSIONALS. They have to have all the same classes and training, even HAZMAT (if you know what that means). Had any of these volunteers not had the training they would not be allowed inside the plant, they have rules and regulations too. Besides that, Tyler Mountain and Institute's VOLUNTEER fire Departments put out that fire while the PAID "TRAINED PROFESSIONALS" kept a stand by. And by the way Volunteers do not get their socks off when their pagers go off, they put them on.

Posted by: TimA on Sep 5, 2008 at 11:25 AM
GET them out of here. For so little they offer this community - the risk are far too great. I fear what they cover up and what they have in tanks underground. I would not drink water from either dunbar or institute. Its time for them to take their british butts home, along with their chemical distructions.

Posted by: carl on Sep 5, 2008 at 10:29 AM
these companies come here and hire ten or twenty people,and put thousands at risk. its not worth the risk for just few jobs.

Posted by: sheila on Sep 5, 2008 at 08:32 AM
what happened to the siren that was suppose to go off when they have trouble in the plant.

Posted by: Anonymous on Sep 5, 2008 at 07:41 AM
Did you not see that metro 911 was calling the guard? It says several times that the phone rang 7 times before the guard answered. Not everything is intentional and I am sure they did not mean for this to happen.

Posted by: WV PEOPLE R A JOKE! on Sep 5, 2008 at 07:38 AM
I have never seen such too faced people. No wonder business is taken to other states. When I got the call about shelter in place it was hour and a half, before that my mother called and told me the situation. That night I saw a offical on the television talking about the situation and never mentioned about sheltering in place. People say what a wonderful job taken by the people over the situation that occured. Now its almost a week and you people are harping and complaining what a terrible job that they have done. I think that this company and so many other companys should pack up and get out of town and let people like you complain about the workers getting laid off apply for welfare and medical cards. I would hope that companys look at the situation and think you have 47 other states that would appricate these jobs and take it to them. People know when you live in a area like the CHEMICAL VALLEY thats a part of a chance. Now where are the lawyers standing with there pens and papers.

Posted by: Confused on Sep 5, 2008 at 06:12 AM
So if Bayer was contacting Metro 911 by other means, then why was their guard calling an emergency line to give Metro non-information? Should that guard be held responsible for tying up a non-emergency line during a crisis? Bayer's excuse, er statement, is lacking crucial details like, for example, the truth.

Posted by: Rich on Sep 5, 2008 at 05:34 AM
Dont worry Kent Carper will save us each and everyone Kent Carper to the RESCUE!!!!

Posted by: SA resident2 on Sep 4, 2008 at 10:17 PM
To Michael- No company has the right to endanger lives no matter what!! I was listening to a scanner the from 10:40 to about 12:30am. Metro repeatedly tried to reach company officials at the fire chief request and admitted no one from the company would respond for more than an hour except the security guard. Later when the company rep. finally got there they didn't even have the correct info sheets and fire reps. had to have the correct ones faxed to even verify what the chemicals were more than 1-2hr later. It was a God given miracle no one else died and this VERY IRRESPONSIBLE company was solely to blame. I hope no one takes this as lightly as Michael because there was more. Next time these same BAYER officials are in charge of an emergency in this area I feel confident they will kill us - but of course it won't be their fault!!

Posted by: Nate to "t" and others on Sep 4, 2008 at 09:12 PM
What gives them the right? Because they are trained PROFESSIONALS, not someone that gets their socks off when their little pager goes off. They are PROFESSIONALS who were fighting the fire, and not being a certain news anchors "source", they are trained PROFESSIONALS who were trying to help two of their brothers instead of taking video with cellphones. THATS WHY THEY TRY TO HANDLE IT THEMSELVES AND NOT HAVE VFD INSIDE THE PLANT.

Posted by: Stewart on Sep 4, 2008 at 08:59 PM
Thanks for the excellent footage. I will use it for training purposes at the chemical complex I work at. Many of us in the chemical industry work daily to insure these type of things do not happen. Pray for us.

Posted by: Mark on Sep 4, 2008 at 08:23 PM
t, Chemical plants have highly trained emergency personell that are trained on the chemicals at the plants. There is no one in the community more trained to deal with chemical emergencies than the plant crews. They have full authority to handle their emergencies. The shift supervisor acts as the incident commander and should have made the call in my opinion. Why is my opinion important? I am a chemical engineer who worked in the Methomyl Larvin unit in the mid 90's and now I work for an engineering firm helping the plant out post incident.

Posted by: t on Sep 4, 2008 at 06:30 PM
I read teh transcripts..are you kidding me? What gives the Bayer plant authority to handle their own situation, keep important info from the emergency personnel, and the public? I hope the plant in my home town area are more responsible and open with authorities. Things could have been much worse. And for them to have the poor guard be the go-between so the higher-ups didn't have to answer any questions! Irresponsible and frightening. Can we really trust these big plants with our safety? If they want to live and be in our communties then they should have to have open communication with the authorities and the public in a time of emergency.

Posted by: Michael on Sep 4, 2008 at 06:14 PM
I do not understand why people are so upset about the Bayer incident. If the incident was life threatening to people on the ouside perimiter of the plant they would have notified the 911 center for people to shelter in place. This company means alot to our community and provides alot of jobs. The people of this community need to stop complaining. Every man and woman knows the risk of working in these chemical plants. We need these companys in WV because there are no new companys here.

Posted by: Valley on Sep 3, 2008 at 11:04 AM
I realize that the chemical plants feed most of our Kan Valley economy, but does that give them the right to poison us? Kill us? Where is the Health Dept? Oh yeah, they are busy writing warnings to bars that ignore their smoking ban.

Posted by: SA Res on Sep 3, 2008 at 11:01 AM
The emergency whistle did not go off until ONE HOUR AFTER the explosion. This is totally unacceptable. I was out in the yard inspecting the house when I should have been inside with a shelter in place.

Posted by: T on Sep 2, 2008 at 09:00 PM
I work at one of the chemical plants in the valley. Not once during this incident was I worried. The folks who work in these units are trained professionals...they know what to do. I commend all the responders as well. I live within 2-3 miles of Bayer, and was never concerned. My condolences to the Withrow family, and I hope the other gentleman makes a full recovery. For those of you who are disgruntled at chemical plants, please remember that these plants produce things that make YOUR everyday living possible. If you don't like it, then give up your cars, the paint in your house, let the weeds grow up all around your house...forget about your Nike tennis shoes and the clothes you wear. Forget about the containers that your food is stored in at the grocery stores as well. Go get a goat, a horse, a plow, lots of pigs and cattle and chickens, and a horse drawn carriage...because without the chemical plants, you're gonna need all those items to have a sustainable life!

Posted by: wvmom on Sep 2, 2008 at 02:21 AM
to anon at 3:05.... Thanks for posting that. I'm glad the firefighters were all ok. And it's good to know that the workers were looking out for you guys too! Makes me proud to be a west virginian.

Posted by: Afflicted on Sep 1, 2008 at 08:56 AM
My thoughts and prayers go out to the withrow and oxley families. My wife's father was the one guy to lose his life in a plant explosion when she was a child in another state. So I can still see what effects this has on the families.

Posted by: anonymous on Sep 1, 2008 at 03:05 AM
i was one of the firemen at the scene, n id jus like to send my thanks out to the bayer coorperation...they did an amazing job informing us what we were going into and what to expect and what they thought had happened so we could be more careful. they also took extraordinary steps to make sure that everything was safe in the area...there was people rushing into that plant to make sure everything was safe for the surrunding area and not worrying about themselves, the true heroes are the workers in the plant...and my condolences go out to the family of Mr. Withrow, and i wish the best to Mr. Oxley and his family

Posted by: Anonymous on Sep 1, 2008 at 01:29 AM
what a terrible thing to happen. Be nice.

Posted by: Samantha K on Aug 31, 2008 at 10:12 PM
Seriously guys, shut up! To James, so you woke up. I did to! I was upset that they woke me up but I am not complaining about it. If you want, sue them! I am sure with the lawsuits here in the great state of WV you could prob win in a court of law! Go for it, wait thats a good idea. Maybe I'll sue as well. They shouldnt be working at night. They need to close down shop so that if an accident occurs it will be during the day when most people are awake. Shame on them for blowing the factory up so late at night. James, you may have a point. Remember though, a live was lost.

Posted by: Pam on Aug 31, 2008 at 09:27 PM
We just returned from Barry Withrow's visitation service at our church. There were well over 1,000 people there. Barry was so loved by so many people! This is a huge loss for our church. Please pray for the children at Cross Lanes Baptist Church. They loved Barry and Barry loved them. Continue to pray for the entire family. They really are doing extremely well and guess what they are not blaming ANYONE!!!!

Posted by: Fred on Aug 31, 2008 at 06:48 PM
Yall need to know your role, and shut your mouth.

Posted by: anonymous on Aug 31, 2008 at 05:49 PM
WHY THE SLANDER,WHY THE HATE,WHY A PERSON HAS PASSED AND ANOTHER INJURED BADLY AND ALL PEOPLE CAN DO IS SLAM,AND HATE EACH OTHER AND DOING THE BLAME GAME.BE RESPECTFUL DURING THIS TIME AND LET THE FACTORY CONDUCT IT"S INSPECTION WITHOUT THE SLANDER,CHEMICALS ARE VERY DANGEROUS AND NEED NOT TO BE MESSED WITH AND ACCIDENTS DO HAPPENBUT PLEASE STOP THE BASHING.

Posted by: tony on Aug 31, 2008 at 05:11 PM
has anyone asked if this was near the MIC process or piping,I know that it does run in the pipe rack without any speical protection other than labeled.donot pubish my name.

Posted by: Anonymous on Aug 31, 2008 at 12:56 AM
In response to the post by Henry: I highly doubt that if it weren't for the industry in WV, you would have much of a reason to stay here. In case you forgot, America was made from industry and farming.

Posted by: Friend on Aug 31, 2008 at 12:02 AM
Did you all see the web extra on the top? They have video of when the explosin happened. Someone rude man said "Someone blew the h--- outta something" Such rude people, they didnt even bother to call 911.

Posted by: Sue on Aug 30, 2008 at 11:41 PM
Our thoughts are with the families of Barry Withrow and Bill Oxley. May GOD be with them and give them the strength they will need to get through this.

Posted by: Anonymous on Aug 30, 2008 at 11:40 PM
"Posted by: James on Aug 29, 2008 at 05:28 PM Stupid explosin woke me up last night! I had to get up at 7am. I mean, how am I do get my sleep when people are mixing chemicals and creating explosions late at night. Cant they do this during the day? Had it been me making such a racket I'd be in jail. Next time, be more considerate of others and be quiet during normal sleeping hours. My condolences to the one who died. May the one who was hurt, have a speedy recoverly." that shows how stupid you are if that was planned then no one would of gotten hurt our prayers go out to the families involved with the workers

Posted by: This Person on Aug 30, 2008 at 11:30 PM
Im very sorry and my prayers go to these families.. God Bless

Posted by: Anonymous on Aug 30, 2008 at 09:21 PM
oh get a life Katty. No one cares whose land it used to be. If you don't like it, pack up your cock roaches and get out

Posted by: Henry on Aug 30, 2008 at 07:51 PM
The statement about toxins raining down is true. We were here first and these people pollut our great state!

Posted by: A friend on Aug 30, 2008 at 07:13 PM
Barry was a great man of God and leaves behind a legacy to the many children he worked with at CLBC. We will all miss him, but he would gladly have given his life if it helps even one person understand God's saving grace.

Posted by: Anonymous on Aug 30, 2008 at 06:40 PM
Has anyone heard how the other worker is doing....My prayers go out to both the families and all the workers that were there and their families. This makes you think how dangerous these men and women work in everyday..... God bless you.

Posted by: daughter of a Bayer Plant employee on Aug 30, 2008 at 04:05 PM
my father worked with both of the men that this tragic accident happened to. He had just left the plant a little over an hour before the larvin unit explosion, he was working with both of the men. I had only seen Barry a few times as he was friends with my Uncle and my father. we had a tragedy in our family 5 months ago and then again a week ago and Barry was right there for our family. He was a great man and was very caring for his friends as well as his family as i understand. I have to let the family know that i am very sorry for your loss, my father said Barry was a great man.. to the burn victims family, i hope that things come through for you. and last to the people who make remarks about toxins raining down on you, and stating that we made national news- do you honestly not have a heart to realize that a man LOST HIS LIFE!!! how inconsiderate can you be. My father and uncle left before anything happened but they lost a friend and wonderful co-worker, and i am hurt for them.

Posted by: Daniel from yesterday on Aug 30, 2008 at 05:39 AM
My prayers are with the families of Mr. Withrow and the families of the burned operator in Pittsburg, I hope for a speedy recovery. As for Barry he is worshiping at the foot of Jesus, his Master, his Savior he is at peace. May God bring this peace to all the families involved. Others that are in my prayers are the fire brigade members that worked late into the hours Friday morning trying to get this beast under control. Emergency Responders go in when others are leaving. With the experience of Barry I'm sure he worked with the situation and didn't leave because he thaught he could get it under control. Maybe he had seen similar situations. This accident will be burned into the memories of all those involved, the emergency squad, those who has worked with him and the other injured operator and years later those horrible thoughts will be as fresh as if it happened yesterday. I've been there and live that daily. May God bring pease and comfort to all as only he can.

Posted by: Anonymous on Aug 30, 2008 at 03:28 AM
To anonymous 10:44 thank you very much. Do you know if he was working at that time?

Posted by: Katty on Aug 30, 2008 at 02:48 AM
In response to Stephanie that wrote, "Regarding anonymous WV thanks for rainig toxic material down on me & my family. Theres no place like home...THEN MOVE AWAY NO ONE IS MAKING YOU STAY HERE!" Guess what? Our families were here before the plant was built. Why should they give up their home when they were here first? That area that the plant is on was my great uncle's land. If he had only known what was gonna happen... My condolences to the family of Barry Withrow.

Posted by: BFS anonymous on Aug 30, 2008 at 02:05 AM
The name of the injured one is Bill Oxley. Please keep his family in your prayers. I'm sorry, Chris.

Posted by: To James on Aug 30, 2008 at 12:31 AM
Sir, I understand you were upset. I am glad though that you were considerate enough to send your condilences. Most people on here would rather argue. Someone died and you realized that. Your a class act my friend. People need to read all of the post not the first few sentences. I know people have trouble in WV when it comes to reading.

Posted by: Anonymous on Aug 30, 2008 at 12:14 AM
Please dont complain about how dangerous it is and how you dont like that they house dangerous chemicals that could hurt you. This is how you live... you have used those chemicals in your home. If you worry about MIC move. Its that simple. Pack up your bags quit your job and move. Its that simple. If you dont like something change it dont complain about it. The workers support their families making the products that you use everyday with chemicals some deadly. We all take that chance ourselves living in the valley. We get scared when there is a mishap but dont think about when its over and that we are still alive. They check the tanks and make sure everything is working correctly but there are accidents. No one or nothing is perfect. Expect that in life. If always expect that everything is perfect you have a false reality of life and how things work here on earth. They did a great job under the pressure they were in and I would do anything to thank Bayer for caring about us!!!

Posted by: Anonymous on Aug 30, 2008 at 12:06 AM
To my community...please do not degrade and think of yourself when you say they didnt do it fast enough to suit YOUR wants. When you mother is having a heart attack with you sitting right there...do you pick up the phone and call 100 family members or do you take care of your mother and do what you need to do to save her life then call everyone. They will ask you the questions what caused her to have the heart attack why did she have it what time did she have it where was she when she had it. Same things with the guys last night...explosion. They take care of trying not to make things worse and take care of the injured before it spreads and makes things worse and spreads to other tanks that do house deadly chemicals. They did you a favor as fast as they could and they did a GREAT job. Please stop thinking of your own wants and how it did not suit you. They had a job to do to protect you...but more important THEIR FAMILIES not just YOU!!! Great job guys!!! Thank you!!!!

Posted by: Anonymous on Aug 29, 2008 at 11:58 PM
In defense of all who helped out especially the DOT. As some stated they shouldnt have been concerned with the roads. Think of it this way. In an earth quake does it not damage roads. Same as an explosion. It caused damage to houses and could cause damage to roads. They are only thinking about our safety. Bayer was as well. I am proud to say I live in such a wonderful community who looks out for all of us... the good and the bad. I saw the blast... I felt the blast... and I saw Saint Albans police respond in seconds. Our emergency response teams look out for their community and including the DOT. Please stop and look at the whole picture...including the picture of working at the bayer plant and having tragedy strike. What if that was you??? What if you knew someone there???? What if that was your family???? Praise the workers and the responders they did an amazing job under such stress!!! Community stop acting so negative and thinking of yourself. Think of them!!!!

Posted by: 3rd Shift EMT at a plant. on Aug 29, 2008 at 11:16 PM
James Are you truely that inconsiderate...That was about as selfish as one could get...Next time I'm sure they will check with you before they blow up their plant and someone looses their life. Good God man get a life.

Posted by: Anonymous on Aug 29, 2008 at 10:44 PM
To anonymous at at 7:52 pm, Joseph Stowers was not the name of the worker that was burned.

Posted by: Anonymous on Aug 29, 2008 at 10:29 PM
Wow that video shows just how big it really was. That ought to be on CNN

Posted by: Nate to JAMES on Aug 29, 2008 at 09:55 PM
YOUR AND IDIOT! Guess what?? There were men putting their lives on the line from 1030 last night till late in the evening hours Friday! You think they were thinking about sleep? NO..they were worried about their co-workers and yea you guessed it..thats someones husband, brother, dad, son...Get a life..Im sure you just had to get up to do something useless anyway.

Posted by: Roger & Dana on Aug 29, 2008 at 09:36 PM
Our families became combined many years ago and our hearts are hurting, grieving for the death of Barry! WE pray God's peace, love and hope blanket the entire Withrow Family, your church family and all who have come to know Barry. Don, GiGi, Michael, girls, Aleisha, Bill & family, Chris, Sue & family-we love you and are so very sorry.

Posted by: Sarah on Aug 29, 2008 at 09:32 PM
I woke up to, James! Alot of people did, but you know what, stop complaining! You had to get up at 7am, well I had to get up at 5am! I got no sleep and had to work all day. James, some people (Like I) have it worse then you do so think next time.

Posted by: phyllis on Aug 29, 2008 at 08:48 PM
this accident scared a lot of the people on my street. i was at wal-mart and didn't hear a thing till my grandaughter called me.our prayers are with the families.

Posted by: Meg on Aug 29, 2008 at 08:46 PM
We know the Withrow family and our toughts & prayers go out to his wife, daughters, and family. It's hard to believe he's gone. He's a great father and will be missed on the soccer field.

Posted by: Anonymous on Aug 29, 2008 at 07:52 PM
Does anyone know the name of the person that was burned, does anyone know if Joesph Stowers was working on that night.. May God be with everyone in the plant that night.. It must have been a very trying time... God be with all the families.......

Posted by: Anyomous on Aug 29, 2008 at 07:47 PM
Barry Withrow's daughters go to my school I haven't met either but, please keep that whole family in your prayers

Posted by: to James at 5:28 pm on Aug 29, 2008 at 06:53 PM
Are you serious??? All you care about is whether or not you got enough sleep??? My father and brothers works in this plant and could have been killed. One man was killed and another seriously injured and all you can think about is sleep? Get a life!

Posted by: James on Aug 29, 2008 at 05:28 PM
Stupid explosin woke me up last night! I had to get up at 7am. I mean, how am I do get my sleep when people are mixing chemicals and creating explosions late at night. Cant they do this during the day? Had it been me making such a racket I'd be in jail. Next time, be more considerate of others and be quiet during normal sleeping hours. My condolences to the one who died. May the one who was hurt, have a speedy recoverly.

Posted by: jennifer on Aug 29, 2008 at 05:21 PM
I saw the cnn blurb as it scrolled across the bottom of the screen this morning and called my grandmother who lives just outside the shelter in place area in Scott Depot, WV to find out and to make su