CINCINNATI (AP) - Third baseman Edwin Encarnacion hit one of Cincinnati's three homers off Mike Pelfrey -- then made a throwing error in the 10th inning that helped the New York Mets rally for a 7-5 victory Sunday.

Robinson Cancel opened the 10th with a double off Bill Bray (2-1), his first extra-base hit in the majors since 1999 with Milwaukee. Jose Reyes bunted for a single, and Argenis Reyes then grounded to Encarnacion, who looked Cancel back to third and then tried to start a double play. Instead, he threw the ball into center field, letting in the go-ahead run.

Carlos Delgado finished the rally with a sacrifice fly.

Adam Dunn led off the second inning with a homer. Encarnacion and Brandon Phillips also had solo shots off Pelfrey.